Does not compile on Mac OS X High sierra. #345
Labels
🏭 build
Compilation or build issues with cmake or make?
Comments
|
What GPU are you using? 2012 MacBook Pro's? I can't build this any more b/c I don't have an NVIDIA GPU-capable Mac. I am looking forward to eGPU support (hopefully soon). For reference, can you paste in the entire compiler output here? |
|
I am generally nervous about what version of nvcc works with which version of xcode that works with which version of the NVIDIA drivers etc. ... I've had a lot of problems with that in the past. |
|
Radeon Pro 560, the 2017 MBP's. |
|
Um, Radeon Pro? AMD's GPU? |
|
Yes, as far as I'm aware, the library should be able to compile, and run in emulation mode on the CPU, |
|
Oh. Wow. Um, we didn't know that. I'm really nervous this has nothing to do with "our" code and instead with the compiler-driver-vendorcompiler stack ... |
|
|
For posterity, can you post your compiler version and your NVIDIA tools version? |
|
Yes, |
|
and which Gunrock branch you're using (master?). |
|
Master, as detailed in the official install guide. |
|
I want "which xcode version and which NVIDIA toolchain version". |
|
Oh sorry, It's With |
|
OK, well, i have the exact same setup. But https://docs.nvidia.com/cuda/cuda-installation-guide-mac-os-x/index.html says that we need XCode 9.2. |
|
I thought it meant just the command-line tools. I'll try to install and see how it goes. |
|
NVIDIA (not just with OS X but with all compilers/platforms) has really really strict requirements about OS+compiler versions. Virtually every time we've had reported compiler issues, it's been because the user did not use the blessed compiler version. |
|
Must be a pain. Explains why Apple don't ship Nvidia graphics any more. |
|
It's not an Apple problem, it's all other OSes as well. Example from earlier this week: #343. It is evidently really really hard to integrate & validate a compiler (gcc/clang) with NVIDIA's compiler/driver. Apple no longer shipping NVIDIA graphics makes me sad too, but I think it's an orthogonal issue to the compiler issues. |
|
Off topic rant, but I think it might be related. Nvidia aren't very cooperative (Torvalds famously pulled a middle finger to them, Carmack called them the "The most unreasonable company he'd worked with"). Apple's whole pitch is providing a seamless experience (hence why |
|
Rolled back to |
|
I don't work with Mac and Mac compilation stuff, but it seems like a boost error. And we've seen that the most stable version of boost for us is 1.58.0. Could that maybe solve that error? |
|
Friend in the know took a look at this and made the following comment:
For the time being, @neoblizz's suggestion of using 1.58.0 is the right path forward, I think. |
|
I'll try to uninstall the brew version of boost and downgrade. |
|
@appetrosyan any luck with this? |
|
Nope. Downgraded boost, still compiles with the same error. Could be because the boost version installed by On another note, compiles fine on Archlinux with |
|
So right now I have a Mac (without an NVIDIA GPU) but I've stupidly? updated Xcode to latest so I can't build: I do hope to reproduce this in the future when the compiler catches up, especially if/when Apple supports eGPUs from NVIDIA 🙏 because I have one ready to go, but fwiw, I use Macports & its boost. |
|
i meet the same problem when i compile caffe on MacOs with egpu, I think the reason should be the conflict between Xcode version and boost version, i am now trying to downgrade my boost version to check this problem, you guys have anything new? |
|
We have nothing new. It does not seem like Apple is interested in either supporting NVIDIA eGPUs or NVIDIA's latest toolchain. I'd like to see this fixed. I have two (useless) eGPUs at home and at work that I'm ready and willing to put through their paces with Gunrock. |
|
@jowens i have located the code raise the error, now checking the code line by line, it may take me a several days. |
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
HI. Just tried to compile the library, but the compilation of
... /dep/gunrock/CMakeFiles/gunrock.dir/app/bfs/./gunrock_generated_bfs_app.cu.o
fails with an unreasonably long error message.
I'm using Xcode Command Line Tools v 9.0, to bypass NVCC not supporting clang v 9.1.
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: