EP2000557B1

EP2000557B1 - Erosion barrier for thermal barrier coatings

Info

Publication number: EP2000557B1
Application number: EP20070252248
Authority: EP
Inventors: Joshua E. Persky; David L. Lambert; David A. Litton
Original assignee: United Technologies Corp
Current assignee: RTX Corp
Priority date: 2007-06-04
Filing date: 2007-06-04
Publication date: 2015-04-29
Anticipated expiration: 2027-06-04
Also published as: EP2000557A1

Description

The present invention relates to an erosion barrier for thermal barrier coatings and to processes for forming the erosion barrier.
Many turbine engine components are provided with a thermal barrier coating to protect the underlying substrate. High velocity particles in the gas path of an engine cause considerable erosion damage to the thermal barrier coating. The erosion of the thermal barrier coating leads to premature failure of the coated turbine engine part. Thus, it is highly desirable to form a hard exterior shell strongly bonded to the thermal barrier coating. For example, EP 0783043 discloses a thermal barrier coating having an erosion-resistant composition dispersed within or overlaying a ceramic layer, and EP 1788122 discloses a process for forming a protective deposit over a ceramic thermal barrier layer.
The present invention provides a process for forming an erosion barrier for protecting a thermal barrier coating on a workpiece as claimed in claim 1. Thus, in the present invention, a hard exterior shell is formed that is strongly bonded to the thermal barrier coating.
The erosion barrier may be formed from aluminum oxide, silicon carbide, silicon nitride, and molybdenum disilicide.
Other details of the erosion barrier for thermal barrier coatings of the present invention, as well as other objects and advantages attendant thereto, are set forth in the following detailed description and the accompanying drawings wherein like reference numerals depict like elements.

FIG. 1 is a schematic representation of an apparatus for forming an erosion barrier on a workpiece having a thermal barrier coating; and
FIG. 2 is a schematic representation of a workpiece having a thermal barrier coating and an erosion barrier.

The present invention involves forming a hard shell exterior coating which acts as an erosion barrier on a thermal barrier coating applied to a substrate such as a turbine engine component. The exterior coating erosion barrier is formed by electrophoretic deposition.
With regard to the electrophoretic deposition, as shown in FIG. 1, the workpiece 50, such as a turbine engine component or part, forming the substrate is immersed in a suspension 10 and electrically connected to one terminal of a voltage source 12. A second electrode 14, which may be formed from any suitable electrically conductive material known in the art, is electrically connected to a second terminal of the voltage source 12.
Prior to immersion in the suspension, a thermal barrier coating 52, such as a zirconia based thermal barrier coating, is applied to the turbine engine component 50. The thermal barrier coating 52 may be applied to the turbine engine component using any suitable technique known in the art.
The suspension 10 consists of very fine ceramic particles ranging in size from about 0.02 microns to 0.2 microns in sol form. Preferably, the ceramic particles have a size in the range of from about 0.02 to 0.05 microns. The ceramic particles may be suspended in a solvent such as water, alcohols including, but not limited to, ethanol or methanol, and water-alcohol mixtures. One can use organic solvents, such as tricholoethane, however, such use may be prohibited by health and environmental issues.
In the simplest embodiment, an aluminum oxide (alumina) sol is put in suspension in water, alcohol, or mixtures thereof, and stabilized by the addition of sufficient acid to keep the pH of the solution below 4.25. This results in a positive charge on the alumina particles, such that they repel each other, avoiding agglomeration and sedimentation of the particles out of solution. Candidates for acids to be added to the solution include, but is not limited to, nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, acetic acid, and stearic acid. Reducing the pH of the solution as low as 2.0 is possible, but low pHs could result in acid attack of any exposed metal on the parts or components to be coated in the suspension. The preferred pH for alumina sol suspensions in water and/or alcohol is from 3.0 to 4.5. The part or component 50 to be coated may be strongly biased with a negative DC voltage to accelerate the suspended particles in the suspension toward the thermal barrier coated surface of the part or component 50. Typical negative biasing voltages range from about 50 to 2000V, preferably from about 900 to 1100V. Higher voltages lead to higher deposition rates, but are potentially hazardous by increasing the system's potential energy to a level that can compromise workplace safety.
In addition to alumina sol in suspension, other hard ceramic materials that would be suitable include silicon nitride sol, silicon carbide sol, and molybdenum disilicide sol. The suitable pH range required to produce a stable suspension varies with the composition of the fine ceramic particles in the suspension. This is due to surface chemistry variations which lead to different buildups of charge on the surfaces of the particles as a function of the pH of the suspension. At low pH, surfaces are positively charged, and at high pH, surfaces are negatively charged. Thus, there exists a pH level that corresponds to zero surface charge on the particles, which is known as the isoelectric point or pHiep. Alumina has a pHiep of 4.5, while silicon nitride has a pHiep of 9.0, silicon nitride has a pHiep of 5.4, and molybdenum disilicide has a pHiep of 2.2.
Since the present invention may be used to form hard shell materials deposited on zirconia based thermal barrier coatings, it may also be advantageous to operate in a pH range that results in negative charge on the zirconia based coatings. This can be done by operating above the pHiep of zirconia which is 4.0. With regard to alumina particles in a suspension, the biasing of the zirconia coating would supply plenty of negative charge to the zirconia surface, thereby extending the useable pH lower limit downwards to 3.0.
As discussed above, strong acids do tend to attack the metals forming the substrate of the part or component as well as metallic coatings. For this reason, silicon nitride may have an advantage over the other coatings since its pHiep is high at 9.0. This system has the additional advantage of being able to be deposited at neutral pH, which has health and safety advantages.
The pH level at which the electrophoretic deposition is carried out may be raised by modifying the surface chemistry of the sols prior to putting them into suspension. For example, nitriding alumina sols, or aluminizing molybdenum disilicide sols may raise the operating pH level, minimizing damage to parts or components 50.
While the foregoing has discussed the addition of an acid to control the pH, one could also add a base to the suspension to maintain the pH equal to or greater than 7.0. Typical bases to add include ammonium hydroxide and aluminum hydroxide. The thermal stability of alumina, as well as its excellent hardness, makes it the preferred material for the erosion barrier coating.
Hardness of the hard shell materials at room temperature are:

Alumina: Vickers hardness, approx. 2650 kgf/mm² (26.0 GPa);
Silicon nitride: Vickers hardness, approx. 1900 kgf/mm² (18.6 GPa);
Silicon carbide: Vickers hardness, approx. 2750 kgf/mm² (27.0 GPa); and
Molybdenum disilicide: Vickers hardness, approx. 1300 kgf/mm² (12.8 GPa).

The concentration of sols in the suspensions may range from about 0.001 wt% to 5.0 wt% solids. Preferably, the concentration of sols in the suspensions may be from about 0.005 to 0.05 wt% solids.
After the part or component 50 is removed from the suspension after the erosion barrier coating has been deposited, it may be dried using any suitable drying technique known in the art. Drying may be carried out at a temperature in the range of from about room temperature to 650°F (20°C to 343°C). Drying times at room temperature may range from about 1.0 to 20 hours, preferably from about 3.0 to 10 hours. At drying temperatures in the range of 250°F to 650°F (121°C to 343°C), the drying times may be reduced from about 0.5 to 5.0 hours with a preferred drying time range of from about 1.0 to 2.0 hours.
After drying, the coated part or component may be subjected to a sintering operation to form strong bonds within the deposited erosion barrier coating and between the erosion barrier coating and the thermal barrier coating. Also, sintering reduces porosity in the erosion barrier coating which drives the hardness values toward the bulk hardness values discussed hereinbefore. Sintering may be carried out using any suitable technique known in the art. Sintering times may range from about 3.0 to 4.0 hours at a temperature in the range of from about 1950°F to 2000°F (1066°C to 1093°C).
If desired, one or more dispersants such as polymethyl methacrylate alcohol and ammonium stearate could be added to the suspension to avoid agglomeration and settling of particles. The dispersant(s) may be present in a concentration from 0.01 to 1.0 wt%, preferably from 0.4 to 0.8 wt%.
If desired, polyvinyl alcohol can be added as a binder to the suspension to increase the strength of the hard shell prior to sintering if necessary. The polyvinyl alcohol may be added in an amount from 0.1 to 3.0 wt%, preferably from 1.0 to 2.0 wt%. The goal of the polyvinyl alcohol binder addition is to coat each particle of sol in the suspension with a monolayer of binder.
Referring now to FIG. 2, the processes of the present invention preferably yield a component or part 50 having a thermal barrier coating (TBC) 52 and a hard shell erosion barrier coating 54 deposited over the thermal barrier coating 52. An infiltrated region 56 may be formed between the coating 54 and the coating 52. The infiltrated region may constitute from 5.0 to 100% of the thickness of the TBC measured down from the surface of the TBC. Preferably, the thickness of the infiltrated region is from 10-20% of the TBC thickness. The component or part 50 may be formed from any suitable metallic material known in the art such as a nickel based superalloy.
Erosion of TBCs tends to happen on specific areas of turbine engine components. For example, blade tips get eroded, especially on the suction side. Outer buttresses of vanes also get eroded due to centrifugal forces. Most particulates in the turbine gas stream are centrifuged out to the outer diameter of the turbine, where they do most of their damage. Any relatively steep contours on the turbine engine components get eroded, simply because steep contours increase the local pressure on the part surface by compressing the gas stream, which increases the frequency of collisions with both molecules and any particulates in the gas stream--thus increasing erosion. To minimize the weight added by the hard shell coating and to minimize any potential detrimental effects a hard shell coating might have on TBCs on any turbine engine component, such as reduction of strain tolerance, it would be beneficial to put the hard shell coating only on areas with known susceptibility to erosion.
The placement of a hard shell coating on only a portion of a turbine engine component may be done using a painting process, a dipping process, or an electrophoretic approach. An organic maskant may be applied to all surfaces not intended to be coated.
The placement of the hard shell coating may be done by applying a UV curable resin, such as a commercially available resin known as PHOTORESIST, on the turbine engine component. Then one could apply a sheet metal mask to the areas onto which the deposition of the hard coating is desired. Thereafter, the resin-coated, masked component may be exposed to UV light for a time period from 1.0 to 10 minutes to cure all exposed resin. After curing, the sheet metal mask is removed. Any uncured resin may be washed off. Then one can proceed to the hard coating process. If photolithography is used, drying may be carried out at a temperature in the range of from 600°F to 900°F (316°C to 482°C) for a time in the range of from 2.0 to 4.0 hours to burn off the cured resin.
The processes of the present invention may be used to form an erosion barrier coating on a wide variety of parts and components having a thermal barrier coating thereon. The parts or components which may be treated include, but are not limited, any part having an airfoil, any part having a seal, airfoils, seals, and the like. Examples of such parts or components include blades, vanes, stators, mid-turbine frames, combustor panels, combustor cans, combustor bulkhead panels, disk side plates, and fuel nozzle guides.
Although the present invention has been described with reference to preferred embodiments, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and detail can be made to the particular embodiments described above without departing from the scope of the invention as set forth in the accompanying claims.

Claims

A process for forming an erosion barrier for protecting a thermal barrier coating (52) on a workpiece (50), said process comprising the steps of:
forming a suspension (10) of ceramic particles suspended in a solvent; and

depositing particles in said suspension on said thermal barrier coating (52);
characterised in that:
said suspension forming step comprises adding an acid or a base to said suspension (10) so that said suspension has a pH no greater than 9.0;

said depositing step comprises electrophorectically depositing said particles in said suspension (10) on said thermal barrier coating by biasing said workpiece having said thermal barrier coating (52) with a DC voltage sufficient to accelerate suspended particles in said suspension (10) toward a surface of the workpiece (50); and

by drying said particles deposited on said thermal barrier coating (52) so as to form an erosion barrier coating (54) which has a Vickers hardness in the range of from 1300 to 2750 kgf/mm² (12.8 to 27.0 GPa).
The process of claim 1, wherein said suspension forming step comprises forming a suspension using a solvent selected from the group consisting of water, alcohol, and mixtures thereof.
The process of claim 1 or 2, wherein said step suspension forming step comprises forming a suspension (10) with ceramic particles selected from the group consisting of aluminum oxide, silicon nitride, silicon carbide, and molybdenum disilicide.
The process of any preceding claim, wherein said step suspension forming step comprises forming a suspension using ceramic particles having a particle size in the range of from 0.02 to 0.2 microns.
The process of any preceding claim, further comprising maintaining said suspension (10) at a temperature in the range of from room temperature (68°F) to 120°F (20°C to 49°C).
The process of any preceding claim, further comprising forming said suspension (10) so that said ceramic particles are present in a concentration of from 0.001 to 5.0 wt%.
The process of claim 6, comprising forming said suspension (10) so that said ceramic particles are present in a concentration of from about 0.005 to 0.05 wt%.
The process of any preceding claim, wherein said acid adding step comprises adding an acid which maintains the pH of said suspension at one of: (i) below 4.25; and (ii) in the range of from 2.0 to 4.25.
The process of claim 8, wherein said acid adding step comprises adding an acid selected from the group consisting of nitric acid, hydrochloric acid, acetic acid, and stearic acid.
The process of any of claims 1 to 7, wherein said base adding step comprises adding a base selected from the group of aluminum hydroxide and ammonium hydroxide to raise the pH of said suspension (10).
The process of any preceding claim, further comprising adding from 0.01 to 1.0 wt% of a dispersant selected from the group consisting of polymethyl methacrylate alcohol and ammonium stearate to said suspension to avoid agglomeration and settling of said particles.
The process of any preceding claim, further comprising adding from 0.1 to 3.0 wt% of a binder to said suspension to increase the strength of a shell formed by said erosion barrier.
The process of claim 12, wherein said binder adding step comprises adding from 1.0 to 2.0 wt% of polyvinyl alcohol.
The process of any preceding claim, wherein said depositing step comprises applying a voltage in the range of from 50 to 2000V to said workpiece (50).
The process of claim 14, wherein said depositing step comprises applying a voltage in the range of from 900 to 1100V to said workpiece (50).
The process of any preceding claim, further comprising removing said workpiece (50) with said deposited particles from said suspension and said drying step comprising drying said workpiece at a temperature in the range from room temperature (68°F) to 650°F (20°C to 343°C) for a time in the range of from 0.5 to 20 hours.
The process of claim 16, wherein said drying step comprises one of: (i) drying said workpiece at room temperature for a time in the range of from 1 to 20 hours; (ii) drying said workpiece at room temperature for a time in the range of 3 to 10 hours; (iii) drying said workpiece at a temperature in the range of 250°F to 650°F (121°C to 343°C) for a time in the range of from 0.5 to 5.0 hours; and (iv) drying said workpiece at a temperature in the range of 250°F to 650°F (121°C to 343°C) for a time in the range of from 1.0 to 2.0 hours.
The process of any preceding claim, further comprising sintering said workpiece (50) at a temperature in the range of 1950°F to 2000°F (1066°C to 1093°C) for a time period in the range of from 3.0 to 4.0 hours.
The process of any preceding claim, wherein said thermal barrier coating (52) comprises a zirconia based thermal barrier coating.
The process of any preceding claim, wherein an infiltrated region (56) is formed between said thermal barrier coating (52) and said erosion barrier (54).
The process of any preceding claim, wherein said workpiece (50) comprises a turbine engine component.