Letter to the Editor

Dear Editor

We read with interest the recent paper by Qin Wang and colleagues published in Respiratory Research (2013, 14:67, doi:10.1186/1465-9921-14-67), addressing epithelial mesenchymal transition (EMT) in COPD airways [1]. This is an important new area and it is quite reassuring that leading respiratory journals are now recognising the potential importance of EMT in pathogenesis of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and its deadly consequences. In this paper the authors conclude that increased urokinase plasminogen activator receptor (uPAR) expression in the small airway epithelium of patients with COPD is a manifestation of an active EMT process [1]. However, we have some issues with the paper.

Firstly, in the discussion Qin Wang and et al. questioned the relevance of our findings on active EMT in large airways of COPD patients. We agree that EMT-type-2 may be involved in pathogenesis of small airway and obliteration. However, a second major feature of COPD, namely, the striking vulnerability of early stage COPD to development of lung cancer [2–4], is also poorly understood. We have suggested that EMT-type-3 in larger airways provides an explanation [2–9]. Wang and et al. have missed this point in our paper, by being overly focused on EMT in small airways, EMT also seems to feature in idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF) and bronchiolitis obliterans syndrome (BOS) [2–11].

EMT when associated with increased angiogenesis of the reticular basement membrane (Rbm) and indeed epithelium itself (Figure 1), leads to the formation of a pro-cancer stroma (EMT-type-3) in contrast to mainly fibrosis-associated EMT-type-2 which lacks angiogenesis [2–4, 7–9, 12]. It is thought that this aberrant vessel plexus gives immune protection to developing malignant cells by preventing egress and local activity of natural killer (NK) cells [13, 14]. Fibroblasts originated from type-3 EMT are designated as “cancer-associated fibroblasts” [15]. This is well described in other epithelial malignancies [16]. It is of interest and relevance in this context that over 90% of human cancer arises in epithelia (e.g. breast, colon, stomach, liver, prostate, ovary/fallopian tube, bladder etc.), and the involvement of EMT in all of these may be a central paradigm [16]. It is pertinent that up to 70% of lung cancer occurs in the context of mild-to-moderate COPD [17–19], and COPD-related cancer may well be just another example of this core principle of unstable epithelium in the context of tissue inflammation and/or chronic stimulation.

Figure 1
figure 1

Airway tissue stained for type-IV collagen to highlight blood vessels. (A) Small airway section, black arrows indicating vessels in the lamina propria with no vessels in the Rbm or epithelium, typical of EMT Type-2; (B) bronchial biopsy section from a matched large airway, with black arrows indicating vessels with in Rbm and also penetrating into the epithelium, typical of EMT Type-3.

Full size image

Our second major issue is the quality of immunostaining of small airway sections for EMT bio-markers in the Wang paper. In Figure 1A, the serial sections from COPD patients stained for E-cadherin (b) and vimentin (d) are not convincing. There is indeed decreased expression of E-cadherin in the epithelium but the authors failed to point out what other cells are staining for E-cadherin nearly 150 microns deep in the lamina propria (LP). If they have migrated from the epithelium they should have lost E-cadherin and should be positive for vimentin in the LP. This suggests some artefact; perhaps the authors should have considered double immunostaining for these markers. In addition, the non-smoker small airway tissue section demonstrates a quite hyperplastic appearance of the epithelium, suggesting aberrant phenotyping.

Finally, the authors show correlations between the expression of cell mesenchymal markers in small airways and lung function for all the 78 subjects together. However, this includes quite distinct groups, including normal, which are bound to give such a relationship. What is needed is an analysis of obstructed participants only, to see if greater expression of markers is related to increased loss of function. This seems unlikely from the data shown.

Inspite of our reservations, this is still an important study which highlights the potential of EMT to be central to COPD pathophysiology. Acceptance of this new concept will change the very way we think about this disease process and its nasty clinical consequences.