8000 Update the contribute guide by alabulei1 · Pull Request #234 · WasmEdge/docs · GitHub
[go: up one dir, main page]
More Web Proxy on the site http://driver.im/
Skip to content

Update the contribute guide #234

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Jump to bottom
Merged
merged 7 commits into from
Jul 8, 2024
Merged

Update the contribute guide #234

merged 7 commits into from
Jul 8, 2024

Conversation

alabulei1
Copy link
Collaborator

Explanation

  • Update Contribute.md following CNCF TAG contributor guideline
  • Remove the location of LLM workload on GPU
  • Add an explanation about the relationship between WasmEdge and Second State

@alabulei1
Update the contribute guide
f4b0442 
Signed-off-by: alabulei1 <vivian.xiage@gmail.com>
@alabulei1 Flows.network Integration
Copy link
Collaborator Author
alabulei1 commented Jun 16, 2024 •
edited
Loading

Hello, I am a code review bot on flows.network. Here are my reviews of code commits in this PR.

Issues and Errors Identified:

  1. Lack of Substantial Content Changes: Several patches focus on minor corrections and wording adjustments without addressing significant enhancements or updates to the contribute guide's content. This could limit the overall impact of the changes and may not significantly improve the user experience.

  2. Missing Context in Commit Messages: Some patches lack detailed commit messages that explain the rationale behind the changes made. Providing clear and informative commit messages is essential for understanding the purpose of each modification within the contribute guide.

  3. Formatting Inconsistencies and Errors: Various patches highlight issues like incorrect formatting, typos, and inconsistent language usage in the contribute guide. Ensuring consistent formatting, language usage, and correcting errors are crucial for maintaining professionalism and clarity in documentation.

Major Findings and Recommendations:

  • It's crucial to ensure that future Pull Requests aim to introduce substantial content changes or improvements to the contribution guide to enhance its usability and effectiveness.

  • Authors should provide detailed explanations in commit messages to help reviewers and contributors understand the context and reasoning behind the modifications made to the contribute guide.

  • Addressing formatting inconsistencies, correcting errors, and ensuring a consistent language style are essential steps to maintain the professionalism and clarity of the documentation.

  • When making changes to links or contact information, consider the impact on contributors and ensure alignment with the project's communication strategy and preferences.

By addressing the identified issues and taking the recommendations into account, the overall quality and usability of the updated contribute guide can be significantly improved, ensuring a more positive user experience for contributors interacting with the documentation.

Details

Commit f4b0442e38ec73b5d3e28319b68abdceb4656547

Key Changes

  1. Renamed the document from "Contributing Steps" to "Contributing Guide."
  2. Expanded the content of the document to include ways to contribute, find an issue, ask for help, pull request lifecycle, and more detailed instructions.
  3. Added a "Development Environment Setup" section.
  4. Included additional information on contributing to the project, such as ways to contribute, asking for help, finding an issue, and attending meetings.

Potential Problems

  1. Document Structure: The restructuring of the document and the addition of new sections could potentially disrupt the flow and organization of the existing content. Review the document's flow to ensure that it remains logical and coherent.

  2. Contributing Steps to Guide: Renaming the section from "Contributing Steps" to "Contributing Guide" could cause confusion if users are familiar with the previous terminology. Consider providing a brief explanation or transition for users who were accustomed to the previous terminology.

  3. Added Content: Review the new content thoroughly to ensure accuracy, completeness, and relevance to the project's guidelines. Verify that all information provided aligns with the project's processes and goals.

  4. Links and References: Check all links and references included in the document to ensure they are correct and functional. Broken links or incorrect references could hinder users' ability to access important resources.

  5. Consistency: Ensure consistency in terminology, formatting, and style throughout the document. Inconsistent language or presentation can make the guide less user-friendly and professional.

As a reviewer, it's crucial to assess the impact of these changes on the document's usability, accuracy, and clarity to ensure that the updated contribute guide serves its purpose effectively.

Commit 6d4d6ff4721b50439f1d933575d85783b86b7e64

Key Changes:

  1. Replaced "our project" with "the project" for clarity.
  2. Updated the Mailing list link to include the "mailto" attribute for direct email.
  3. Corrected a grammatical error by removing the line "\ No newline at end of file."
  4. Minor formatting adjustments.

Potential Problems:

  1. The patch does not address any substantial content changes or enhancements to the contribute guide. It mainly focuses on wording and link corrections.
  2. While the changes are beneficial for clarity and correctness, they are relatively minor in nature and may not significantly impact the user experience or understanding.
  3. The patch lacks detailed commit messages that explain the reasoning behind the changes, making it harder to understand the context of the modifications.

Recommendation:
Given that the changes are minor and mostly related to language enhancements, the patch seems appropriate. However, considering the lack of substantial content changes, it would be beneficial to ensure that future Pull Requests include more significant updates to improve the contribution guide further. Additionally, it would be helpful for the author to provide more detailed commit messages to aid in understanding the purpose of each change.

Commit c4b3f448a16e2c8eb0fd86724a445146d461f6c8

Key Changes:

  • Updated the mailing list link in the contribute.md file from [WasmEdge@googlegroups.com](mailto:WasmEdge@googlegroups.com) to [our email list](mailto:WasmEdge@googlegroups.com).

Potential Problems:

  • The change itself seems straightforward and does not introduce any significant issues.
  • However, it's always good to verify if the new email alias [our email list] is accurately representative of the mailing list to avoid confusion for contributors.

Overall, this patch appears to be a minor but beneficial update to the contribute guide. It should not cause any functional issues.

Commit 00c636224bab36d53b85fcdea98c230b57c0b132

Key Changes:

  • Updated the email address in the mailing list section of the contribute guide.

Potential Problems:

  1. Incorrect Formatting: The email address in the update Mailing list section seems to be missing the mailto: prefix. It should be mailto:WasmEdge@googlegroups.com to function correctly as a mailto link.

  2. Lack of Details: The commit message and patch are brief, making it hard to determine the reason for the change. Providing more context in the commit message would improve the clarity and understanding of the change.

  3. Consistency: The markdown formatting in this file should be consistent throughout. Make sure headings, formatting, and links are consistent and follow the project's style guide for documentation.

  4. Error in Documentation: The documentation may have been misleading or incorrect before the change, leading to the update. It's crucial to ensure the accuracy of the information provided in the documentation to avoid confusion for contributors.

Overall, the main focus should be on fixing the email link format and providing more context for the changes to ensure clarity and consistency in the contribute guide.

Commit ecbfa75e2308b992243c21e91dee3dd8919e6fa7

Key Changes:

  1. Corrected a typo in the sentence about issues needing help in the project.
  2. Updated instructions on how to communicate interest in contributing and seeking help.
  3. Fixed a typo in the sentence regarding marking a PR as a draft and correcting feedback timelines.
  4. Updated links for the mailing list and Discord server.
  5. Fixed a typo in referencing the PR contributor and maintainer actions.
  6. Clarified instructions on maintaining a PR and being credited in the release notes.
  7. Fixed a typo in the section about the Code of Conduct.

Potential Problems:

  1. The patch contains several typographical errors, such as "commnet" (should be "comment") and "miantainer" (should be "maintainer"). These should be corrected for clarity and professionalism.
  2. Inconsistent language usage, such as mixing "days" and "work days" within the same context. It may lead to confusion and should be standardized for better comprehension.
  3. The guidance on enabling maintainers to edit a PR if the contributor doesn't want to maintain it is mentioned but lacks specific instructions on how to proceed with enabling this action.
  4. The patch introduces updated links for the mailing list and Discord server. It is essential to verify that these new links are correct and accessible to users.

These are the main findings based on the patch provided. It would be beneficial to address these issues before merging the changes to ensure clarity and correctness in the contribute guide.

Commit 22faea7e1a768c970fffc331eed6b430f0c75330

Key Changes:

  1. Fixed a typo in the URL for the "help wanted" label in the contribute guide.

Potential Problems:

  1. It seems that the typo in the URL was the only intended change in this patch. The patch doesn't include any other updates or improvements related to the contribution guide. It would be beneficial to have more substantial changes to the guide along with fixing the mentioned issue.
  2. The description doesn't provide details about the reason for updating the contribute guide or any context for the changes made. Providing a clear and concise commit message helps reviewers understand the purpose of the changes and ensures transparency in the contribution process. It would be beneficial to include more context in the commit message.

Commit d27c85cd621939b476d44a1e43f20af0cbca0276

Key Changes:

Potential Problems:

  1. Corrected Link Format: The corrected link format for contacting the team is now in a proper URL format. This ensures that users clicking on the link will be directed to the correct destination.
  2. Email Contact: While changing the link to a Google Groups page is a good update, some contributors might prefer or expect an email contact option. Depending on the project's communication preferences, this change may need further discussion or clarification.

In this patch, the most important finding is the correction of the contact link to a valid URL format. Ensure that the team is aligned with the decision to replace the direct email contact with a link to the Google Groups page and that this change aligns with the project's communication strategy.

@alabulei1 alabulei1 mentioned this pull request Jun 16, 2024
Closed
@alabulei1 alabulei1 requested review from juntao, hydai and q82419 June 16, 2024 16:29
hydai
hydai requested changes Jun 17, 2024
View reviewed changes
alabulei1 added 6 commits June 19, 2024 22:26
@alabulei1
Update contribute.md
6d4d6ff 
Signed-off-by: alabulei1 <vivian.xiage@gmail.com>
@alabulei1
Update contribute.md
c4b3f44 
Signed-off-by: alabulei1 <vivian.xiage@gmail.com>
@alabulei1
Update contribute.md
00c6362 
Signed-off-by: alabulei1 <vivian.xiage@gmail.com>
@alabulei1
Update contribute.md
ecbfa75 
Signed-off-by: alabulei1 <vivian.xiage@gmail.com>
@alabulei1
Update contribute.md
22faea7
@alabulei1
Update contribute.md
d27c85c 
Signed-off-by: alabulei1 <vivian.xiage@gmail.com>
hydai
hydai approved these changes Jun 27, 2024
View reviewed changes
Copy link
Member
@hydai hydai left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

LGTM

@alabulei1 alabulei1 merged commit b301926 into main Jul 8, 2024
6 checks passed
@alabulei1 alabulei1 deleted the update-contribute-docs branch July 8, 2024 15:39
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Reviewers

@hydai hydai hydai approved these changes

@juntao juntao Awaiting requested review from juntao juntao is a code owner

@q82419 q82419 Awaiting requested review from q82419

Assignees
No one assigned
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Milestone
No milestone
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.
2 participants
@alabulei1 @hydai
0