EP0000556B1

EP0000556B1 - Testing device for testing the dental pulp of a tooth

Info

Publication number: EP0000556B1
Application number: EP78100459A
Authority: EP
Inventors: C. Johan Masreliez
Original assignee: Individual
Current assignee: Individual
Priority date: 1977-06-22
Filing date: 1978-07-20
Publication date: 1981-03-11
Also published as: EP0000556A1

Description

The invention relates to a testing device for testing the dental pulp of a tooth as referred to in the introductory part of claim 1.
When a tooth has been subject to decay, physical trauma, thermal changes or irritation by sweet foods or deep fillings, the pulp tissue becomes inflamed. When this inflammation is left untreated for a long time, the ensuing pulpal inflammation generally proceeds to a severe infection with abscess formation about the root tips. It is at this stage that many teeth require extraction and that endodontic procedures, designed to help remove this infection, are least successful.
Electric devices used to test the vitality of pulpal tissue have long been used as diagnostic aids by dentists. For example, these devices have found application where a patient complains of pain on one side of the mouth and cannot isolate the specific tooth from which the pain emanates. Also they have been used in the diagnosis of decay which develops around the borders of fillings in teeth with existing restorations, a situation where X-rays alone may not indicate the presence or extent of the decay.
In actual operation, a stimulating electrode of an electric pulp tester is applied to a tooth which is undergoing examination. The level of the voltage at the electrode is then gradually raised until the patient feels a tingling or mild electric shock in the tooth that is being touched by the electrode. By comparing the voltage level to which the patient responds with the level at which other of his normal teeth respond, the dentist can make a diagnosis on the state of inflammation or vitality of the dental pulp in the tooth under examination.
While the existing dental pulp testers have proved to be valuable diagnostic tools, they suffer from certain disadvantages which have limited their utility. A disadvantage of conventional pulp testers is that a reasonable testing rate can only be achieved by rapidly increasing the intensity of the stimulation. However, this rapid increase causes the intensity to "overshoot" the point where the patient can perceive the stimulation before the probe can be removed from the tooth and the increase in intensity can be terminated. Consequently, the patient is subjected to unnecessary pain, and the intensity readings taken from the display are erroneously high.
Still another disadvantage of conventional pulp testers is the characteristics of the electrical stimulus which they apply to a tooth. The electrical stimulus is generally either a continuous voltage having a magnitude which increases with time, or a continuous series of pulses having an amplitude which increases with time. A testing device of the last- mentioned type is known from Biomedical Engineering, Vol. 11, No. 1, January, 1976, J.M. Mumford and D.G. Lewis "Electronic Tooth Stimulator for Pain Research", pages 22 and 23. The probe used in this device includes a microswitch which allows the amplitude of the pulses applied to the electrode to increase as long as it is pressed. Actuation of this microswitch, however, directs the attention of the dental practitioner away from the patient. A more serious disadvantage of this known device, however, is that by constantly stimulating the tooth, it loses part of its sensitivity.
The object underlying the invention is to provide for a testing device of the kind mentioned in the introductory part of claim 1, being easier to handle by the practitioner and leading to more reliable medical results.
This task is performed by the features being included in the characterizing clause of claim 1.
The testing device according to the invention has a contact detector for sensing when the electrode of the probe makes contact with the tooth under test. The contact detector causes the intensity of the stimulus to increase from a low initial level until the probe is removed from the tooth. The intensity of the stimulus when the probe is removed from the tooth is then displayed on a digital display. When the probe once again makes contact with a tooth the display is reset to the initial value of intensity, and the intensity of the stimulus increases from the initial value. The stimulation is in the form of intermittently produced bursts of pulses with the amplitude of each burst being larger than the amplitude of the previous burst. Consequently, the dental pulp is allowed to reset before each increase in the intensity of the stimulus.
Further preferred embodiments are claimed in claims 2-11.
The invention is described in more detail in the following description of the drawings, wherein

Fig. 1 is an isometric view of the dental pulp tester in use;
Fig. 2 is a schematic of a first embodiment of the dental pulp tester;
Fig. 3 is a cross-sectional view of the dental probe of the dental pulp tester;
Fig. 4 is a cross-sectional view taken along the line 4-4 of Fig. 3, and
Fig. 5 is a schematic of a part of second embodiment of the dental pulp tester.

The dental pulp tester is used to test the dental pulp in the teeth of a patient P as illustrated in Fig. 1. The dental practitioner D utilizes a probe 12 having an electrode contacting a tooth under test. The probe 12 is connected to a testing unit 14 through electric conductors 16. The testing unit 14 includes a digital display 18 which provides an indication of the intensity of the electrical stimulus from the probe 12. The only controls and indicators for the unit are an on-off switch 20, a low-voltage warning light 21 which is illuminated if the amplitude of the electrical stimulus falls below a minimum value, and a sweep rate control 22 which adjusts the rate at which the intensity of the stimulus increases. Both of these controls 20, 22 normally remain stationary while the dental pulp of a patient P is being tested.
As illustrated in Fig. 2, the electrical stimulus originates in a pulse generator 28 having a pulse width determined by-a pulse width control voltage. The voltage controlled pulse generator 28 may be implemented by an integrated circuit dual monostable multi-vibrator or "one-shot" such as a Fairchild F4528 or Motorola MC14528. Basically, the circuit consists of two one-shots 28a,b each having an output Q_a, Q_b triggering the input I_b,a of the other so that the circuits are periodically triggered. The first one-shots 28a generates pulses having a manually adjustable duration, while the pulses generated by the second one-shot 28b have a duration determined by a control input. The duration of the pulses from the first one-shot 28a is determined by timing capacitor 30 and the series combination of fixed resistor 32 and variable resistor 34 which is adjusted, as explained hereinafter, to control the rate. at which the intensity of the electrical stimulation is increased. A capacitor 33 is connected between supply voltage and the input I_b of the second one-shot in order to trigger the second one-shot 28b when power is applied to the unit.
The duration of the pulses produced by the second one-shot 28b is determined by the voltage at the base of transistor 36. Transistor 36 acts as a voltage follower to provide a high impedance discharge path from capacitor 38 to the pulse generator 28. Resistors 40, 42 and capacitor 44 are provided to bias the pulse duration at a predetermined value. The capacitor 38 is initially discharged by transistor 46 at the start of each test. Thereafter the capacitor 38 is charged through diode 48 and resistor 50 by periodic, negative going pulses from the Q_e output of a first one-shot 52a in a dual one-shot circuit 52. The first one-shot 52a is triggered at l_a by the Q_ob output of decade counters 54b which is driven by the Q₃, output of decade counter 54a in series driven by the pulse generator 28. Consequently, the capacitor 38 is incrementally charged for each 20 pulses from pulse generator 28. The duration of the pulse from the one-shot 52, and hence the amount of charge provided during each increment, is determined by timing capacitor 56 and resistor 58.
The Q_ob output of the counter 54b also gates the output of the pulse generator 28 through NOR gate 60 to the base of a transistor 62 through resistor 64. Since the output Q_ob is alternately low for 10 pulses of pulse generator 28 and then high for 10 pulses of pulse generator 28, NOR gate 60 gates 10 pulses to the transistor 62 and then cuts off the transistor 62 for 10 pulses. Consequently, a "dead space" is produced after each burst of 10 pulses which, as explained hereinafter, allows the nerves in the dental pulp to reset after each stimulus so that the nerves are at the maximum sensitivity at the start of each stimulus. As the transistor 62 saturates, current flows through the primary of transformer 66 and resistor 68. Resistor 68 is selected to limit the maximum current flow through the primary of transformer . 66. The pulses across the secondary of the transformer, which are generated inductively when turning off the transistor 62, have a peak amplitude which is determined by the value of resistor 70 and the duration of the pulses at the output of the NOR gate 60. Capacitor 72 is provided to dampen the reverse emf spike generated when current flow through transistor 62 is terminated.
In summary, 10 pulses from the pulse generator 28 are gated through the NOR gate 60 to produce 10 equal amplitude pulses across the secondary of transformer 66 followed by a dead space of 10 pulses during which the NOR gate 60 is gated off. After each pulse burst of 10 pulses, the I_a input of one-shot 52a is triggered to generate a charging pulse on the Qg output of one-shot 52 which incrementally charges capacitor 38 and decreases the control voltage to the pulse generator 28 so that the subsequent burst of pulses from the NOR gate 60 has an increased duration resulting in pulses of increased amplitude across the secondary of the transformer 66. The rate at which the electrical stimulus increases can be varied by adjusting the sweep rate resistor 34 which is controlled by the sweep rate control 22 on the front panel of the unit 14 (Fig. 1).
As explained in greater detail hereinafter, the electrode 74 includes a conductive outer sleeve. 74 surrounding, and insulated from, and elongated center electrode 78. In operation the center electrode 78 makes contact with the tooth of a patient, and the electrode 74 is in electrical contact with the patient through the dentist's hand and the patient's lip. The electrode 74 is connected to the power supply output through resistor 80 so that when the electrode 78 makes contact with the tooth, current flows through resistor 80 and probe 12 into the base of the darlington pair 82. As the darlington pair 82 becomes saturated the current flowing through resistor 84 causes the voltage at the collector of the darlington pair 82 to go low thereby causing the output of NOR gate 85 to go high and the output of NOR gate 86 to go low. The output of NOR gate 86 is connected to the counter inhibit input Ci_a of a counter 54a so that as the output of NOR gate 86 goes low counter 54 begins incrementing. At the same time capacitor 88 is discharged through diode 90 so that the output of NOR gate 92 goes high. NOR gate 92 then saturates transistor 94 through resistor 96 and illuminates three light emitting diodes 98 which, as explained hereinafter, are visibly mounted on the probe 12. NOR gate 92 also turns off transistor 46 permitting capacitor 38 to be charged, and it triggers the I_b input of one-shot 52b thereby producing a pulse at the o_b output which resets counter 100. Counter 100 counts the pulses from the output of counter 54 and displays the contents on digital displays 102, 104 through BCD-to-7 segment latch/decoder/ drivers 106, 108, respectively. The outputs of the counter 100 are continuously displayed until the counter 100 is reset by one-shot 52b. the input 111 of one-shot 52b is connected to the output of NOR gate 92 so that a reset pulse is generated at the output O_b of one-shot 52b when the output of NOR gate 92 goes high as the probe electrode 78 makes contact with a tooth. The duration of the reset pulse, which is not critical, is determined by the values of timing resistor 109 and timing capacitor 111. The most significant bit output Q_3b of the counter 100b is connected to the inhibit input 1₈ of counter 100 so the counter 100 "locks up" if incremented to near its maximum capacity.
The tester unit also includes a circuit for insuring that the output voltage from the probe does not fall below a predetermined minimum level. This circuit is connected to electrode 74 through resistor 120. Transistor 122 is normally saturated thereby cutting off transistor 124. When the positive going pulse from the transformer 66 exceeds a level set by the voltage divider formed by resistors 130, 132 in combination with resistor 120, transistor 122 becomes cut off thereby saturating transistor 124 and allowing current to flow in the emitter- collector circuit through resistor 134 and light emitting diode 21. Positive feedback capacitor 138 is provided to completely saturate transistor 124 as transistor 122 goes into cutoff. Consequently,. pulsating illumination from light emitting diode 21 indicates that the amplitude of the signal at the output of the transformer 66 is sufficient.
An alternative embodiment of the circuit for generating the electrical stimulus is illustrated in Fig. 5. Basically, the alternative embodiment places a linearly increasing voltage on one lead of the secondary of transformer 66 while the other lead of the transformer secondary is periodically connected to ground through transistor 62 by constant duration pulses from pulse generator 28. The embodiment illustrated in Fig. 5 is placed in the circuit of Fig. 2 with the alphabetical markings of the broken leads matching the correspondingly marked leads illustrated in Fig. 2. The negative going pulses at the 5₈ output of one-shot 52 drives transistor 200 into conduction. The current through transistor 200 is proportional to the voltage across resistor 202 divided by the resistance of resistor 202. Resistors 204, 206 form a voltage divider and are selected to place the proper voltage on the emitter of transistor 200 to achieve a predetermined constant current for charging capacitor 208. As capacitor 208 continues to charge, a linearly increasing voltage is produced across capacitor 208 which is coupled to output line z by emitter follower transistor 210. Capacitor 211 is provided to filter the output line z which is secondary of transformer 66. Capacitor 208 is reset through diode 212 by a low level output of NOR gate 92 each time the electrode 78 breaks the contact with a tooth. Diode 214 is placed across the secondary of transformer 66 to dampen reverse emf transients which are produced when current through the transistor 62 is terminated. In this alternate embodiment, the probe stimulus output pulses are generated when turning on transistor 62 rather than as in the previous embodiment when turning off transistor.
The dental pulp tester unit also includes an internal power supply 140 having a rechargeable battery 142 which may be recharged through resistor 144 and rectifying diode 146. When the on-off switch 20 is in its on position the battery 142 is connected to the power supply line 148. The power supply 140 includes a low-voltage warning circuit which indicates when the battery 142 must be recharged. As long as the voltage on line 148 exceeds the reverse breakdown voltage of zener diode 150 current flows through resistors 152, 154. Under these conditions, transistor 156 is saturated thereby cutting off transistor 158 so that current is unable to flow through resistor 160 and light emitting diode 162. When the voltage on line 148 drops below the breakdown voltage of zener diode 150, transistor 156 is cut off thereby allowing current to flow through resistor 164 and the base-emitter junction of transistor 158. Transistor 158 then saturates allowing current to flow through light emitting diode 162 and indicate that the battery 142 is in need of recharging.
The structure of the probe 12 is best illustrated in Figs. 3 and 4. The probe 12 includes a cylindrical conductor forming the outer electrode 75 having its ends closed by a pair of end caps 170, 172. The end cap 172 is formed of an insulative, light-transmissive substance such as plastic, and it contains an axial bore which receives the electrode 78 which makes contact with the tooth. A transparent, cylindrical insert 174 placed in a bore formed in the end cap 172 contains the three light emitting diodes 98 which indicate that the electrode 78 has made contact with a tooth as described above. The cable 16 includes a first conductor 16a connected to the outer electrode 74, a second conductor 16b connected to the inner electrodes 78 and a pair of conductors 16c,d completing a circuit with the light emitting diodes 98. The conductors 16 are encased in a cylindrical sheathing 176 which passes through a bore in the end cap 170 and is retained in place by an annular washer 178.
In operation, when the electrode 78 of the probe 12 first makes contact with a tooth the output of NOR gate 86 goes low thereby illuminating light emitting diodes 98, releasing integrating capacitor 38, resetting counter 100 and allowing counter 54 to begin incrementing. When the output of counter 54 goes low the pulses from the output of the pulse generator 28 are gated through NOR gate 60 to drive transformer 66 and generate 10 pulses at the probe 12. The output of counter 54 then goes high thereby gating NOR gate 60 off and triggering a pulse from the Q_a output of one-shot 52a which incrementally charges integrating capacitor 38. When the output of counter 54 again goes high, pulses having an increased duration are gated through NOR gate 60 so that the amplitude of the pulses across the secondary transformer 60 are increased. The pulse bursts continue to increase in amplitude until the electrical stimulus is felt by the patient at which time the electrode 78 is removed from the tooth of the patient. Since the amplitude of the pulses in each pulse burst is incrementally increased after every 20 pulses from the pulse generator 28, the number of pulses counted by counter 100, as indicated by display 102, 104, is an indication of the amplitude of the pulses delivered to the probe 12. When the electrode 78 is removed from the tooth the current path through the probe 12 is broken so that the output of NOR gate 86 goes high thereby charging capacitor 88 through resistor 110. After a predetermined delay time, the output of NOR gate 92 goes low thereby resetting capacitor 38 and extinguishing the light emitting diodes 98. The time delay provided by capacitor 88 and resistor 110 prevents the counter 100 and integrating capacitor 38 from becoming reset should the electrode 78 of the probe momentarily lose contact with the tooth. However, loss of contact between the electrode 78 and the tooth will inhibit the counter 54 to prevent the counter 100 from incrementing and the duration of the pulses from the pulse generator 28 from increasing.

Claims

1. Testing device for testing the dental pulp of a tooth, comprising,

a probe (12) having a first electrode (78) adapted to directly contact the tooth,

a second electrode (74) adapted for indirect electrical contact with the tooth,

an electrical stimulus circuitry (28, 30, 36, 38, 52, 60, 62, 66) connected to the probe (12) and producing an electrical stimulus between the first and second electrodes (78, 74) having an intensity which increases with time responsive to an initiate signal,

a display (102, 104) providing an indication of the intensity of the electrical stimulus and retaining the indication of electrical stimulus intensity subsequent to termination of the initiate signal such that the display continually indicates the maximum value of electrical stimulus,

a contact decoder (82, 98) for determining when the first electrode (78) is in contact with the tooth and for generating the initiate signal in response thereto such that the intensity of the electrical stimulus is automatically increased responsive to the first electrode (78) contacting the tooth,

characterized in that

the stimulus circuitry (28, 30, 36, 38, 52, 60, 62, 66) provides repetitively generated bursts of pulsating signals, the amplitude of the signals being relatively constant during each burst and the amplitude of the signals during each burst being greater than the amplitude of signals during the previous burst,

the contact detector resets the intensity of the electrical stimulus to a predetermined value responsive to termination of the initiate signal for longer than a predetermined period such that the intensity of the electrical stimulus is initialized to a preset value by removal of the first electrode (78) from the tooth for a longer than a predetermined period, the display (102,. 104) is operatively associated with the stimulus circuitry and retains the indication of electrical stimulus intensity subsequent to termination of the initiate signal and automatically removes the indication of electrical stimulus intensity and resets the indication of the electrical stimulus to a predetermined value upon subsequent commencement of the initiate signal.

2. Testing device as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that, the contact detector (82, 98) is operable independently from the stimulus circuitry (28, 30, 36, 38, 52, 60, 62, 66), such that the contact detector may be actuated prior to generation of the stimulus.

3. Testing device as claimed in claims 1 or 2, characterized in that, the rate at which the intensity of the stimulus increases is adjustable.

4. Testing device as claimed in one of claims 1-3, characterized in that there is provided a counter (100) for counting the number of pulses generated by a signal generator (28) during the period the initiate signal is being produced and, a display (102, 104) for displaying the contents of the counter.

5. Testing device as claimed in claim 4, characterized in that the signal generator (28) is provided to maintain the duration of the pulses constant responsive to termination of the initiate signal for less than a predetermined period such that the intensity of the electric stimulus remains constant when the first electrode (78) loses contact with the tooth for less than a predetermined period.

6. Testing devices at least as claimed in claim 4, characterized in that the counter (100) is reset to an initial value at the commencement of the initiate signal such that the digital display (102, 104) indicates the maximum value of the electrical stimulus after the first electrode (78) is removed from the tooth until the first electrode subsequently contacts the tooth.

7. Testing device as claimed in one of claims 1-6, characterized in that the probe (12) includes a contact indicator (98) for producing a visual indication of the initiate signal thereby producing a visual indication of electrical contact with the tooth.

8. Testing device as claimed in one of claims 4-7, characterized in that the signal generator (28) is voltage controlled and there is provided a capacitor (38) having a pair of electrical contacts, one of which is maintained at a fixed potential, a timer (30, 32) triggered by the pulses from the voltage controlled signal generator (28) for periodically generating a stimulus increase signal in response thereto, and an electrical circuitry (46) to charge on the capacitor responsive to the stimulus increase signal such that the voltage across the capacitor incrementally varies with time thereby generating the pulse control signal for the voltage controlled pulse generator (28) on the other of the capacitor contacts.

9. Testing device as claimed in one of claims 4-8, characterized in that there is provided a transformer (66) having its primary driven by the signal generator (28), and its secondary connected between the first and second electrodes (78, 74), the transformer having a relatively slow response time such that the transformer remains unsaturated when receiving the longest duration of the pulses, such that the magnitude of the signal across the secondary is proportional to the width of the pulses.

10. Testing device as claimed in claim 9, characterized in that a voltage which is proportional to the pulse control signal is applied to the primary of the transformer (66) for allowing current to flow through the primary responsive to pulses from the pulse generator (28) such that the pulses are generated across the electrodes (78, 74) having an amplitude proportional to the amplitude of the pulse control signal and a frequency corresponding to the frequency of the pulses from the pulse generator.

11. Testing device as claimed in one of claims 4-10, characterized in that there is provided a gate circuitry (60) for intermittently transmitting the pulses of the signal generator (28) such that the electrical stimulation is produced in intermittent bursts of pulsating signals thereby allowing the pulpal tooth nerve to reset between the bursts.