Marshaling the professional experience of doctoral students: a contribution to the practical relevance debate
Pages 675 - 686
Abstract
In this paper, we propose a partial solution to the problem of the relevance of information systems research by adjusting doctoral programs to the specific needs and talents of doctoral students that have significant prior professional life experience. The purpose of this paper is first to recognize that the "professionally qualified doctoral student" (PQDS) has a different type of knowledge that may give her/him some advantages over other students, including greater symbolic capital. We examine the epistemic evidence for the claim that part of their practical experience constitutes a specific type of "applicative" knowledge that should be considered as different from but of equal value to theory, which has been the mainstay of academic education. Three independent lines of academic research contribute such evidence: the communities of practice literature, philosophical perspectives on applicative knowledge, and cognitive sciences. We argue that PQDSs may benefit from doctoral programs with specific features designed to leverage their practical knowledge. In turn, they may be able to "boundary span" and publish research results in forms that are appreciated by their professional communities. Finally we discuss some practical institutional issues that could be addressed if we are to sustain this profile of researchers.
References
[1]
Apel, K.-O. 1972. Towards a Transformation of Philosophy (G. Adey and D. Frisby, Trans.), London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
[2]
Anderson, J. 2000. Cognitive Psychology and its Implications, New York: Worth.
[3]
Aristotle. 1941. The Basic Works of Aristotle, New York: Random House.
[4]
Barnes, R. J. 2005. Conflict and Ambiguity in Information Systems Development, unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, Binghamton University State University of New York.
[5]
Baskerville, R., and Myers, M. D. 2004. "Special Issue on Action Research in Information Systems: Making IS Research Relevant to Practice-Foreword," MIS Quarterly (28:3), pp. 329-335.
[6]
Behar, R. 1996. The Vulnerable Observer: Anthropology That Breaks Your Heart, Boston: Beacon Press.
[7]
Benbasat, I., and Zmud R. 1999. "Empirical Research in Information Systems: The practice of Relevance," MIS Quarterly (23:1), pp. 3-16.
[8]
Bennis, W., and O'Toole, J. 2005. "How Business Schools Lost Their Way," Harvard Business Review, May, pp. 96-104.
[9]
Bourdieu, P. 1979. "Les trois états du capital culturel," Actes de la Recherche en Sciences Sociales (30), pp. 3-6.
[10]
Bourdieu, P. 1980. "Le capital social, notes provisoires," Actes de la Recherche en Sciences Sociales (31), pp. 2-3.
[11]
Bourdieu, P. 1984. Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste, London: Routledge.
[12]
Bourdieu, P. 1988. Homo Academicus, Cambridge, UK: Polity Press.
[13]
Brown, J. S., and Duguid P. 1994. "Borderline Issues: Social and Material Aspects of Design," Human-Computer Interaction (9:1), pp. 1-36.
[14]
Carvalho, J. A., and Rowe, F. 2005. "Latin Model," in Research in Information Systems: A Handbook for Research Supervisors and their Students, D. Avison and J. Pries Heje (eds.), London: Butterworth Heinemann, pp. 277-287.
[15]
Cheng J. L., and McKinley, W. 1983. "Towards an Integration of Organization Research and Practice: A Contingency Study of Bureaucratic Control and Performance in Scientific Settings," Administrative Science Quarterly (27), pp. 85-100.
[16]
Cook, S., and Brown, J. S. 1999. "Bridging Epistemologies: The Generative Dance between Organizational Knowledge and Organizational Knowing" Organization Science (10:4), pp. 381-400.
[17]
Cook, T. D., and Campbell, D. T. 1979. Quasi-experimentation Design and Analysis for Field Settings, Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
[18]
Dane, E., and Pratt, M. 2007. "Exploring Intuition and its Role in Managerial Decision-Making," Academy of Management Review (32:1), pp. 33-54.
[19]
Davis, G. B. 2005. "Advising and Supervising," in Research in Information Systems: A Handbook for Research Supervisors and their Students, D. Avison and J. Pries Heje (eds.), London: Butterworth Heinemann, pp. 3-34.
[20]
Demers, C. 2003. "L'entretien," in Conduire un projet de recherches: une perspective qualitative, Y. Giordano (ed.), Colombelles, France: EMS Editions, pp.173-210.
[21]
Denzin, N. K., and Lincoln, Y. S. (eds.). 2000. The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (2nd ed.), Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
[22]
Denzin, N. K., and Lincoln, Y. S. (eds.). 2005. The Sage Handbook of Qualitative Research (3rd ed.), Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
[23]
Erlandson, D., Harris, E., Skipper, B., and Allen, S. 1993. Doing Naturalistic Inquiry, Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
[24]
Fedorowicz, J., Gelinas, U. J., Gogan, J. L., Howard, M., Markus, M.L., Usoff, C., and Vidgen, R. 2005. "Extending Business Process Modeling Notation for Successful Implementation of Interorganizational Systems?," Proceedings of the 11th Americas Conference on Information Systems, Omaha, NE, August 11-14.
[25]
Fitzgerald, G. 2005. "UK Model," in Research in Information Systems: A Handbook for Research Supervisors and Their Students, D. Avison and J. Pries Heje (eds.), London: Butterworth Heinemann, pp. 267-276.
[26]
Gadamer, H-G. 1975. Truth and Method (G. Barret and J. Cumming, trans.), New York: the Seabury Press.
[27]
Gherardi, S., and Nicolini, D. 2006. Organizational Knowledge: The Texture of Workplace Learning, Malden, MA: Blackwell.
[28]
Gregor, S. 2006. "The Nature of Theory in Information Systems," MIS Quarterly (30:3), pp. 611-642.
[29]
Habermas, J. 1984. The Theory of Communicative Action: Reason and the Rationalisation of Society (Vol I), Boston: Beacon Press.
[30]
Habermas, J. 1988. On the Logic of the Social Sciences, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
[31]
Hatchuel, A. 2001. "The Two Pillars of New Management Research," British Journal of Management (12:Special Issue), pp. 33-40.
[32]
Hayano, D. 1979. "Auto-Ethnography: Paradigms, Problems, and Prospects," Human Organization (38:1), pp. 99-104.
[33]
Heidegger, M. 1931. Sein und Zeit (3rd ed.), Halle, Germany: Max Niemeyer.
[34]
Heiskanen, A., and Newman, M. 1997. "Bridging the Gap between Information Systems Research and Practice: The Reflective Practitioner as a Researcher," in Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Information Systems, K. Kumar and J. I. DeGross (eds.), Atlanta, GA, December 14-17, pp. 121-132.
[35]
Herschbach, D. 1995. "Technology as Knowledge: Implications for Instruction," Journal of Technology Education (7:1), pp. 31-42.
[36]
Hirschheim, R., and Klein, H. K. 2003. "Crisis in the IS Field? A Critical Reflection on the State of the Discipline," Journal of the Association of Information Systems (4:10), pp. 237-293.
[37]
Hoffman, A. 2004. "Reconsidering the Role of the Practical Theorist: On (Re)connecting Theory to Practice in Organization Theory," Strategic Organization (2:2), pp. 213-222.
[38]
Holmqvist, B. and Bøgh Andersen, P. 1987. "Work-Language and Information Technology," Journal of Pragmatics (11), pp. 327-357.
[39]
Holmqvist, B., and Bøgh Andersen, P. 1991. "Language, Perspective, and Design," in Design at Work, J. Greenbaum and M. Kyng (eds.), Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum, pp. 91-121.
[40]
Holmqvist, B., Bøgh Andersen P., Klein, H. and Posner, P. 1996. Signs of Work: Semiosis and Information Processing in Organisations, Berlin: W. de Gruyter.
[41]
Iivari, J., Hirschheim, R. and Klein, H. K. 2004. "Towards a Distinctive Body of Knowledge for Information Systems Experts: Coding ISD Process Knowledge in Two IS Journals," Information Systems Journal (14:4), pp. 313-342.
[42]
Iivari, J., Hirschheim, R. and Klein, H. K. 2008. "Challenges of Professionalization: Bridging Research and Practice through a Body of Knowledge for IT Specialists," in Advances in Information Systems Research, Education and Practice, D. Avison, G. Kasper, P. Pernici, I. Ramos, and D. Roode (eds.), Boston: Springer, pp. 15-27.
[43]
Khazanchi, D., and Munkvold, B. 2001. "Expanding the Notion of Relevance in IS Research: A Proposal and Some Recommendations," Communication of the AIS (6:14).
[44]
Khatri, N., and Ng, H. A. 2000. "The Role of Intuition in Strategic Decision-Making," Human Relations (53), pp. 57-86.
[45]
Kihlstrom, J., Dorfman J., and Park L. 2007. "Implicit and Explicit Learning and Memory," in A Companion to Consciousness, M. Velmans and S.Schneider (eds.), Oxford, UK: Blackwell, pp. 525-539.
[46]
Klein, H. K. 2004. "Seeking the New and the Critical in critical Realism: déjà vu?," Information and Organization (14), pp. 123-144.
[47]
Klein, H. K. and Hirschheim, R. 2006. "Further Reflections on the IS Discipline: Climbing the Tower of Babel," in Information Systems: The State of the Field, J. L. King and K. Lyytinen (eds.), Chichester, England: Wiley, pp. 307-323.
[48]
Lee, A. S., and Baskerville, R. L. 2003. "Generalizing Generalizability in Information Systems Research," Information Systems Research (14:3), pp. 221-243.
[49]
Lieberman, M. D. 2000. "Intuition: A Social Cognitive Neuroscience Approach," Psychological Bulletin (126:1), pp. 109-137.
[50]
Lyytinen, K. 1999. "Empirical Research in Information Systems: On the Relevance of Practice in Thinking of IS Research," MIS Quarterly (23:1), pp. 25-28.
[51]
Markus, M. L. 1997. "The Qualitative Difference in Information Systems Research and Practice," in Information Systems and Qualitative Research, A. S. Lee, J. Liebenau and J. I. DeGross (eds.), London: Chapman & Hall, pp. 11-27.
[52]
Markus, M. L., and Lee, A. 1999. "Special Issue on Intensive Research in Information Systems: Using Qualitative, Interpretive, and Case Methods to Study Information Technology-Foreward," MIS Quarterly (23:1), pp. 35-38.
[53]
Monnier-Senicourt, L. 2008. "L'influence des caractéristiques professionnelles sur la consultation d'un SGC et la capitalisation: le cas des métiers d'auditeur, d'avocat et de consultant," Systèmes d'Information et Management (13:1), pp. 14-33.
[54]
Morgan, G., and Smircich, L. 1980. "The Case for Qualitative Research," Academy of Management Review (5:4), pp. 491-500.
[55]
Montealegre, R., and Truex, D. 2005. "Focus on the Supervisor: Mentoring," in Research Supervision in Information Systems: A Handbook for Supervisors and their Students, D. Avison and J. Pres-Heje (eds.), London: Butterworth Heinemann, pp. 75-92.
[56]
Myers, M. D., and Avison D. 2002. "An Introduction to Qualitative Research in Information Systems" in Qualitative Research in Information Systems: A Reader, M. D. Myers and D. Avison (eds.), London: Sage Publications, pp. 3-12.
[57]
Orlikowski, W. J. 2002. "Enacting a Collective Capability in Distributed Organizing," Organization Science (13-3), pp. 249-273.
[58]
Pierce, C. S. 1931. Collected Papers, C. Hartshorne and P. Weiss (eds.), Cambridge, MA: Reprint Service Corp.
[59]
Postman, N. 1988. Conscientious Objections: Stirring Up Trouble about Language, Technology and Education, New York: Vintage Books.
[60]
Reckwitz, A. 2002. "Towards a Theory of Social Practices: A Development in Culturalist Theorizing," European Journal of Social Theory (5:2), pp. 243-263.
[61]
Ross, P. 2006. "The Expert Mind: Studies of the Mental Processes of Chess Grandmasters Have Revealed Clues to How People Become Experts in Other Fields as Well," Scientific American, July 24, pp. 61-65.
[62]
Rowe, F., and Pries Heje J. 2005. "Finance," in Research in Information Systems: A Handbook for Research Supervisors and their Students, D. Avison and J. Pries Heje (eds.), London: Butterworth Heinemann, pp. 131-142.
[63]
Stahl, B. 2008. "The Ethical Nature of Critical Research in Information Systems," Information Systems Journal (18:2), pp. 137-163.
[64]
Straub, D., and Ang, S. 2008. "Readability and the Relevance Versus Rigor Debate," MIS Quarterly (32:4), pp. iii-xiii.
[65]
Strauss, A., and Corbin, J. 1990. Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques, Newbury Park, CA: Sage Publications.
[66]
Sussman, S., and Siegel, W. 2003. "Informational Influence in Organizations: An Integrated Approach to Knowledge Adoption," Information Systems Research (14:1), pp. 47-65.
[67]
Truex, D., Baskerville R., and Travis, J. 2000. "Amethodical Systems Development: The Deferred Meaning of Systems Development Methods," Accounting, Management and Information Technologies (10:1), pp. 53-79.
[68]
Truex, D., and Long, C. 2005. "Ph.D. Models: The US Model," in Research Supervision in Information Systems: A Handbook for Supervisors and Their Students, D. Avison and J. Pres-Heje (eds.), London: Butterworth Heinemann, pp. 257-266.
[69]
Truex, D., Montealegre, R., Avison D., and Long, C. 2005. "Focus on the Student: The Phases of Growth and Change in the Supervisor-Student Interaction," in Research Supervision in Information Systems: A Handbook for Supervisors and Their Students, D. Avison and J. Pres-Heje (eds.), London: Butterworth Heinemann, pp. 93-106.
[70]
Van de Ven, A. H., and Johnson, P. 2006. "Knowledge for Theory and Practice," Academy of Management Review (31:4), pp. 802-821.
[71]
Van Maanen, J. 1988. Tales of the Field: On Writing Ethography, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
[72]
Wenger, E. 1998. Communities of Practice: Learning, Meaning, and Identity, Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
[73]
Wittgenstein, L. 1953. Philosophical Investigations, Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell.
[74]
Wyssusek, B., and Totzke, R. 2004. "Data → Information → Knowledge? The Perspective of Media Philosophy on Knowledge and its Management," Proceedings of the 15th Australasian Conference on Information Systems, Hobart, Tasmania.
Recommendations
Using practice theory to investigate professional engineers' workplace learning
FIE '12: Proceedings of the 2012 IEEE Frontiers in Education Conference (FIE)This paper reports on the first phase of an Australian inter-disciplinary partnership study concerned with professional learning of experienced engineers. It is a theoretically motivated, qualitative paper that aims to produce detailed descriptions of ...
Experience-based learning of Japanese IT professionals: A qualitative research
Grounded in the Experiential Learning Theory and expertise research, this study examines the processes of experience-based learning, i.e., acquisition of skills and knowledge from direct experience, at different career stages of different types of IT ...
Knowledge in Software-Maintenance Outsourcing Projects: Beyond Integration of Business and Technical Knowledge
HICSS '15: Proceedings of the 2015 48th Hawaii International Conference on System SciencesKnowledge processes are critical to outsourced software projects. According to outsourcing research, outsourced software projects succeed if they manage to integrate the client's business knowledge and the vendor's technical knowledge. In this paper, we ...
Comments
Please enable JavaScript to view thecomments powered by Disqus.Information & Contributors
Information
Published In
Publisher
Society for Information Management and The Management Information Systems Research Center
United States
Publication History
Published: 01 December 2008
Author Tags
Qualifiers
- Article
Contributors
Other Metrics
Bibliometrics & Citations
Bibliometrics
Article Metrics
- 0Total Citations
- 9Total Downloads
- Downloads (Last 12 months)0
- Downloads (Last 6 weeks)0
Reflects downloads up to 21 Dec 2024