Monday, December 30, 2013
Most Perfect HOF ballots
?Ranked from best to worst, compared to how the Straight Arrow readers evaluate the careers of all these players, using a point system I posted here, and using as the source material from leokitty.
Feel free to draw a line as to what is an acceptable ballot and what is not, with respect to the Straight Arrow readers' view. If you have a different view, create your own point system, and evaluate each ballot under that.
Score Voter- 100 Lynn Henning
- 100 Bob Klapisch
- 100 David Lennon
- 100 Jeff Passan
- 100 Joe Posnanski
- 100 Larry Stone
- 98 Mark Saxon
- 98 Henry Schulman
- 98 Mike Silverman
- 96 Jon Becker
- 96 Tim Cowlishaw
- 96 Mark Hale
- 96 Tim Kurkijan
- 96 Brendan Roberts
- 96 Chaz Scoggins
- 96 Carl Steward
- 95 Bob Smizik
- 94 -- Tangotiger (big 7, plus Schilling, Mussina, La Walker)
- 94 Gordon Edes
- 94 Ian O'Connor
- 94 Peter Pascarelli
- 93 Mark Topkin
- 92 Ken Davidoff
- 92 Tim Kawakami
- 92 Adam Rubin
- 91 Pete Abraham
- 90 Barry Bloom
- 90 Marcos Breton
- 90 David Maril
- 90 Dave Perkins
- 90 Mike Vaccaro
- 89 Joe Henderson
- 89 Buster Olney
- 88 Jim Caple
- 88 Gerry Fraley
- 88 Joel Sherman
- 87 Jose de Jesus Ortiz
- 87 Bob Herzog
- 87 George A King III
- 87 Jack Magruder
- 87 Aurelio Moreno
- 86 Nick Cafardo
- 86 Mike Shalin
- 85 Mike Dyer
- 85 Richard Griffin
- 85 Rob Maaddi
- 84 Mike Imrem
- 83 Marc Maturo
- 83 Bob Nightengale
- 83 Tracy Ringolsby
- 82 John Erardi
- 82 Peter Gammons
- 82 Jack McCaffery
- 82 Scott Priestle
- 82 Troy Renck
- 82 Ken Rosenthal
- 82 TR Sullivan
- 81 Tom Haudricourt
- 81 John Tomase
- 80 William Ballou
- 80 Tim Brown
- 80 Jerry Crasnick
- 80 Evan Grant
- 80 Wallace Matthews
- 79 Frank Clines
- 79 Bob Elliot
- 78 Mel Antonen
- 78 Kirby Arnold
- 78 Chris Bahr
- 78 Steve Buckley
- 78 Jack Curry
- 78 John Delcos
- 78 Jim Henneman
- 78 Jeff Jacobs
- 78 Dave Krieger
- 78 Roch Kubatko
- 78 Carrie Muskat
- 78 Mike Nadel
- 78 Mark Newman
- 78 Phil Rogers
- 78 Bob Ryan
- 77.5 -- Above this line is a definite passing grade
- 77 Bob Sansevere
- 76 Don Burke
- 76 Chris DeLuca
- 76 John Harper
- 76 Rob Parker
- 76 Jayson Stark
- 75 Jay Dunn
- 75 Barry Rozner
- 74 Phil Arvia
- 74 Teddy Greenstein
- 74 Richard Justice
- 74 Bruce Miles
- 74 Gene Myers
- 74 Rick Plumlee
- 71 Peter Botte
- 71 Chris Elsberry
- 71 Jim Ingraham
- 71 Thom Loverro
- 70 Jerry Green
- 70 Paul Hoynes
- 70 Jim Street
- 69 Steve Serby
- 68 Scot Gregor
- 67 Rick Gosselin
- 67 Lyle Spencer
- 66 Fred Klein
- 66 Bob Sherwin
- 65 Garry Brown
- 65 Ron Chimelis
- 64 Joe Goddard
- 64 Mark Gonzales
- 64 Chris Haft
- 64 Ross Newhan
- 63 Jon Heyman
- 62 Steve Simmons
- 61.5 -- Below this line is a definite failing grade
- 60 Phil Hersh
- 53 Dave Lariviere
- 52 John Canzano
- 52 Dan McGrath
- 51 Dan Graziano
- 51 Tom Singer
- 50 Mike Bauman
- 50 Kevin Kernan
- 50 Tony Massarotti
- 47 Pat Caputo
- 45 Barry Stanton
- 42 Chris Assenheimer
- 40 Sean Horgan
- 38 Fred Mitchell
- 37 Michael Knisley
- 35 Dick Kaegel
- 34 Paul Sullivan
- 33 Pedro Gomez
- 33 Mike Puma
- 26 Rob Biertempfel
- 22 Sean McAdam
- 14 Dan Shuaghnessy
- 11 Terrence Moore
- 4 Mark Kreidler
- -2 Hal Bodley
- -2 Howard Bryant
- -2 Murray Chass
- -2 Mark Purdy
- -13 Juan Vene
- -22 Steven Marcus
- -27 Marty Noble
- -80 Ken Gurnick
- -100 -- (whoever submits a blank ballot)
Recent comments
Older comments
Page 1 of 150 pages 1 2 3 > Last ›Complete Archive – By Category
Complete Archive – By Date
FORUM TOPICS
Jul 12 15:22 MarcelsApr 16 14:31 Pitch Count Estimators
Mar 12 16:30 Appendix to THE BOOK - THE GORY DETAILS
Jan 29 09:41 NFL Overtime Idea
Jan 22 14:48 Weighting Years for NFL Player Projections
Jan 21 09:18 positional runs in pythagenpat
Oct 20 15:57 DRS: FG vs. BB-Ref
Apr 12 09:43 What if baseball was like survivor? You are eliminated ...
Nov 24 09:57 Win Attribution to offense, pitching, and fielding at the game level (prototype method)
Jul 13 10:20 How to watch great past games without spoilers