Towards a simplified definition of Function Points

Background: The measurement of Function Points is based on Base Functional Components. The process of identifying and weighting Base Functional Components is hardly automatable, due to the informality of both the Function Point method and the requirements documents being measured. So, Function Point measurement generally requires a lengthy and costly process. Objectives: We investigate whether it is possible to take into account only subsets of Base Functional Components so as to obtain functional size measures that simplify Function Points with the same effort estimation accuracy as the original Function Points measure. Simplifying the definition of Function Points would imply a reduction of measurement costs and may help spread the adoption of this type of measurement practices. Specifically, we empirically investigate the following issues: whether available data provide evidence that simplified software functionality measures can be defined in a way that is consistent with Function Point Analysis; whether simplified functional size measures by themselves can be used without any appreciable loss in software development effort prediction accuracy; whether simplified functional size measures can be used as software development effort predictors in models that also use other software requirements measures. Method: We analyze the relationships between Function Points and their Base Functional Components. We also analyze the relationships between Base Functional Components and development effort. Finally, we built effort prediction models that contain both the simplified functional measures and additional requirements measures. Results: Significant statistical models correlate Function Points with Base Functional Components. Basic Functional Components can be used to build models of effort that are equivalent, in terms of accuracy, to those based on Function Points. Finally, simplified Function Points measures can be used as software development effort predictors in models that also use other requirements measures. Conclusion: The definition and measurement processes of Function Points can be dramatically simplified by taking into account a subset of the Base Functional Components used in the original definition of the measure, thus allowing for substantial savings in measurement effort, without sacrificing the accuracy of software development effort estimates.