NiMoS on alumina, USY and mixed alumina-USY supports was studied in a batch reactor to assess the effect of support acidity in valorizing lignin dimers by hydrodeoxygenation (HDO). The reactivity of α-O-4 (benzyl phenyl ether), β-O-4 (2-phenethyl phenyl ether) and 5-5′ (2,2′-dihydroxybiphenyl) linkages was investigated in dodecane at 593 K and a H₂ pressure of 5 MPa. A relatively fast rate of hydrogenolysis of the sp³ hybridized etheric bonds was observed for the catalyst supported on the mixed support. With the α-O-4 linkage, the USY supported catalyst selectively yielded deoxygenated aromatics including BTX products with fewer residual C–C dimers. For the β-O-4 linkage, analogous trends have been observed but with more aromatics. Interestingly, with 5-5′ linkages the catalyst on USY and mixed supports can break the C–C linkages without producing other intermediate C–C dimer byproducts. The results show high hydrocracking and isomerization activities of the catalyst supported on USY and mixed supports. This is consistent with XRD, Raman, XPS and TEM measurements, where enhanced dispersion of the active phase was observed. However, hydrogenation activity on the USY support is reduced to a significant degree which results in a large amount of benzene compared to NiMoS–Al₂O₃ that produces mostly cyclohexane. In addition, elemental analysis revealed that carbon deposition is higher on the USY-based catalyst compared to the alumina-based catalyst owing to its higher acidity. However, the potential for superior C–C bond cleavage on NiMoS-USY opens the possibility to valorize technical lignin in biorefinery processes.