On the notion of coupling in communication middleware

It is well accepted that different types of distributed architectures require different levels of coupling. For example, in client-server and three-tier architectures the application components are generally tightly coupled between them and with the underlying communication middleware. Meanwhile, in off-line transaction processing, grid computing and mobile application architectures, the degree of coupling between application components and with the underlying middleware needs to be minimised along different dimensions. In the literature, terms such as synchronous, asynchronous, blocking, non-blocking, directed, and non-directed are generally used to refer to the degree of coupling required by a given architecture or provided by a given middleware. However, these terms are used with various connotations by different authors and middleware vendors. And while several informal definitions of these terms have been provided, there is a lack of an overarching framework with a formal grounding upon which software architects can rely to unambiguously communicate architectural requirements with respect to coupling. This paper addresses this gap by: (i) identifying and formally defining three dimensions of coupling; (ii) relating these dimensions to existing communication middleware; and (iii) proposing notational elements for representing coupling configurations. The identified dimensions provide the basis for a classification of middleware which can be used as a selection instrument.