TITLE: MONOCLONAL ANTIBODIES AND IMMUNO-CAPTURE METHOD FOR QUANTITATION AND SPECIATION OF MALARIA PARASITES BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION
Malaria, a protozoan disease transmitted by the Anopheles mosquito, affects millions of people each year and has been characterized as "the most important of all infectious diseases" (Sir Macfarlane Burnet). There are over 200 million cases of malaria annually with the number of clinical cases exceeding 120 million. Approximately 2 million of those cases result in death, the majority of which are infants and young children.
Malaria remains endemic in many countries including Africa, Central America, the Caribbean Islands, South America, Europe, Asia, Indian sub-continent, Eastern Asia and Oceania. The disease is characterized by fever, rigors, anemia, splenomegaly, and chronic relapsing course.
In humans, the disease can be caused by four species of protozoa: Plasmodium vivax, Plasmodium malariae, Plasmodium ovale, and Plasmodium falciparum. These Plasmodia go through a number of morphological changes with multiplication of the organisms in man and in insect vectors. Man is infected by the saliva of a female anopheline mosquito that contains the infective sporozoite form. This sporozoite then enter the liver cells where they multiply. After approximately seven to ten days, multiple small forms break out of the liver cells into the blood and subsequently enter red blood cells. The dormancy of the infection in the liver cells explain relapses in malaria caused by Plasmodium vivax and Plasmodium ovale . While in the red blood cells, the organisms produce multiple infective merozoites. Upon bursting of the erythrocyte, this form can enter new red blood cells. The duration of the cycle is approximately two days for P . vivax, P. ovale, and P. falciparum and three days for P. malariae . This phase of the cycle presents clinically as erythrocytic febrile attacks. Some of these merozoites become sexual forms or gametocytes which when consumed by mosquitoes complete the life cycle.
Most cases of malaria reported in the United States are found in travelers recently exposed to mosquitoes in endemic areas. Additionally, transmission may occur in drug addicts sharing needles and syringes or by blood transfusions. Rarely, infection is cause congenitally or by mosquito transmission from imported cases. Delays often occur in the recognition and treatment of malaria because American physicians fail to consider this latter mode of transmission in their differential diagnosis. Further, physicians also neglect to advise travelers of a need to receive chemoprophylaxis for malaria when traveling to endemic areas.
In addition, over the last twenty years there has been an increasing need to develop new approaches to prevent the spread of malaria. The spread of malaria has been exacerbated by the parasites ' increased resistance to standard antimalarials such as chloroquine, efloquine, and quinine. There is therefore a necessary and real incentive to develop, refine and further format a diagnostic assay for malaria to rapidly and accurately diagnose malaria cases which can also detect drug resistance. Prior art diagnostic tests for malaria involve examination of an appropriately stained blood film. Morphological differences among the plasmodial species infecting humans allows identification in blood smears. Usually, fingertip blood is smeared on a glass slide and stained with Wright's, Giemsa's, or Field stain. A disadvantage to this type of diagnostic test is that thick smears usually contain other unwanted artifacts which can result in inaccurate diagnoses.
Another diagnostic procedure involves the use of thin blood smears. While thin smears are easier to examine, the scarceness of cells in a thin smear increases the likelihood that a diagnosis will be missed. Additionally, because the intensity of parasitemia varies greatly from hour to hour, frequent repeated examinations of thin blood smears may be required which may be prohibitively labor intensive and expensive, especially in endemic areas.
It is know that antiplasmodial antibodies are produced in animals during a malarial infection. For example, using hybridoma technology, Taylor, D.W. et al., Infection Immunity,
32(2) :563-570 (1981), identified monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) to Plasmodium voelii , a rodent malarial parasite. These MAbs identified stage specific, species specific, and cross-reactive antigens. The antigens were found on the surface or within the cytoplasm of the parasite, but not on the surface of erythrocytes from infected animals.
Malarial antigens are also known to appear in the serum of humans infected with P . falciparum. McGregor, I.A., et al., Lancet 1:881-884 (1968). The antigens may be secreted from infected erythrocytes for release during erythrocyte rupture and reinvasion. Winchell, E.J., et al. , Molecular Biochemistry and Paras it o logy 10:287-296 (1984). U.S. Pat. No. 5,001,225 issued to Taylor on March 19, 1991 discloses a hybridoma cell line which secretes a monoclonal antibody which binds to a protein present in Plasmodium which may be used for immunodiagnostic and immunotherapeutic treatment of malarial diseases of man and animals.
It has previously been reported that parasitic LDH (pLDH) can be used as a means of detecting the presence of P. falciparum . Makler et al. 1993, "Measurement of the Lactate Dehydrogenase Activity of Plasmodium falciparum as an Assessment of Parasitemia", Am. J. Trop. Med. Hyg. , 48(2), pp. 205-210. LDH is a metabolic enzyme found within the parasite's cytoplasm and each parasite contains 1-2 nUnits of LDH activity. This method comprises an enzyme assay which measures the ability of Plasmodium LDH (pLDH) to rapidly use 3-acetyl pyridine NAD as a coenzyme in the reaction leading to the formation of pyruvate from lactate. Further, Kaushal, et. al. demonstrated that polyclonal immune monkey serum raised against schizonts of Plasmodium knowlesi (H-strain) showed the presence of antibodies to LDH of P. knowlesi . Kaushal, D.C. et al., "Antibodies to Lactate Dehydrogenase of Plasmodium Knowlesi are Specific to Plasmodium Species", Immunological Investigations , 17:507-516 (1988). Thus far, however, the antigenic properties of pLDH have not been addressed for their potential role in the diagnosis of malaria in humans.
It iβ therefore an objective of the present invention to provide a novel method for the quantitation and/or speciation of malarial parasites.
It is another objective of the present invention to detect Plasmodium lactate hehydrogenase, a marker which can be used to indicate the presence of active, malaria causing parasites in humans.
It iβ a further objective of the present invention to provide monoclonal antibodies which detect the presence of plasmodium LDH which can be used to assay for its presence for purposes of diagnosing malaria.
It iβ yet another objective of the present invention to provide a method of distinguishing pLDH using a series of monoclonal antibodies which may be used in both wet and dry assays.
It iβ still another objective of the present invention to provide a method of diagnosing malaria which is rapid, sensitive, specific, quantitative, and easy to perform..
These and other objectives of the invention will become apparent from the foregoing description.
SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION
This invention discloses an improved method for the detection and quantitation of malarial infection. A series of monoclonal antibodies has been developed that can capture an active metabolic enzyme, specifically Plasmodium lactate dehydrogenase (pLDH). The monoclonal antibodies are specific for Plasmodium LDH and do not cross-react with LDH isoforms present in whole blood of human, bovine, murine, avian, or other primate sources of LDH. The activity of the captured pLDH may then be assayed using standard assay procedures which are well known to those of ordinary skill in the art. Preferably, the pLDH is assayed using the LDH substrate lactate and 3-acetyl pyridine nicotiπamide adenine dinucleotide as specified in U.S. Patent 5,124,141 dated June 23, 1992, the disclosure of which is hereby incorporated by reference. This novel assay method has increased the specificity of the pLDH
assay as recorded in Patent No. 5,124,141 by ten to one hundred fold.
The present invention also encompasses the development of a panel of monoclonal antibodies capable of differentiating LDH isoforms from different species of Plasmodium that infect humans. These species include P . falciparum, P . vivax, P . ovale, and P . malariae . A subset within this panel of monoclonal antibodies can capture pLDH from the human-specific Plasmodium species in the fully active form. Binding competition studies used to epitope map the antibodies show that the monoclonal antibodies bind to sites distinct from one another.
The present invention further involves a test based upon the specificity of the monoclonal antibodies which may be used to differentiate between different species of malaria-causing parasites in humans as well as Plasmodium from murine, avian, and primate sources. Since correct speciation is a critical feature for diagnostic and epidemiological studies of malaria, this new set of tests is extremely useful for the efficient and timely diagnosis of malaria. These tests are based upon the fact that the monoclonal antibodies directed to pLDH are able to capture these active parasitic enzymes from the sample, whether this be hemolyzed red cells, plasma, serum, saliva, or other body fluids. During the capture process, the catalytic site of the pLDH remains enzymatically active, thereby making it possible to detect the captured enzyme by a previously developed and patented diagnostic reagent. The invention includes several enzyme-immuno assay formats which are capable of capturing pLDH from different Plasmodium species.
BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
Figure 1 is a graph demonstrating the column chromatography of pLDH using Cibacron blue sepharose chromatography from culture lysates. pLDH activity (APAD) can be separated from human red blood cell LDH (1st NAD peak) because pLDH binds tightly to Cibracron blue (Column profile).
Figure 2 is an agarose electrophoresis gel in which recombinant pLDH has been stained with NAD+, NBT and PES.
Figure 3 are microtiter plates which have been coated with the MAbs: 6C9a, 6C9b, 17E4, 19G7, and 7G9 which demonstrate that the plates are capable of capturing enzymatically active pLDH from blood samples. Figure 4 is a graph showing the measurement of specific activities (mOD/min) of 7 samples of P. falciparum and 3 samples of P. vivax.
Figure 5 is a graph showing the quantitation of the ICpLDH assay demonstrating the parasitic activity (mOD/ml) plotted as a function of % parasitemia.
Figure 6 shows microtiter wells coated with either the 19G7 monoclonal antibody (pan-specific) or the 17E4 monoclonal antibody (P. falciparum specific). The wells were washed 2 times with PBS and incubated with APAD containing NBT and Diaphorase. Either 100 μls or 5 μls of blood sample were incubated in a coated microtiter well for 30 minutes.
Figure 7 is a graph demonstrating the activity of pLDH as tested in the presence of the anti-pLDH antibodies 6C9a, 7G9, 17E4, and 19G7. A solution of recombinant pLDH was incubated for five minutes with the indicated concentration of antibody ( μg/ml) prior to assay with APAD. Only the 6C9a antibody was inhibitory to the enzyme activity.
Figure 8 visually depicts the activity of the indicated Plasmodium species when incubated in microtiter wells coated with the indicated antibody. The 6C9a antibody recognized all Plasmodium LDH isoforms.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENT
The presence of antibodies to key metabolic enzymes of parasites has been demonstrated in the infected host during certain parasitic infections, but their role has not been critically assessed. Plasmodium lactate dehydrogenase (pLDH) , the terminal enzyme of the glycotic pathway, has been demonstrated in several malarial parasites. This enzyme plays an important role in the regulation of intracellular redox state and thus affects the energy metabolism of these parasites. Although considerable work has been done to study
the kinetic and electrophoretic behavior of Plasmodium LDH, little has been demonstrated about its antigenic nature.
The present invention is directly related to the antigenic nature of pLDH in the development of monoclonal antibodies and an immunocapture method for quantifying and speciating malarial parasites. This invention is thus useful in the diagnosis and detection of malaria in humans caused by the human malarial parasites P. falciparum, P . vivax, P . ovale, and P . malariae . The assay system is based upon the quantitation of previously captured pLDH.
This parasite enzyme assay can detect pLDH produced by all four species of Plasmodium that infect humans, thus making the specific and sensitive measure of pLDH a useful tool for the diagnosis of all forms of malaria. Because the measure of pLDH is quantitative and reflects the presence of viable parasites, such a measure is also useful to quickly test the efficacy of drug treatment for a particular malarial infection, to determine the presence of drug resistance, and to also detect the presence of parasites in blood products. The invention sets forth a unique method which: (1) enhances the sensitivity and specificity of the measurement of pLDH; (2) relates the levels of pLDH whole blood to the percent parasitemia and the severity of the disease; (3) formats an easy to perform, simple to interpret, inexpensive, and quantitative diagnostic test for malaria using whole blood, lysed red blood cells, and plasma- serum; and (4) modifies the immuno-enzyme assay to reformat an in-vitro culture and sensitivity assay to evaluate multiple drug resistance under field conditions.
As such, according to the invention, monoclonal antibodies that specifically react with pLDH have been prepared.
Experiments with these MAbs have shown that they effectively quantify and identify the particular Plasmodium species which the host is infected with. The MAbs of the invention were obtained using methods standard in the art for production of such antibodies.
Numerous studies in the literature have studied the characteristics of Plasmodium LDH. However, the prior art has not yet disclosed a method for producing monoclonal antibodies
directed towards specific Plasmodium species which cause malaria in humans nor do they identify a method of specifically identifying the particular Plasmodium species causing the infection. The invention thus embodies a method for detection of pLDH, a marker of active malaria causing Plasmodium parasites, and a method of diagnosis, therapy, or study of the same by assaying for the presence of pLDH. The presence of the pLDH, may be ascertained by collecting a biological sample which may include serum, plasma, urine, saliva, or other body fluids.
One method involves exploitation of the immunogenicity of the pLDH by developing monoclonal antibodies and immunological quantification. Conventional immunoassays are well known and readily ascertained by those of ordinary skill in the art. A preferred immunoassay uses a specialized detection reagent consisting of 3-acetyl pyridine adenine dinucleotide (APAD) in combination with a selected substrate, such as a lactate salt or lactic acid, and a buffer, as described in U.S. Pat. No. 5,124,141 incorporated herein by reference. The combination of the reagent with a sample of parasite-infected blood catalyzes oxidation of the substrate and simultaneously reduces the APAD. The host LDH has no influence on the APAD.
In the preferred assay, reduced APAD may be detected in numerous ways. For example, the reduced material may be spectrophotometrically detected by observing its characteristic absorption peak at about 363-365 nm, which is distinctive from the absorption spectra of a sample containing unreduced APAD. It is also possible to colorimetrically detect the reduced APAD using a series of chromogens. The chromogens (e.g. tetrazolium salts) react in the presence of the reduced APAD to generate a colored product which is visually detectable. Finally, the reduced APAD is fluorescent, and may be detected using an appropriately configured fluorescent lamp system or fluorometer. Regardless of which detecting method is used, the present invention enables the rapid and accurate detection of malaria-infected blood in a manner not previously known in the art.
Monoclonal antibodies are prepared by recovering spleen cells from immunized animals and immortalizing the cells in conventional fashion, e.g., by fusion with myeloma cells or by Epstein-Barr virus transformation in screening for clones expressing the desired antibody. The hybridoma technique described originally by Koehler and Milstein, jϊur. J. Immunol . , 6:511 (1976) and also described by Hammerling et al., in "Monoclonal Antibodies and T-Cell Hybridomas", Elsevier, New York, pp. 563-681 (1981) have been widely applied to produce hybrid cell lines that secrete high levels of monoclonal antibodies against many specific antigens. The hybrid cell lines can be maintained in vitro in cell culture media. The cell lines producing the antibodies can be selected and/or maintained in a medium containing hypoxanthine-aminopterin thymidine (HAT) . In fact, once the hybridoma cell line is established, it can be maintained on a variety of nutritionally adequate media. Moreover, the hybrid cells lines can be stored and preserved in any number of conventional ways, including freezing and storage under liquid nitrogen. Frozen cell lines can be revived and cultured indefinitely with resumed synthesis and secretion of monoclonal antibody.
The secreted antibody is recovered from tissue culture supernatant or ascites fluid by conventional methods such as immune precipitation, ion exchange chromatography, affinity chromatography such as protein A/protein G column chromatography, or the like. The antibodies described herein are also recovered from hybridoma cell cultures by conventional methods such as precipitation with 50% ammonium sulfate. The purified antibodies can then be sterile filtered. The term "monoclonal antibody" as used herein refers to any antibody obtained from a population of substantially homogeneous antibodies, i.e., the individual antibodies comprising the population are identical except for possible naturally occurring mutations that may be present in minor amounts. Monoclonal antibodies are highly specific, being directed against a single antigenic site. Furthermore, in contrast to conventional (polyclonal) antibody preparations which typically include different antibodies directed against
different determinants (epitopes), each monoclonal antibody is directed against a single determinant on the antigen. In addition to their specificity, the monoclonal antibodies are advantageous in that they are synthesized by the hybridoma culture, uncontaminated by other immunoglobulins.
The monoclonal antibodies herein also include hybrid and recombinant antibodies produced by splicing a variable (including hypervariable) domain of an anti-pLDH antibody with a constant domain (e.g. "humanized" antibodies), or a light chain with a heavy chain, or a chain from one species with a chain from another species, or fusions with heterologous proteins, regardless of species of origin or immunoglobulin class or subclass designation, as well as antibodies fragment (e.g., Fab, F(ab')2 and Fv), so long as they exhibit the desired biological activity. (See e.g. Cabilly et al. U.S. Patent No. 4,816,567; Mage and Lamoyi, "Monoclonal Antibody Production Technique and Applications", pp. 79-97 (Marcel Dekker, Inc., New York, 1987)).
Thus, the modifier "monoclonal" indicates the character of the antibody as being obtained from a substantially homogenous population of antibodies, and is not to be construed as requiring production of the antibody by any particular method. For example, the monoclonal antibodies to be used in accordance with the present invention may be made by the hybridoma method described by Koehler and Milstein, supra, or may be made by recombinant DNA methods (Cabilly, et al. supra).
Anti-pLDH antibodies are useful in diagnostic assays for pLDH expression in specific cells or tissues wherein the antibodies are labeled as described below and are immobilized on an insoluble matrix. Anti-pLDH antibodies also are useful for the affinity purification of the pLDH from recombinant cell culture or natural sources. The anti-pLDH antibodies that do not detectably cross react with other pLDH can be used to purify each pLDH free from other homologous receptors. Suitable diagnostic assays for the pLDH are well known per se. For example, a biological sample may be assayed for pLDH by obtaining the sample from a desired source, admixing the sample with anti-pLDH antibody to allow the antibody to form
antibody/pLDH complex with any pLDH present in the mixture and detecting any antibody/pLDH complex present in the mixture. The biological sample may be prepared for assay by methods known in the art which are suitable for the particular sample. The methods of admixing the sample with antibodies and the methods of detecting antibodies/pLDH complex are chosen according to the type of assay used. Such assays include competitive and sandwich assays, and steric inhibition assays. Competitive and sandwich methods employ a phase-separation step as an integral part of the method while steric inhibition assays are conducted in a single reaction mixture.
Analytical methods for the pLDH all use one or more of the following reagents: labeled pLDH analog, immobilized pLDH analog, labels anti-pLDH antibody, immobilized anti-pLDH antibody and steric conjugate.
The label used is any detectable functionality that does not interfere with the binding of pLDH and anti-pLDH antibody. Numerous labels are known for use in immunoassay, examples including moieties that may be detected directly, such as fluorochrome, chemiluminescent, and radioactive labels, as well as moieties such as enzymes, that must be reacted or derivatized to be detected. Examples of such labels include the radioisotopes 32P, 14C, 125I, 3H, and 131I, fluorophores such as rare earth chelates or fluorescein and its derivatives, rhodamine and its derivatives, dansyn, umbelliferone, luceriferases, e.g. firefly lucifera and bacterial lucifera (U.S. Patent No. 4,737,456), luciferin, 2,3- dihydrophthalazinediones, horseradish peroxidase (HRP), alkaline phosphatase, β-galactosidase, glucoamylase, lysozyme, saccharide oxidases, e.g. glucose oxidase, galactose oxidase, and glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase, heterocyclic oxidases such as uricase and xanthine oxidase, coupled with an enzyme that employs hydrogen peroxide to oxidize a dye precursor such as HRP, lactoperoxidase, or microperoxidase, biotin/avidin, spin labels, bacteriophage labels, stable free radicals, and the like.
Conventional methods are available to bind these labels covalently to proteins or polypeptides. For instance, coupling
agents such as dialdehydes, carbondiimides, dimaleimides, bisimidates, bisdiazotized benzidine, and the like may be used to tag antibodies with the above described fluorescent, chemiluminescent and enzyme labels. See for e.g. U.S. Patent Nos. 3,940,475 (fluorimetry) and 3,645,090 (enzymes); Hunter et al.. Nature , 144:945 (1962); David et al. , Biochemistry, 13:1014-1021 (1974); Pain et al., J. Immunol . Methods , 40:219- 230 (1981); and Nygren, J". Histochem . and Cytochem. , 30:407-412 (1982). Preferred labels herein are enzymes such as horseradish peroxidase and alkaline phosphatase.
The conjugation of such label, including the enzymes, to the antibody is a standard manipulative procedure for one of ordinary skill in immunoassay techniques. See for e.g. O'SuUivan et al., "Methods for the Preparation of Enzyme- Antibody Conjugates for use in Enzyme Immunoassays" , in Methods in Enzymology, Et. J.J. Langone and H. VanVunkis, Vol. 73 (Academic Press, New York, New York, 1981), pp. 147-156.
Immobilization of reagents is required for certain assay methods. Immobilization entails separating the anti-pLDH antibody from any pLDH that remains free in solution. This conventionally is accomplished by either insolubilizing the anti-pLDH antibody or pLDH analogue before the assay procedure, as by adsorption to a water-insoluble matrix or surface (Bennich et al. , U.S. Patent No. 3,720,760), by covalent coupling (for e.g., using glutaraldehyde cross-linking), or by insolubilizing the anti-pLDH antibody or pLDH analog afterward, e.g. by immunoprecipitation.
Other assay methods, known as competitive or sandwich assays, are well established and widely used in the commercial diagnostic industry.
Competitive assays rely on the ability of a tracer pLDH analog to compete with the test sample pLDH for a limited number of anti-pLDH antibody antigen-binding sites. The anti- pLDH antibody generally is insolubilized before or after the competition and then the tracer and pLDH bound to the anti-pLDH antibody are separated from the unbound tracer and pLDH. This separation is accomplished by decanting (where the binding partner was preinsolubilized) or by centrifuging (where the
binding partner was precipitated after the competitive reaction) . The amount of test sample pLDH is inversely proportional to the amount of bound tracer as measured by the amount of marker substance. Dose-response curves with known amounts of pLDH are prepared and compared with the tests results to quantitatively determine the amount of pLDH present in the test sample. These assays are called ELISA systems when enzymes are used as the detectable markers.
Another species of competitive assay called a "homogenous" assay, does not require a phase separation. Here, a conjugate of an enzyme with the pLDH is prepared and used such that when aKushalnti-pLDH antibodies binds to the pLDH, the presence of the anti-pLDH antibody modifies the enzyme activity. In this case, the pLDH or its immunologically active fragments are conjugated with a bifunctional organic bridge to an enzyme such a peroxidase. Conjugates are selected for use with anti-pLDH antibody so that binding of the anti-pLDH antibody inhibits or potentiates the enzyme activity of the label. This method per se is widely practiced under the name of EMIT. Steric conjugates are used in steric hindrance methods or homogenous assays. These conjugates are synthesized by covalently linking a low-molecular-weight hapten to a small pLDH fragment so that antibody to hapten is substantially unable to bind the conjugate at the same time as the anti-pLDH antibody. Under this assay procedure, the pLDH present in the test sample will bind anti-pLDH antibody, thereby allowing anti-hapten to bind the conjugate, resulting in a change in the character of the conjugate hapten, e.g. a change in fluorescence when the hapten is a fluorophore. Sandwich assays are also useful for the determination of pLDH or anti-pLDH antibodies. In sequential sandwich assays, an immobilized anti-pLDH antibody is used to adsorb test sample pLDH, the test sample is removed as by washing, the bound pLDH is used to adsorb a second, labeled anti-pLDH antibody and bound material is then separated from residual tracer. The amount of bound tracer is directly proportional to test sample pLDH. In "simultaneous" sandwich assays, the test sample is not separated before adding the labeled anti-pLDH. A
sequential sandwich assay using an anti-pLDH monoclonal antibody as one antibody and a polyclonal anti-pLDH antibody as the other is useful in testing samples for pLDH.
One type of assay which is particularly useful in testing samples for pLDH is the patented assay set forth in U.S. Pat. No. 5,124,141. This assay procedure is discussed in detail in the patent but briefly consists of the following. A blood sample, which may consist of whole blood, blood hemolysates, plasma, serum or the like, is combined with a specialized reagent. The reagent includes three main components. The first component is 3-acetyl pyridine adenine dinucleotide ("APAD") which functions as a coenzyme/necessary cofactor and is reduced enzymatically in the presence of pLDH. This material is commercially available from the Sigma Chemical Corporation of St. Louis, MO.
The second component is a substrate which is generally defined as a molecule whose chemical conversion is catalyzed by an enzyme. In a preferred embodiment, the substrate is a 1- lactate salt.. The third component of the reagent is a buffer which is used to maintain the pH of the reagent at between about 8.0- 10.0. Preferred buffers include AMPSO, CHES, bis-tris propane, AMP, and TRIS but other suitable buffers capable of maintaining the proper pH may also be used.. The reagent and blood sample are then combined. In a preferred sample, the reagent to blood volume ratio is about 1:300 and if serum is used the preferable range is from about 1:1 to about 1:20. If the blood sample contains any pLDH, the APAD is enzymatically reduced to APADH and the substrate is oxidized (e.g. lactate to pyruvate). The APADH may thereafter be detected using spectrophotometric techniques, colorimetrically, fluorimetrically, or electrophoretically. These detection methods are well known to those of ordinary skill in the art. The foregoing are merely exemplary diagnostic assays for pLDH. Other methods now or hereafter developed that use anti-
LDH antibody for the determination of pLDH are included within the scope hereof, including the bioassays described above.
All references cited in this specification are hereby expressly incorporated by reference. The following examples are offered by way of illustration and not by way of limitation. It should be appreciated that the Plasmodium used in each of the below examples are representative of all
Plasmodium in that particular species since they each produce the same essential metabolic functions and characteristics.
All references cited in this specification are hereby expressly incorporated by reference. The following examples are offered by way of illustration and not by way of limitation.
Example 1
Production and Evaluation of Monoclonal pLDH Antibodies The panel of anti-pLDH monoclonal antibodies was made by immunizing Balb-c mice to a protein fraction containing pLDH purified from red blood cells grown in vitro cultures of the P . falciparum strain D6. The authenticity of this source of pLDH was demonstrated by direct sequencing of the N-terminus. For boosting immunization, recombinant pLDH was produced by subcloning a PCR fragment amplified from genomic DNA from the P. falciparum strain D6 into the expression vector pTrc99 (Pharmacia). E. Coli transformed with the resulting plasmid were subsequently induced with IPTG to produce recombinant pLDH (rpLDH). Recombinant pLDH is purified from bacterial lysates over a Cibacron blue sephrose and ion exchange column chromatography.
Purified recombinant pLDH was used to immunize a series of mice to raise monoclonal antibodies that specifically recognize pLDH. This data is summarized in Figures 1-4. Authentic pLDH was purified by Cibacron blue sepharose chromatography from culture lysates (Fig. 1). pLDH activity (ADAP) can be separated from human red blood cell LDH (1st NAD peak) because pLDH binds tightly to Cibacron blue. Recombinant pLDH produced in bacteria is purified the same way and shows identical biochemical characteristics to authentic pLDH.
Hybridoma cell lines were subcloned until monoclonality was established. Antibodies were harvested from serum free
media and purified by the sequential precipitation with ammonium sulfate and caprylic acid. Antibodies were subtyped as:
19G7-C10; IgGl, K 7G9-G1; IgGl, K
17E4-D6; IgGl, K
6C9(A)-D6; IgGl, K
6C9(B)-G7; IgA, K
Figure 2 shows an agarose electrophoresis gel in which active enzyme has been stained with NAD+, NBT and PES. Active recombinant pLDH was used as an immunogen to raise the monoclonal antibodies, 19G7, 7G9, 17E4, 6C9a, and 6C9b.
These antibodies have been used to coat microtiter plates (see Figure 3) . These coated plates are capable of capturing enzymatically active pLDH from samples of whole blood, plasma, or lysed red blood cells. The immuno-enzyme capture assay (ICpLDH) is able to capture small amounts of pLDH from blood products and allow for the unambiguous measurement of pLDH activity. Four of the MAbs captured active enzyme without adverse effects on enzyme activity. In contrast, the 6C9a antibody captured pLDH but at high concentrations inhibits enzyme activity. All five antibodies were subcloned and prepared and purified on a large scale.
Formatting and Testing of a Solution Based Immunocapture pLDH Assay
To insure that the pLDH assay would reflect % parasitemia in patient samples, the specific activity of pLDH must be similar in different isolates. Therefore, the specific activity of pLDH from different patient samples was measured. Samples of high parasitemia were allowed to bind to coated microtiter plates such that the enzyme was in excess. Since all of the antibody sites were then occupied by pLDH, the relative specific activities could be measured. This was done in triplicate for seven samples of P. falciparum and three samples of P. vivax. All P. falciparum samples had similar activities (see Fig. 4).
Tabular data is presented for a subset of data generated from two studies. For each study, patient samples (100 μls) were incubated in microliter wells for 40 minutes after which wells were washed with PBS. In the first studies, wells were allowed to react with 3-acetyl pyridine adenine dinucleotide
(APAD) for 20 minutes and read at 365 nm after which a solution of NBT and Diaphorase was added to assay for pLDH activity colorimetrically. These experiments gave reproducible results, however, this assay was non linear with respect to enzyme activity and required modification. This included the addition of APAD and NBT/Diaphorase. The kinetics of this later reaction were linear as a function of enzyme concentration. A standard curve showing the sensitivity of this ICpLDH assay is shown in Figure 5. A starting parasitemia of 10% was diluted in whole uninfected blood to yield samples of the indicated % parasitemia. Either 100 μls or 5 μls of the sample were incubated in coated microtiter wells for 30 minutes. The sample volumes were adjusted to 150 μls total with the addition of PBS containing 1% BSA. The wells were previously coated with either the 19G7 monoclonal antibody (pan-specific) or the 17E4 monoclonal antibody (P. falciparum specific). the wells were then washed 2 times with PBS and incubated with APAD containing NBT and Diaphorase. The microtiter wells are shown in Figure 6.
The Specificity of the New PLDH Amino capture assay (ICtLDH)
Preliminary findings reveal that MAbs 19G7, 6C9a and 6C9b are able to capture both P. falciparum and P . vivax LDH, while two other antibodies, 17E4 and 7G9 capture only pLDH from P . falciparum. P. vivax pLDH blood samples from Central America,
West and South Africa, India and Papua New Guinea (Figure 7) all perform as described with the MAb reagents. A visual depiction of the results is set forth in Figure 8. In all cases, 19G7, 6C9a and 6C9b MAbs were able to capture active P . vivax pLDH. All five antibodies were able to capture P. falciparum pLDH. This result shows that there are epitopes both common to pLDH from different species as well as unique
species specific epitopes. Because some antibodies recognized unique epitopes of P . falciparum and P . vivax pLDH, the reactivity of these antibodies to other Plasmodium species were tested. In general, the 19G7 and 6C9a antibodies recognized a wide range of Plasmodium LDH isoforms. In particular, 6C9a recognized all isoforms tested. Based on previous data on other Plasmodium enzymes, it is fully expected that the 6C9a antibody will be fully capable of recognizing the pLDH isoforms in these species as well. Clinical Studies
In the first study, over 135 samples from 75 patients were tested. Several serial samples from a subset of patients were evaluated in the study. These samples were evaluated by microscopic inspection of Giemsa thin smears. The first study was restricted to samples infected with P . falciparum. This data is presented in Table 1. The pLDH assay did not yield any false negatives. Besides the nineteen samples judged parasite free by microscopy, noninfected specimens of whole blood fro 35 other patients with a wide range of ailments were also analyzed. None of these samples were positive by ICpLDH assay. The pLDH assay was able to detect all patients samples with parasitemias of P . falciparum of > 0.06% (> 3,000 μl). Within the range of 0.001-0.05%, the pLDH test was positive with 90% of the samples. Curiously, three of the false negative samples were from a single patient (Patient #64). As with all of these data points, the samples were part of a series taken from a patient undergoing antimalarial treatment. The initial sample taken was positive by ICpLDH assay, demonstrating that the reason for false negative result was not due to a lack of antibody specificity.
Further analysis of these samples by SDS-PAGE and immunoblot showed that the immunoreactive material was degraded and thus provided one explanation for the loss of pLDH activity. A second explanation is that treatment destroyed the parasites and thus the pLDH activity. Further studies are needed to validate these explanations. Elimination of this patient's samples from the analysis would bring the sensitivity of the pLDH assay to ~97% for samples of 0.001%-0.05%. The
ICpLDH assay was able to detect ~83% of samples with parasitemias of <0.001 (<50/μl).
Table 1. Immunocapture test with P . falciparum Infected Blood
G emsa pLDH immunocapture Activity Assay
% Parasitemia Parasites/μl Positive Negative Sensitivity
>0 . 06 3,000 45 0 100%
0 . 06-0 . 001 50-3,000 39 4 (1*) 90% (97%)
>0 . 001 <50 or 25 5(4*) 83%(87%) gametocytes
Specificity
Control 19 100%
Total
137 Samples
75 Patients
Most of the samples tested in the first study presented above were from patients infected with malaria in India and Africa. In another study, samples from 26 patients collected in Central America, Cali, Columbia were evaluated. The range of parasitemias tested were from 42 - 15,000 parasites/μl (0.001-0.3% parasitemia). Patient samples infected with either P . vivax or P. falciparum were evaluated in one of two ways: Samples were either stored on ice until evaluation or were absorbed to sheets of Whatman 3M paper, dried and stored at room temperature. To assay the dried samples, a 1 cm2 are of the paper was soaked in 300 μls of PBS for 20 minutes. 200 μls of this solution was used in the ICpLDH test with the 19G7 antibody. The results from these studies are presented in Table 2. In all cases, the ICpLDH assay was able to identify samples from patients infected with either P . falciparumor P . vivax. This was true for whole blood samples stored at 4°C and for samples absorbed to Whatman 3M paper and stored at room temperature for 7 months. Also, no false positives were detected by the ICpLDH assay. To further support this finding, uninfected control blood from 10 different sources was dried on Whatman paper and subjected to extraction and the ICpLDH test.
No false positives were detected with these additional samples (data not shown).
Table 2 shows the efficacy of the diagnostic test for the detection of P . vivax. Results from samples collected at Portland Veterans Administration Hospital, the London Hospital for Tropical Disease, and from a collaborative clinic in Cali Columbia were combined and tabulated.
In the most extensive evaluation of P. falciparum samples, it was found that within the range the ICpLDH assay was 96% sensitive and 100% specific for samples of >0.001% parasitemia. These studies show that the ICpLDH is well suited for diagnosis of malaria. By using a rapid purification procedure based on the immobilization of active pLDH in microliter wells, false positives are eliminated and the sensitivity of the pLDH assay is increased. The use of the 19G7 antibody also affords the detection of both P . vivax and P . falciparum. Further, it has been shown that other anti-pLDH monoclonal antibodies are specific for pLDH from P. falciparum. Therefore a simple test could be formatted to speciate Plasmodium infections.
Table 2. Immunocapture test infected Blood: South America pLDH Immunocapture Activity Giemsa Assay
4°C storage Dry Storage
Parasitemia Parasites sp . Positive Negative Positive Negative
0.25-0.001 P . falciparum 8 0 8 0
0.8-0.004 P . vivax 12 0 12 0
0 Control 0 5 0 5
Total
25 samples
25 patients
One important consideration which must be reemphasized is that, in interpreting the above data, one must remember that the apparent sensitivity of the pLDH test was ascertained by testing samples from patients undergoing anti malarial therapy, Thus, the starting parasitemias of these patients were often quite high (0.01-1%). All of the low parasitemia samples were from patients that had been treated for at least 2-3 days.
Therefore, the viability of the parasites within these samples may have been severely compromised. pLDH activity is an indicator of viable parasites. Consequently, the samples that were originally designated with "low parasitemia" or no parasitemia may in fact be samples that contain non viable parasites.
On important aspect of the ICpLDH assay is apparent from inspection of several samples of patients undergoing anti malarial treatment. These data sets show that pLDH activity presents in peripheral red blood cells drops in concert with parasitemia. It is possible that plasma levels of pLDH may reflect total parasite load (sequestered and peripheral parasites) .
Comparison with ParaSiqhtF™ ParasightF™ antigen detection assay was found to perform comparably to the assay of the present invention using MAbs. Within a very low range of parasitemias (<0.001% or 50 μls/μl) some infected samples were found positive by pLDH but not by ParasightF™ as well as vise versa. Upon analyzing serial samples from patients undergoing anti malarial chemotherapy, the ParasightF™ assay, in contrast to the ICpLDH assay and the standard thin smear, consistently gave a positive signal even when parasites were completely cleared as judged by microscopy. This persistent antigenemia was readily apparent in some patients who were tested 14 days after antimalarial treatment, 10 days after they were judged parasite free by microscopy. This data again underscores the utility of the pLDH assay. The fact that active pLDH levels do not persist once parasites have been killed combined with the quantitative aspect of the ICpLDH assay make it possible to use the present test to monitor patient progress with a given antimalarial chemotherapy regimen. This ability is a major requirement for identifying and assessing drug resistant infection in vivo. Preliminary studies with a dry "dip stick" antigen detection based assay for pLDH also indicate that the presence of pLDH antigen also does not persist after parasite clearance.
Formatting of a Dry Immuno-Capture pLDH Assay
A nitrocellulose strip was coated with a line of 17E4 monoclonal antibody (P. falciparum specific) and a second line of 19G7 monoclonal antibody (pan specific). The blood sample was then lysed with a bead conjugate made with the 6C9a antibody. Thus, each of the antibodies used had a separate epitope. The lysate was then wicked up the nitrocellulase strip. If the sample contained pLDH (from P . falciparum) the bead conjugate (with bound pLDH) would bind to the 17E4 line. If the bead conjugate has pLDH from P. vivax bound, the conjugate would pass over the 17E4 line and bind only to the 19G7 line. It is anticipated that the dip stick will be able to differentiate between P. vivax and P. falciparum and is capable of detecting 5 viable parasites/μl of blood, thus providing a solid phase "dip-stick" assay.
The above description thus sets forth a novel and simple to use diagnostic assay for malaria based on the quantitation of pLDH. It further demonstrates a novel series of monoclonal antibodies which are useful in the speciation of Plasmodium isoforms in order to determine which particular is causing the infection in the host. It is therefore submitted that the present invention accomplishes at least all of its stated objectives.