Abstract
Environmental threats and progressive degradation of natural resources are considered critical impediments to sustainable development. This paper reports on a participatory impact assessment of alternative soil and water conservation (SWC) scenarios in the Oum Zessar watershed, Tunisia. The first objective was to assess the impact of three SWC scenarios on key social, economic and environmental land use functions. The second objective was to test and evaluate the applicability of the ‘Framework for Participatory Impact Assessment (FoPIA)’ for assessing scenario impacts in the context of a developing country, in this case Tunisia. The assessed scenarios included: the originally planned SWC policy implementation at 85 % coverage of arable land of the watershed, the current implementation (70 %), and a hypothetical expansion of SWC measures to the entire watershed (100 %). Our results suggest that implementation of the SWC policy at 100 % coverage of arable land achieves the maximum socioeconomic benefit. However, if stakeholders’ preferences regarding land use functions are taken into account, and considering the fact that the implementation of SWC measures also implies some negative changes to traditional landscapes and the natural system, SWC implementation at 85 % coverage of arable land might be preferable. The FoPIA approved to be a useful tool for conducting a holistic sustainability impact assessment of SWC scenarios and for studying the most intriguing sustainability problems while providing possible recommendations towards sustainable development. We conclude that participatory impact assessment contributes to an enhanced regional understanding of key linkages between policy effects and sustainable development, which provides the foundation for improved policy decision making.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
Notes
National Institute of Statistics, Tunisia.
References
Amsalu A, de Graaff J (2007) Determinants of adoption and continued use of stone terraces for soil and water conservation in an Ethiopian highland watershed. Ecological Economics 61:294–302
Bacic ILZ, Bregt AK, Rossiter DG (2006) A participatory approach for integrating risk assessment into rural decision-making: a case study in Santa Catarina, Brazil. Agricultural Systems 87:229–244
Baur H, Poulter G, Puccioni M, Castro P, Lutzeyer HJ, Krall S (2003) Impact assessment and evaluation in agricultural research for development. Agricultural Systems 78:329–336
Bennett EM, Peterson GD, Gordon LJ (2009) Understanding relationships among multiple ecosystem services. Ecology Letters 12:1394–1404
Binder CR, Feola G, Steinberger JK (2010) Considering the normative, systemic and procedural dimensions in indicator-based sustainability assessments in agriculture. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 30:71–81
Boulanger PM, Brechet T (2005) Models for policy-making in sustainable development: the state of the art and perspectives for research. Ecological Economics 55:337–350
Brismar A (2002) River systems as providers of goods and services: a basis for comparing desired and undesired effects of large dam projects. Environmental Management 29:598–609
Commission of the European Communities (CEC) (2005) Impact assessment guidelines
European Commission SEC (2005) 791, European Commission. 10-5-2007. http://www.mfcr.cz/cps/rde/xbcr/mfcr/SEC2005791ImpactAssessmentGuidelines2006update.pdf
De Ridder W, Turnpenny J, Nilsson M, Von Raggamby A (2007) A framework for tool selection and use in integrated assessment for sustainable development. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management 9:423–441
De Smedt P (2010) The use of impact assessment tools to support sustainable policy objectives in Europe. Ecology and Society 15:Art.30
Dhehibi B, Lachaal L (2006) Empirical evidence of productivity growth in Tunisian agriculture: 1961-2000. African Development Review-Revue Africaine de Developpement 18:248–257
Diaz-Balteiro L, Romero C (2004) In search of a natural systems sustainability index. Ecological Economics 49:401–405
Fleskens L, Stroosnijder L, Ouessar M, De Graaff J (2005) Evaluation of the on-site impact of water harvesting in southern Tunisia. Journal of Arid Environments 62:613–630
Freeman ER (1984) Strategic management: a stakeholder approach. Pitman, Boston
George C, Kirkpatrick C (2006) Assessing national sustainable development strategies: strengthening the links to operational policy. Natural Resources Forum 30:146–156
Hacking T, Guthrie P (2002) A framework for clarifying the meaning of triple bottom-line, integrated, and sustainability assessment. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 28:73–89
Halvorson WL, Castellanos AE, Murrieta-Saldivar J (2003) Sustainable land use requires attention to ecological signals. Environmental Management 32:551–558
Helming K, Diehl K, Bach H, Dilly O, König B, Kuhlman T, Perez-Soba M, Sieber S, Tabbush P, Tscherning K, Wascher D, Wiggering H (2011) Ex ante impact assessment of policies affecting land use, part A: analytical framework. Ecology and Society 16:Art. 27
Hill J, Woodland W (2003) Contrasting water management techniques in Tunisia: towards sustainable agricultural use. The Geographical Journal 169:342–357
Hill MJ, Lesslie R, Donohue R, Houlder P, Holloway J, Smith J, Ritman K (2006) Multi-criteria assessment of tensions in resource use at continental scale: a proof of concept with Australian rangelands. Environmental Management 37:712–731
Holman IP, Rounsevell MDA, Cojacaru G, Shackley S, McLachlan C, Audsley E, Berry PM, Fontaine C, Harrison PA, Henriques C, Mokrech M, Nicholls RJ, Pearn KR, Richards JA (2008) The concepts and development of a participatory regional integrated assessment tool. Climatic Change 90:5–30
Jeddi K, Chaieb M (2010) Changes in soil properties and vegetation following livestock grazing exclusion in degraded arid environments of South Tunisia. Flora—Morphology, Distribution, Functional Ecology of Plants 205:184–189
Kates RW, Clark WC, Corell R, Hall JM, Jaeger CC, Lowe I, McCarthy JJ, Schellnhuber HJ, Bolin B, Dickson NM, Faucheux S, Gallopin GC, Grubler A, Huntley B, Jager J, Jodha NS, Kasperson RE, Mabogunje A, Matson P, Mooney H, Moore B, O’Riordan T, Svedin U (2001) Environment and development—Sustainability science. Science 292:641–642
Kirkpatrick C, Parker D (2004) Regulatory impact assessment and regulatory governance in developing countries. Public Administration and Development 24:333–344
König HJ, Schuler J, Suarma U, McNeill D, Imbernon J, Damayanti F, Dalimunthe SA, Uthes S, Sartohadi J, Helming K, Morris J (2010) Assessing the impact of land use policy on urban-rural sustainability using the FoPIA Approach in Yogyakarta, Indonesia. Sustainability 2:1991–2009
König HJ, Zhen L, Helming K, Uthes S, Yang L, Xiaochang C, Wiggering H (in press) Assessing the impact of the SLCP land conversion program on rural sustainability in Guyuan, Western China. Land Degradation & Development.
Lambin EF, Turner BL, Geist HJ, Agbola SB, Angelsen A, Bruce JW, Coomes OT, Dirzo R, Fischer G, Folke C, George PS, Homewood K, Imbernon J, Leemans R, Li XB, Moran EF, Mortimore M, Ramakrishnan PS, Richards JF, Skanes H, Steffen W, Stone GD, Svedin U, Veldkamp TA, Vogel C, Xu JC (2001) The causes of land-use and land-cover change: moving beyond the myths. Global Environmental Change-Human and Policy Dimensions 11:261–269
Linkov I, Satterstrom FK, Kiker G, Batchelor C, Bridges T, Ferguson E (2006) From comparative risk assessment to multi-criteria decision analysis and adaptive management: recent developments and applications. Environment International 32:1072–1093
Liu J, Dietz T, Carpenter SR, Alberti M, Folke C, Moran E, Pell AN, Deadman P, Kratz T, Lubchenco J, Ostrom E, Ouyang Z, Provencher W, Redman CL, Schneider SH, Taylor WW (2007) Complexity of coupled human and natural systems. Science 317:1513–1516
Morris J, Tassone V, De Groot R, Camilleri M, Moncada S (2011) A Framework for Participatory Impact Assessment’ (FoPIA): involving stakeholders in European policy-making, a case study of land use change in Malta. Ecology and Society 16:Art. 12
O’Farrell PJ, Anderson PM (2010) Sustainable multifunctional landscapes: a review to implementation. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability 2:59–65
Ouessar M, Sghaier M, Mahdhi N, Abdelli F, De Graaff J, Chaieb H, Yahyaoui H, Gabriels D (2004) An integrated approach for impact assessment of water harvesting techniques in dry areas: the case of oued oum zessar watershed (Tunisia). Environmental Monitoring and Assessment 99:127–140
Ouessar M, Bruggeman A, Mohtar R, Ouerchefani D, Abdelli F, Boufelgha M (2009) An Overview of Evaluation and Impact Assessment Tools for Water Harvesting. In: Lee C, Schaaf T (eds) The future of drylands. Springer, Netherlands, pp 255–267
Paracchini ML, Pacini C, Jones MLM, Perez-Soba M (2011) An aggregation framework to link indicators associated with multifunctional land use to the stakeholder evaluation of policy options. Ecological Indicators 11:71–80
Pérez-Soba M, Petit S, Jones L, Bertrand N, Briquel V, Omodei-Zorini L, Contini C, Helming K, Farrington JH, Mossello MT, Wascher D, Kienast F, Groot R (2008) Land use functions—a multifunctionality approach to assess the impact of land use changes on land use sustainability. In: Helming K, Pérez-Soba M, Tabbush P (eds) Sustainability impact assessment of land use changes. Springer, Berlin, pp 375–404
Pope J, Grace W (2006) Sustainability assessment in context: issues of process, policy and governance. Journal of Environmental Assessment Policy and Management 8:373–398
Reed MS (2008) Stakeholder participation for environmental management: a literature review. Biological Conservation 141:2417–2431
Reidsma P, König H, Feng S, Bezlepkina I, Nesheim I, Bonin M, Sghaier M, Purushothaman S, Sieber S, van Ittersum MK, Brouwer F (2011) Methods and tools for integrated assessment of land use policies on sustainable development in developing countries. Land Use Policy 28:604–617
Rotmans J (1998) Methods for IA: the challenges and opportunities ahead. Environmental Modeling and Assessment 3:155–179
Schiettecatte W, Ouessar M, Gabriels D, Tanghe S, Heirman S, Abdelli F (2005) Impact of water harvesting techniques on soil and water conservation: a case study on a micro catchment in southeastern Tunisia. Journal of Arid Environments 61:297–313
Schößer B, Helming K, Wiggering H (2010) Assessing land use change impacts—a comparison of the SENSOR land use function approach with other frameworks. Journal of Land Use Science 5:159–178
Scrieciu SS (2007) The inherent dangers of using computable general equilibrium models as a single integrated modelling framework for sustainability impact assessment. A critical note on Bohringer and Löschel (2006). Ecological Economics 60:678–684
Sghaier M, Ounalli N, Djeder H, Bouzaida MA (2009) D 3.1—overview and analysis of land use policies in Tunisia. LUPIS, E. 6. F. P. w. l. e
Sheate WR, do Partidario MR, Byron H, Bina O, Dagg S (2008) Sustainability assessment of future scenarios: methodology and application to mountain areas of Europe. Environmental Management 41:282–299
Sieber S, Müller K, Verweij P, Haraldsson H, Fricke K, Pacini C, Tscherning K, Helming K, Jansson T (2008) Transfer into decision support: the sustainability impact assessment tool. Springer, New York, pp 107–128
Singh RK, Murty HR, Gupta SK, Dikshit AK (2009) An overview of sustainability assessment methodologies. Ecological Indicators 9:189–212
Slee B (2007) Social indicators of multifunctional rural land use: the case of forestry in the UK. Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 120:31–40
Smeets E, Weterings R (1999) Environmental indicators: typology and overview. European Environmental Agency (EAA), Copenhagen
Steinfeld H, Mooney HA, Schmeider F, Neville LE (2010) Livestock in a changing landscape, vol 1. Drivers, consequences and responses. Island Press, Washington DC
Thabrew L, Wiek A, Ries R (2009) Environmental decision making in multi-stakeholder contexts: applicability of life cycle thinking in development planning and implementation. Journal of Cleaner Production 17:67–76
Tscherning K, König H, Schößer B, Helming K, Sieber S (2008) Ex-ante Impact Assessments (IA) in the European Commission—an overview. In: Helming K, Pérez-Soba M, Tabbush P (eds) Sustainability impact assessment of land use changes. Springer, Berlin, pp 17–33
Uthes S, Fricke K, König H, Zander P, van Ittersum M, Sieber S, Helming K, Piorr A, Müller K (2010) Policy relevance of three integrated assessment tools—A comparison with specific reference to agricultural policies. Ecological Modelling 221:2136–2152
van Ittersum MK, Ewert F, Heckelei T, Wery J, Olsson JA, Andersen E, Bezlepkina I, Brouwer F, Donatelli M, Flichman G, Olsson L, Rizzoli AE, van der Wal T, Wien JE, Wolf J (2008) Integrated assessment of agricultural systems—A component-based framework for the European Union (SEAMLESS). Agricultural Systems 96:150–165
Walmsley JJ (2002) Framework for measuring sustainable development in catchment systems. Environmental Management 29:195–206
Walter C, Stutzel H (2009) A new method for assessing the sustainability of land-use systems (II): evaluating impact indicators. Ecological Economics 68:1288–1300
Walz R (2000) Development of environmental indicator systems: experiences from Germany. Environmental Management 25:613–623
Wiggering H, Dalchow C, Glemnitz M, Helming K, Müller K, Schultz A, Stachow U, Zander P (2006) Indicators for multifunctional land use—Linking socio-economic requirements with landscape potentials. Ecological Indicators 6:238–249
Zhen L, Cao S, Wei Y, Dilly O, Liu X, Li F, Koenig H, Tscherning K, Helming K (2009) Comparison of sustainability issues in two sensitive areas of China. Environmental Science & Policy 12:1153–1167
Zhu X, Dale AP (2000) Identifying opportunities for decision support systems in support of regional resource use planning: an approach through soft systems methodology. Environmental Management 26:371–384
Acknowledgments
The work in this publication was supported by the LUPIS project under the EU 6th Framework Sustainable Development, Global Change and Ecosystems programme. The authors wish to acknowledge first the numerous stakeholders who contributed their knowledge to this study. We thank all the anonymous reviewers for their thorough evaluation and constructive recommendations for improving this manuscript.
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
König, H.J., Sghaier, M., Schuler, J. et al. Participatory Impact Assessment of Soil and Water Conservation Scenarios in Oum Zessar Watershed, Tunisia. Environmental Management 50, 153–165 (2012). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-012-9865-y
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s00267-012-9865-y