Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to present the main idea and rules of the “bucket brigades” and to analyse the modelling approaches and some real case studies reported in the literature. The “bucket brigades” represent a new concept of organising the flow line activities. This principle, first time implemented at Toyota, requires a considerably reduced design and supervision effort as regards the traditional assembly lines. The simple functioning protocol yields the spontaneous line balancing, due to a decentralised control strategy. So, for instance, it is no longer need to solve the Assembly Line Balancing (ALB) problem, which is NP-hard. In this paper, the main theoretical results are summed up, emphasizing the advantages and disadvantages of implementing the bucket brigades and identifying the still open problems. It seems that the bucket brigades have some strong points versus the classical solutions, including, but not limited to: decentralisation, flexibility, adaptability. This study will allow to generally concluding on some new trends in the production systems design and management.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Anderson, C. and Bartholdi, J. J. (2000) Centralized versus decentralized control in manufacturing: lessons from social insects. Proceedings of Complexity and Complex Systems in Industry, September 19–20, 2000, Warwick, UK, pp. 92–105
Anderson, C., Boomsma, J. J. and Bartholdi, J. J. (in press) Task partitioning in insect societies: bucket brigades. Insectes Sociaux, 49(2)
Armbruster, D. and Gel, E.S. (in press) Bucket brigades when worker speeds do not dominate each other uniformly. Operations Research
Bartholdi, J. J., Eisenstein, D. D., Jacobs-Blecha, C. and Ratcliff, H. D. (1995) Design of a bucket brigade production line (www.isye.gatech.edu/∼jjb, May 2002)
J. J. Bartholdi D. D. Eisenstein (1996a) ArticleTitleA production line that balances itself Operations Research 44 IssueID1 21–34
Bartholdi, J. J. and Eisenstein, D. D. (1996b) The agility of bucket brigade production lines. Proceedings of Conference on Flexible and Intelligent Manufacturing. January 22, 1996
Bartholdi, J. J. and Eisenstein, D. D. (1997) Bucket brigades—a self-balancing order picking system for a warehouse (www.isye.gatech.edu/∼jjb, May 2002)
Bartholdi, J. J. and Eisenstein, D. D. (1998) Bucket brigades—a self-organizing scheme for sharing work. February 26, 1998 (www.isye.gatech.edu/∼jjb, May 2002)
J. J. Bartholdi L. A. Bunimovich D. D. Eisenstein (1999) ArticleTitleDynamics of 2- and 3-worker bucket brigade production lines Operations Research 47 IssueID3 488–491
J. J. Bartholdi D. D. Eisenstein R. D. Foley (2001) ArticleTitlePerformance of bucket brigades when work is stochastic Operations Research 49 IssueID5 710–719
Bartholdi, J. J., Eisenstein, D. D. and Lim, Y. F. (submitted for publication) Bucket Brigades on Generalized Assembly lines. European Journal of Operations Research
Bartholdi, J. J. and Eisenstein, D. D. (2004a) A bucket brigade assembly line with walk-back and hand-off times. Working paper
Bartholdi, J. J. and Eisenstein, D. D. (2004b) Chaos and convergence in bucket brigades with finite walk-back velocities. Working paper
I. Baybars (1986) ArticleTitleA survey of exact algorithms for the simple assembly line balancing problem Management Science 32 IssueID8 909–932
D. P. Bischak (1995) ArticleTitlePerformance of a manufacturing module with moving workers IIE Transactions 28 IssueID9 723–733
Bratcu, A. (1999) Nonlinear modelling of a self-balancing production line. Proceedings of the 11th European Simulation Symposium—ESS ‘99, October 26–28, 1999, Erlangen, Germany, pp. 481–483
Bratcu, A. and Mînzu, V. (1999) A simulation study of self-balancing production lines. Proceedings of the 1999 IEEE International Conference on Intelligent Engineering Systems—INES ’99, November 1–3, 1999, Stará Lesná, Slovakia, pp. 165–170
Bratcu, A., Henrioud, J.-M. and Mînzu, V. (2001) A look at self-balancing manufacturing lines through theory of hybrid dynamical systems. Proceedings of the 2001 IEEE International Symposium on Assembly and Task Planning—ISATP 2001, May 28–29, 2001, Fukuoka, Japan, pp. 375–380
Bratcu, A. (2001) Détermination systématique des graphes de précédence et équilibrage des lignes d’assemblage. Thèse de Doctorat. Université de Franche-Comté, Besançon, France
Bratcu, A. (2002) On the modelling of bucket brigades. Preprints of the 15th Triennial IFAC World Congress (CD-ROM, Editors: E.F. Camacho, L. Basañez and J.A. de la Puente). July 21–26, 2002, Barcelona, Spain
Bratcu, A. and Dolgui, A. (2003a) Une relaxation du Modèle Normatif des lignes de production auto-équilibrées (“bucket brigades”), Actes de la 4-ième Conférence Francophone de Modélisation et Simulation—MOSIM ’03, April 23–25, 2003, Toulouse, France, pp. 262–269
Bratcu, A. I. and Dolgui, A. (2003b) Lignes auto-équilibrées: nouveau concept, analyse et modélisation. Revue des Systèmes, hors Sèrie/4-ième Colloque Francophone sur la Modélisation des Systèmes Réactifs—MSR 2003, pp. 195–209
Bratcu, A. and Dolgui, A. (2003c) Synergy, collaboration and self-balancing in production systems—the Bucket brigades. Pre-prints of the IFAC International Workshop on Intelligent Assembly and Disassembly (IAD), October 9–11, Jade Hall, Uzinexport, Bucarest, pp. 78–84
Bunimovich, L. A. (1999) Controlling production lines, in Handbook of Chaos Control, H. Schuster (ed.), Wiley–VCH, , pp. 337–354.
L. Bunimovich (2001) ArticleTitleDynamical systems and operations research: a basic model Discrete and Continuous Dynamical Systems 1 IssueID2 209–218
Chen, G. (ed) (2000) Controlling Chaos and Bifurcations in Engineering Systems CRC Press LLC.
Dolgui, A., Guschinsky, N. and Levin, G. (2000) Approaches to balancing of transfer lines with blocks of parallel operations. Institute of Engineering Cybernetics of Academy of Sciences of Belarus/University of Technology of Troyes, Minsk, Belarus, Preprint No 8, November 2000, 41 pp
E. Falkenauer (1996) ArticleTitleA hybrid grouping genetic algorithm for bin packing Journal of Heuristics 2 IssueID1 5–30
L. F. Hutchinson J. R. Villalobos M.G. Bernvides (2002) ArticleTitleEffects of high labor turnover in a serial assembly environment International Journal of Production Research 35 IssueID11 3201–3223
L. Jung (1997) ArticleTitleA single-run optimization algorithm for stochastic assembly line balancing problems Journal of Manufacturing Systems 16 IssueID3 204–210
Juran, D. C. and Schruben, L. W. (submitted for publication) Modeling the worker, Operations Research. (www.orie.cornell.edu/∼metin, August 2002)
L. F. Muñoz J. R. Villalobos (2002) ArticleTitleWork allocation strategies for serial assembly lines under high labor turnover International Journal of Production Research 40 IssueID8 1835–1852
M. P. Van Oyen E. G. Senturk-Gel W. J. Hopp (2001) ArticleTitlePerformance opportunity of workforce agility in collaborative and noncollaborative work systems IIE Transactions 33 IssueID9 761–777
B. Rekiek A. Dolgui A. Delchambre A. Bratcu (2002) ArticleTitleState of art of assembly lines design optimization Annual Reviews in Control 26 IssueID2 163–174
J. L. Reyes J. Fernández Haeger (1999) ArticleTitleSequential co-operative load transport in the seed-harvesting ant Messor barbarus Insectes Sociaux 46 IssueID2 119–125
M. E. Salveson (1955) ArticleTitleThe assembly line balancing problem Journal of Industrial Engineering 6 IssueID3 18–25
Scholl, A. (1999) Balancing and Sequencing of Assembly Lines, : Physica-Verlag, Springer-Verlag Company.
Schroer, B. J., Wang J. and Ziemke, M. C. (1991) A look at TSS through simulation. Bobbin magazine, July 1991, 114–119
K. L. Schultz D. C. Juran J. W. Boudreau J. O. McClain L. J. Thomas (1998) ArticleTitleModeling and worker motivation in JIT production systems Management Science 44 IssueID12 1595–1607
Villalobos, J. R., Muñoz L. F. and Mar, L. R. (1999) Assembly line designs that reduce the impact of personnel turnover. IIE Solutions ’99
E. Zavadlav J. O. McClain L. J. Thomas (1996) ArticleTitleSelf-buffering, self-balancing, self-flushing production lines Management Science 42 IssueID8 1151–1164
WWW 1 www.isye.gatech.edu/faculty/John_Bartholdi/bucket-brigades/resources.html (October 2002)
WWW 2 www.tli.gatech.edu/research/casestudy/cs.cfm (October 2002)
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Bratcu, A.I., Dolgui, A. A survey of the self-balancing production lines (“bucket brigades”). J Intell Manuf 16, 139–158 (2005). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10845-004-5885-7
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10845-004-5885-7