Insurance Payor Status and Outcomes in Pediatric Sports-Related Injuries: A Rapid Review
<p>PRISMA flow diagram.</p> "> Figure 2
<p>Summary of key findings. (<b>a</b>) Publicly insured patients experienced delays compared to privately insured patients, including longer times to clinic [<a href="#B15-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">15</a>], imaging [<a href="#B35-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">35</a>], and surgery [<a href="#B18-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">18</a>]. (<b>b</b>) Treatment course shows publicly insured patients had more injury-related ED visits [<a href="#B42-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">42</a>], higher rates of casting compared to bracing, longer hospital stays [<a href="#B37-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">37</a>], and fewer postoperative physical therapy appointments [<a href="#B18-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">18</a>]. (<b>c</b>) Postoperative complications revealed higher rates of repeat dislocation in publicly insured patients [<a href="#B27-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">27</a>], while graft rupture was more common among privately insured patients [<a href="#B18-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">18</a>]. Reoperation rates were higher in publicly insured patients [<a href="#B27-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">27</a>]. (<b>d</b>) Patient-reported outcomes show that publicly insured patients experienced lower rates of functional recovery, including reduced range of motion [<a href="#B36-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">36</a>], lower hop test pass rates [<a href="#B23-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">23</a>], and lower return-to-sport clearance rates [<a href="#B18-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">18</a>]. Privately insured patients were more likely to receive postoperative opioids [<a href="#B16-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">16</a>].</p> "> Figure 3
<p>Surgical wait times and incidence of medial meniscus tears in private vs. government-insured patients. (Zoller 2017 [<a href="#B49-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">49</a>])—This study shows a significant increase in medial meniscal tear incidence, decrease in preoperative scores, and worse tear severity with surgical wait time >6 months. Public insurance was a risk factor for longer surgical wait time and meniscus tear. There was a significant association between government insurance and surgical wait time >3 months (<span class="html-italic">p</span> < 0.001, OR 12.4), surgical wait time >6 months (<span class="html-italic">p</span> < 0.001, OR 7.8), and significant tears. ** <span class="html-italic">p</span> < 0.001.</p> "> Figure 4
<p>Delays to care among college-aged patients. (Johnson 2019 [<a href="#B28-clinpract-15-00052" class="html-bibr">28</a>])—Publicly insured and uninsured pediatric and college-aged patients faced significant barriers in accessing orthopedic services, as demonstrated by substantially longer times between the initial injury and referral to an orthopedic evaluation and surgery; however, these socioeconomic factors did not affect the rate of surgical management. * <span class="html-italic">p</span> < 0.05, ** <span class="html-italic">p</span> < 0.001, *** <span class="html-italic">p</span> < 0.0001.</p> ">
Abstract
:1. Introduction
2. Methods
2.1. Literature Search and Screening
2.2. Quality Appraisal and Risk of Bias
3. Results
3.1. Study and Cohort Characteristics
3.2. Access to Care
3.3. Treatment Course
3.4. Postoperative Complications
3.5. Patient-Reported Outcomes
3.5.1. Pain
3.5.2. Functional Scores
3.5.3. Return to Sport
3.6. Insurance Status and Other Social Drivers of Health
4. Discussion
4.1. Comparisons Within Orthopedics
4.2. Clinical and Policy Implications
- Culturally Competent Care: Training healthcare providers to increase awareness of barriers to care (i.e., transportation), align their practice to support different communities (i.e., interpreters), and assist patients to overcome barriers (i.e., referral to charity care) could help reduce disparities in care access and outcomes [17,18].
4.3. Strengths and Limitations
5. Conclusions
Author Contributions
Funding
Institutional Review Board Statement
Informed Consent Statement
Data Availability Statement
Conflicts of Interest
Appendix A. Database Search Terms
Set # | Search Strategy | Results |
1 Insurance keywords | “Insurance, Health”[Mesh] OR insurance[tiab] OR insurances[tiab] OR insured[tiab] OR Medicaid[tiab] OR medi-cal[tiab] | 274,958 |
2 Pediatric keywords | “Adolescent”[Mesh] OR “Child”[Mesh] OR “Child, Preschool”[Mesh] OR “Hospitals, Pediatric”[Mesh] OR “Infant”[Mesh] OR “Infant, Newborn”[Mesh] OR “Neonatology”[Mesh] OR “Minors”[Mesh] OR “Pediatrics”[Mesh] OR “Pediatric Anesthesia”[Mesh] OR “Pediatric Emergency Medicine”[Mesh] OR “Perinatology”[Mesh] OR “Puberty”[Mesh] OR adolescent[tiab] OR adolescents[tiab] OR adolescence[tiab] OR baby[tiab] OR babies[tiab] OR boy[tiab] OR boys[tiab] OR boyhood[tiab] OR child[tiab] OR childhood[tiab] OR children[tiab] OR “emerging adult”[tiab] OR “emerging adults”[tiab] OR girl[tiab] OR girls[tiab] OR girlhood[tiab] OR infant[tiab] OR infants[tiab] OR infancy[tiab] OR juvenile[tiab] OR juveniles[tiab] OR kid[tiab] OR kids[tiab] OR minors[tiab] OR newborn[tiab] OR newborns[tiab] OR neonatal[tiab] OR neonate[tiab] OR neonates[tiab] OR neonatology[tiab] OR neonatologist[tiab] OR neonatologists[tiab] OR preterm[tiab] OR prematurity[tiab] OR preadolescent[tiab] OR preadolescents[tiab] OR preadolescence[tiab] OR puberty[tiab] OR pubescent[tiab] OR pubescence[tiab] OR prepubescent[tiab] OR prepubescence[tiab] OR pediatric[tiab] OR pediatrics[tiab] OR paediatric[tiab] OR paediatrics[tiab] OR PICU[tiab] OR Pediatrician[tiab] OR pediatricians[tiab] OR paediatrician[tiab] OR paediatricians[tiab] OR pediatric[tiab] OR pediatrics[tiab] OR paediatric[tiab] OR paediatrics[tiab] OR stepchild[tiab] OR stepchildren[tiab] OR schoolchild[tiab] OR schoolgirl[tiab] OR schoolgirls[tiab] OR schoolboy[tiab] OR schoolboys[tiab] OR “school age”[tiab] OR “school aged”[tiab] OR toddler[tiab] OR toddlers[tiab] OR teen[tiab] OR teens[tiab] OR teenager[tiab] OR teenagers[tiab] OR teenaged[tiab] OR teenage[tiab] OR youth[tiab] OR youths[tiab] OR youngster[tiab] OR youngsters[tiab] OR “young person”[tiab] OR “young persons”[tiab] OR “young people”[tiab] | 5,011,769 |
3 Sport injuries | “Orthopedics”[Mesh] OR “Tibial Meniscus Injuries”[Mesh] OR “Humeral Fractures, Distal”[Mesh] OR “Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction”[Mesh] OR ((“Sports”[Mesh] OR “Youth Sports”[Mesh] OR sport[tiab] OR sports[tiab] OR athlete[tiab] OR athletes[tiab] OR athletics[tiab] OR athletic[tiab]) AND (injur*[tiab] OR hurt[tiab] OR hurting[tiab] OR accident[tiab] OR accidents[tiab])) OR ((“anterior cruciate ligament”[MeSH] OR “Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries”[Mesh] OR “Anterior Cruciate Ligament”[tiab] OR ACL[tiab] OR “Meniscus”[Mesh] OR “Menisci, Tibial”[Mesh] OR meniscus[tiab] OR menisci[tiab]) AND (“surgery”[Subheading] OR “surgery”[tiab] OR surgical[tiab] OR operative[tiab] OR operation[tiab] OR postoperative[tiab] OR post-operative[tiab] OR “general surgery”[MeSH Terms] OR repair[tiab] OR repaired[tiab] OR reconstruction[tiab] OR reconstructive[tiab] OR augment[tiab] OR augmentation[tiab] OR injury[tiab] OR re-injury[tiab] OR injuries[tiab])) OR “supracondylar fracture”[tiab] OR “supracondylar fractures”[tiab] OR ((humerus[tiab] OR humeral[tiab]) AND (fracture[tiab] OR fractures[tiab] OR broken[tiab])) OR orthopedic[tiab] OR orthopaedic[tiab] OR orthopedics[tiab] OR orthopaedics[tiab] | 226,099 |
4 | 1 AND 2 AND 3 | 585 |
References
- Trentacosta, N. Pediatric Sports Injuries. Pediatr. Clin. N. Am. 2020, 67, 205–225. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Caine, D.; Caine, C.; Maffulli, N. Incidence and Distribution of Pediatric Sport-Related Injuries. Clin. J. Sport Med. 2006, 16, 500–513. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Popkin, C.A.; Bayomy, A.F.; Ahmad, C.S. Early Sport Specialization. JAAOS—J. Am. Acad. Orthop. Surg. 2019, 27, e995–e1000. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rosen, H.; Saleh, F.; Lipsitz, S.; Rogers, S.O., Jr.; Gawande, A.A. Downwardly Mobile: The Accidental Cost of Being Uninsured. Arch. Surg. 2009, 144, 1006–1011. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Nathens, A.B.; Maier, R.V.; Copass, M.K.; Jurkovich, G.J. Payer Status: The Unspoken Triage Criterion. J. Trauma Acute Care Surg. 2001, 50, 776–783. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Unequal Treatment. Confronting Racial and Ethnic Disparities in Health Care (with CD); National Academies Press: Washington, DC, USA, 2003; ISBN 978-0-309-21582-4. [Google Scholar]
- Haider, A.H.; Chang, D.C.; Efron, D.T.; Haut, E.R.; Crandall, M.; Cornwell, E.E. III Race and Insurance Status as Risk Factors for Trauma Mortality. Arch. Surg. 2008, 143, 945–949. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- DeMartini, S. Pereira Disparities Exist in the Experience of Financial Burden Among Orthopedic Trauma Patients: A Systematic Review. Curr. Rev. Musculoskelet. Med. 2024, 17, 129–135. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Alvarez, P.M.; McKeon, J.F.; Spitzer, A.I.; Krueger, C.A.; Pigott, M.; Li, M.; Vajapey, S.P. Socioeconomic Factors Affecting Outcomes in Total Knee and Hip Arthroplasty: A Systematic Review on Healthcare Disparities. Arthroplasty 2022, 4, 36. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Lakomkin, N.; Hutzler, L.; Bosco, J.A.I. The Relationship Between Medicaid Coverage and Outcomes following total knee arthroplasty: A systematic review. JBJS Rev. 2020, 8, e0085. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Wiznia, D.H.; Nwachuku, E.; Roth, A.; Kim, C.-Y.; Save, A.; Anandasivam, N.S.; Medvecky, M.; Pelker, R. The Influence of Medical Insurance on Patient Access to Orthopaedic Surgery Sports Medicine Appointments Under the Affordable Care Act. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2017, 5, 2325967117714140. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Shi, W.; Anastasio, A.; Guisse, N.F.; Faraj, R.; Fakunle, O.; Easley, K.; Hammond, K. Impact of Insurance and Practice Type on Access to Orthopaedic Sports Medicine. 2020. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2020, 8, 2325967120933696. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Pyrz, K.; Hargreaves, M.; Wood, A.; Girardi, A.; McGwin, G.; Kirk, J.; Patton, B.; Casp, A.; Momaya, A. Does Insurance Provide Adequate Coverage for Physical Therapy Visits for Common Orthopaedic Diagnoses? A Survey Study. South. Med. J. 2024, 117, 353. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Slim, K.; Nini, E.; Forestier, D.; Kwiatkowski, F.; Panis, Y.; Chipponi, J. Methodological Index for Non-randomized Studies (MINORS): Development and Validation of a New Instrument. ANZ J. Surg. 2003, 73, 712–716. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Allahabadi, S.; Halvorson, R.T.; Pandya, N.K. Pandya Association of Insurance Status with Treatment Delays for Pediatric and Adolescent Patients Undergoing Surgery for Patellar Instability. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2022, 10, 23259671221094799. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Anandarajan, D.; Williams, B.A.; Markiewitz, N.D.; Talwar, D.; Wells, L.; Williams, B. Perioperative Opioid Exposure Patterns in Pediatric Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: A Ten-Year Administrative Database Study. Cureus 2021, 13, e13927. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Beck, J.J.; West, N.; Shaw, K.G.; Jackson, N.; Bowen, R.E. Delays in Obtaining Knee MRI in Pediatric Sports Medicine: Impact of Insurance Type. J. Pediatr. Orthop. 2020, 40, e952–e957. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Bram, J.T.; Talathi, N.S.; Patel, N.M.; DeFrancesco, C.J.; Striano, B.M.; Ganley, T.J. How Do Race and Insurance Status Affect the Care of Pediatric Anterior Cruciate Ligament Injuries? Clin. J. Sport Med. 2020, 30, e201–e206. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Brodeur, P.G.; Licht, A.H.; Modest, J.M.; Testa, E.J.; Gil, J.A.; Cru, A.I., Jr. Epidemiology and Revision Rates of Pediatric ACL Reconstruction in New York State. Am. J. Sports Med. 2022, 50, 1222–1228. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Dodwell, E.R.; LaMont, L.E.; Green, D.W.; Pan, T.J.; Marx, R.G.; Lyman, S. 20 Years of Pediatric Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction in New York State. Am. J. Sports Med. 2014, 42, 675–680. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Fletcher, N.D.; Sirmon, B.J.; Mansour, A.S.; Carpenter, W.E.; Ward, L.A. Impact of Insurance Status on Ability to Return for Outpatient Management of Pediatric Supracondylar Humerus Fractures. J. Child. Orthop. 2016, 10, 421–427. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Gao, Y.; Johnston, R.C.; Karam, M. Pediatric Sports-Related Lower Extremity Fractures: Hospital Length of Stay and Charges: What Is the Role of the Primary Payer? Iowa Orthop. J. 2010, 30, 115–118. [Google Scholar]
- Greenberg, E.; Butler, L.; Giampetruzzi, N.; Link, M.; Prati, V.; Weaver, A.; Saper, M. Differences in the Course of Rehabilitation and Outcomes for Publicly Insured Pediatric Patients after Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. Phys. Ther. Sport 2022, 58, 52–57. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Hoch, C.P.; Scott, D.J.; Gross, C.E. Medicaid Patients Face Limited Access to Care for Ankle Sprains in Unexpanded States. Foot Ankle Spec. 2022, 19386400221125375. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Hogue, G.D.; Liu, D.S.; Kaushal, S.G.; Tavabi, N.; Feldman, L.; Stracciolini, A.; Shore, B.; Hedequist, D.; Bae, D.; Meehan, W.; et al. Telehealth Potential in Pediatric Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine Care Is Comparable to In-Person Care but Disparities Remain. J. Pediatr. Orthop. 2024, 44, 379–385. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Hubbard, E.W.; Rathjen, K.E.; Elliott, M.; Wimberly, R.L.; Riccio, A.I. Predictors of Appointment Adherence Following Operative Treatment of Pediatric Supracondylar Humerus Fractures: Which Patients Are Not Following Up? J. Pediatr. Orthop. B 2022, 31, 25–30. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Hung, N.J.; Darevsky, D.M.; Pandya, N.K. Pediatric and Adolescent Shoulder Instability: Does Insurance Status Predict Delays in Care, Outcomes, and Complication Rate? Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2020, 8, 2325967120959330. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Johnson, T.R.; Nguyen, A.; Shah, K.; Hogue, G.D. Impact of Insurance Status on Time to Evaluation and Treatment of Meniscal Tears in Children, Adolescents, and College-Aged Patients in the United States. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2019, 7, 2325967119875079. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Kiani, S.N.; Yellin, J.L.; Houlihan, N.V.; Talwar, D.; Shea, K.G.; Ganley, T.J. Trends in Pediatric Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: The Effect of COVID-19. J. Athl. Train. 2022, 57, 972–977. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Kirchner, G.E.; Rivers, N.J.; Balogh, E.F.; Huntley, S.R.; MacLennan, P.A.; Ponce, B.A.; Brabston, E.W.; Momaya, A.M. Does Medicaid Expansion Improve Access to Care for the First-Time Shoulder Dislocator? J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2019, 28, 2079–2083. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Li, L.T.; Bokshan, S.L.; Lemme, N.J.; Testa, E.J.; Owens, B.D.; Cruz, A.I. Predictors of Surgery and Cost of Care Associated with Patellar Instability in the Pediatric and Young Adult Population. Arthrosc. Sports Med. Rehabil. 2021, 3, e1279–e1286. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Mercurio, A.M.; Coene, R.P.; Cook, D.L.; Feldman, L.; Milewski, M.D. Influence of Sex, Race/Ethnicity, and Socioeconomic Factors on Meniscal Treatment with Pediatric and Adolescent ACL Reconstruction. Am. J. Sports Med. 2022, 50, 2909–2916. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Modest, J.M.; Brodeur, P.G.; Kim, K.W.; Testa, E.J.; Gil, J.A.; Cruz, A.I. Social Disparities in Outpatient and Inpatient Management of Pediatric Supracondylar Humerus Fractures. J. Clin. Med. 2022, 11, 4573. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Newman, J.T.; Carry, P.M.; Terhune, E.B.; Spruiell, M.; Heare, A.; Mayo, M.; Vidal, A.F. Delay to Reconstruction of the Adolescent Anterior Cruciate Ligament. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2014, 2, 2325967114548176. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Olson, M.; Pandya, N. Public Insurance Status Negatively Affects Access to Care in Pediatric Patients with Meniscal Injury. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2021, 9, 2325967120979989. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Patel, A.R.; Sarkisova, N.; Smith, R.; Gupta, K.; VandenBerg, C.D. Socioeconomic Status Impacts Outcomes Following Pediatric Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. Medicine 2019, 98, e15361. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Patel, N.M.; Helber, A.R.; Gandhi, J.S.; Shea, K.G.; Ganley, T.J. Patel Race Predicts Unsuccessful Healing of Osteochondritis Dissecans in the Pediatric Knee. Orthopedics 2021, 44, e378–e384. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Pierce, T.R.; Mehlman, C.T.; Tamai, J.; Skaggs, D.L. Access to Care for the Adolescent Anterior Cruciate Ligament Patient with Medicaid Versus Private Insurance. J. Pediatr. Orthop. 2012, 32, 245–248. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Poorman, M.J.; Talwar, D.; Sanjuan, J.; Baldwin, K.D.; Sutliff, N.; Franklin, C.C. Increasing Hospital Admissions for Patellar Instability: A National Database Study from 2004 to 2017. Phys. Sportsmed. 2020, 48, 215–221. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Rosenberg, S.I.; Ouweleen, A.J.; Hall, T.B.; Patel, N.M. Are Neighborhood Conditions Associated with Surgical Delays and Meniscus Tears in Children and Adolescents Undergoing ACL Reconstruction? Clin. Orthop. 2023, 481, 281–288. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Sarkisova, N.; Smith, R.; VandenBerg, C.; Pace, J.L.; Goldstein, R.Y. Access to Physical Therapy for Pediatric and Adolescent Patients Following Orthopedic Surgery. Glob. Pediatr. Health 2019, 6, 2333794X19848676. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Simon, T.D.; Bublitz, C.; Hambidge, S.J. Emergency department visits among pediatric patients for sports-related injury: Basic epidemiology and impact of race/ethnicity and insurance status. Pediatr. Emerg. Care 2006, 22, 309–315. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Slover, J.; Gibson, J.; Tosteson, T.; Smith, B.; Koval, K. Racial and Economic Disparity and the Treatment of Pediatric Fractures. J. Pediatr. Orthop. 2005, 25, 717–721. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Smith, H.E.; Cruz, A.I.; Mistovich, R.J.; Leska, T.M.; Ganley, T.J.; Aoyama, J.T.; Ellis, H.B.; Kushare, I.; Lee, R.J.; McKay, S.D.; et al. What Are the Causes and Consequences of Delayed Surgery for Pediatric Tibial Spine Fractures? A Multicenter Study. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2022, 10, 23259671221078333. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Smith, H.E.; Lyons, M.M.; Patel, N.M. Epidemiology of Meniscal Allograft Transplantation at Children’s Hospitals in the United States. Orthop. J. Sports Med. 2021, 9, 23259671211034877. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
- Smith, H.E.; Mistovich, R.J.; Cruz, A.I.; Leska, T.M.; Ganley, T.J.; Aoyama, J.T.; Ellis, H.B.; Fabricant, P.D.; Green, D.W.; Jagodzinski, J.; et al. Does Insurance Status Affect Treatment of Children with Tibial Spine Fractures? Am. J. Sports Med. 2021, 49, 3842–3849. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Williams, A.A.; Mancini, N.S.; Solomito, M.J.; Nissen, C.W.; Milewski, M.D. Chondral Injuries and Irreparable Meniscal Tears Among Adolescents with Anterior Cruciate Ligament or Meniscal Tears Are More Common in Patients with Public Insurance. Am. J. Sports Med. 2017, 45, 2111–2115. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Xu, Y.; Duan, D.; He, L.; Ouyang, L. Suture Anchor Versus Allogenic Tendon Suture in Treatment of Haglund Syndrome. Med. Sci. Monit. Int. Med. J. Exp. Clin. Res. 2020, 26, e927501. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Zoller, S.D.; Toy, K.A.; Wang, P.; Ebramzadeh, E.; Bowen, R.E. Temporal Relation of Meniscal Tear Incidence, Severity, and Outcome Scores in Adolescents Undergoing Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction. Knee Surg. Sports Traumatol. Arthrosc. Off. J. ESSKA 2017, 25, 215–221. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Status of State Action on the Medicaid Expansion Decision. KFF. Available online: https://www.kff.org/status-of-state-medicaid-expansion-decisions/ (accessed on 26 December 2024).
- Dawes, A.M.; Farley, K.X.; Godfrey, W.S.; Karzon, A.L.; Gottschalk, M.B.; Wagner, E.R. Medicaid Payer Status Is Associated with Increased 90-Day Morbidity and Resource Utilization Following Primary Shoulder Arthroplasty: A Propensity Score–Matched Analysis. J. Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2023, 32, 104–110. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Halawi, M.J.; Cote, M.P.; Savoy, L.; Williams, V.J.; Lieberman, J.R. The Effect of Payer Type on Patient-Reported Outcomes in Total Joint Arthroplasty Is Modulated by Baseline Patient Characteristics. J. Arthroplasty 2019, 34, 1072–1075. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef]
- Tallapaneni, J.; Harrington, M.; Troiani, Z.; Venturino, L.; Rosenbaum, A. The Impact of Insurance Status on Patient Placement into Inpatient and Outpatient Orthopaedic Surgical Centers. J. Orthop. Surg. Res. 2024, 19, 379. [Google Scholar] [CrossRef] [PubMed]
Author, Year | Study Design (Retrospective, Prospective, etc.) | Number of Subjects | Age: Mean (SD), Median (SE/Range), or Range | Insurance Type (Medicaid, Private, Uninsured, etc.) | Insurance Type by Number: N (%) | Risk of Bias Assessment (MINORS Score) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Allahabadi 2022 [15] | Retrospective | 78 | 15.3 (2.4) | Public, Private | Public: 38 (48.7%), Private: 40 (51.3%) | 10 |
Anandarajan 2021 [16] | Retrospective | 19,821 | 14.2 (3.1) | Non-Private, Private | Non-Private: 9462 (48.0%) Private: 10,359 (52.0%) | 12 |
Beck 2020 [17] | Retrospective | 168 | 14 (3) | Private, Government | Private: 70 (41.7%) Government: 98 (58.3%) | 12 |
Bram 2020 [18] | Retrospective | 915 | 15.0 (2.2) | Public, Private | Public: 164 (17.9%) Private: 751 (82.1%) | 12 |
Brodeur 2022 [19] | Retrospective | 20,170 | 3–19 | Private, Federal, Workers’ compensation, Self-pay, Unknown | Private: 18,074 (89.6%) Federal: 1742 (8.6%) Workers’ compensation: 68 (0.3%) Self-pay: 263 (1.3%) Unknown: 23 (0.1%) | 12 |
Dodwell 2014 [20] | Retrospective | 25,315 | 3–20 | Not covered, Private, Medicare, Medicaid, other | Not covered: 712 (2.8%) Private: 21,886 (86.5%) Medicare: 42 (0.2%) Medicaid: 1494 (5.9%) Other: 1181 (4.7%) | 12 |
Fletcher 2016 [21] | Retrospective | 2584 | 0–4 4–8 8–12 >12 | Private, Public, Uninsured | Insurance status: (n = 2583) - Private: 1508 (58%) - Public: 919 (36%) - Uninsured: 156 (6%) Insurance status of * type 2 patients (n = 583) - Private: 313 (54%) - Public: 247 (42%) - Uninsured: 23 (4%) * these 583 patients are included in the total 2583 | 10 |
Gao 2010 [22] | Retrospective | 3345 | 13.8 | Public, Private | Public: 633 (18.9%) Private: 2712 (81.1%) | 10 |
Greenberg 2022 [23] | Retrospective | 281 | 15.7 (1.9) | Public, Private | Public: 128 (45.6%) Private: 153 (54.4%) | 12 |
Hoch 2022 [24] | Prospective/Simulated survey | 96 offices | Fictitious 16-year-old | Medicaid, BCBS | Number of calls: 192 - Medicaid: 96 - BCBS: 96 | 6 |
Hogue 2024 [25] | Retrospective | 334,659 orthopedic sports medicine visits | NR | Public, Private | NR | 12 |
Hubbard 2022 [26] | Retrospective | 560 | 5.2 | Government, Private, Uninsured | Government: 278 (63.5%) Private: 121 (27.6%) Uninsured: 39 (8.9%) | 12 |
Hung 2020 [27] | Retrospective | 55 | 14.81 (1.68) | Private, Public | Private: 18 Public: 37 | 12 |
Johnson 2019 [28] | Retrospective | 332 traumatic meniscal tears, 237 included in the study | 16.92 (2.72) | Public, Private, Uninsured | Public: 117 (49.4%) Private: 63 (26.6%) Uninsured: 57 (24.0%) | 12 |
Kiani 2022 [29] | Retrospective | 24,843 | 14.89 (10.39–19.37) | Private, Public, Uninsured, Other, Unknown | Pre-pandemic (Jan 2016 to Feb 2020) - Private: 10,345 (53.9%) - Public: 7261 (37.8%) - Uninsured: 166 (0.9%) - Other: 1237 (6.4%) - Unknown: 16,833 (87.7%) Intra-pandemic (March 2020 to June 2021) - Private: 3291 (58.3%) - Public: 1925 (34.1%) - Uninsured: 69 (1.2%) - Other: 348 (6.2%) - Unknown: 8 (0.1%) Comparing pre-pandemic to intra-pandemic p < 0.01 Odds Ratio (95% CI) of receiving an ACL reconstruction among pediatric patients from January 2016 to June 2021 - Private: reference - Public: 0.921 (0.857–0.989), p = 0.02 - Uninsured: 1.250 (0.926–1.686), p = 0.14 - Other: 0.950 (0.782–1.054), p = 0.21 | 12 |
Kirchner 2019 [30] | Prospective/Simulated survey | 91 physician offices | Fictitious 16-year-old | Medicaid, BCBS | - Medicaid: 91 - BCBS: 91 | 6 |
Li 2021 [31] | Retrospective | 2557 | Mean age: - Nonoperative group: 15.3 - Operative group: 15.2 p = 0.662 | Private, Medicaid, Self-pay, Other | Private: 1705 (66.7%) Medicaid: 609 (23.8%) Self-pay: 177 (6.9%) Other: 66 (2.6%) | 12 |
Mercurio 2022 [32] | Retrospective | 14,398 | ≤10: 438 (3%) 11–14: 4301 (30%) 15–18: 9659 (67%) | Private, Public, Other | Private: 7699 (53%) Public or other: (47%) | 12 |
Modest 2022 [33] | Retrospective | Outpatient: 2484 Inpatient: 4595 Total: 7079 | Outpatient: 5 (5.4, 2.3) Inpatient: 5 (5.3, 2.4) | Private, Federal, Self-pay | Outpatient: - Private: 2066 (83.2%) - Federal: 345 (13.9%) - Self-pay:73 (2.9%) Inpatient: - Private: 3862 (84.1%) - Federal: 611 (13.3%) - Self-pay: 122 (2.7%) | 10 |
Newman 2014 [34] | Cohort | 272 | 15.2 (2.12) | Private, Government-assisted, Uninsured | Private: 166 (61.48%) Government-assisted: 81 (30.00%) Uninsured: 23 (8.52%) | 12 |
Olson 2021 [35] | Cohort | 49 | Public insurance:16.4 Private insurance:15.6 | Public, Private | Public insurance: 32 (65.3%) Private insurance: 17 (34.7%) | 12 |
Patel 2019 [36] | Retrospective review | 127 | 15 | Private, Government-assisted | Private: 68 (53.5%) Government-assisted: 59 (46.5%) | 12 |
Patel 2021 [37] | Retrospective review | 196 (204 lesions) | 12.4 (2.8) | Private, Public | Private: 160 (81.6%) Public: 44 (18.4) * Number of lesions | 12 |
Pierce 2012 [38] | Fictitious Patient | 42 | Contacted 42 orthopedic offices instead of patients. | Medicaid, Private | Offices accepting Medicaid: 6 (14.3%) Not accepting Medicaid: 36 (85.7%) Accepting private insurance: 42 (100%) | 6 |
Poorman 2020 [39] | Retrospective | 25,413 | 13.9 (2.5) | Private, Medicaid/Government, Unknown | Private: 13,824 (54.4%) Medicaid/Government: 9403 (37.0%) Unknown/Not reported: 2186 (8.6%) | 12 |
Rosenberg 2023 [40] | Retrospective comparative study | 415 | - High or very high COI score: 15 (2.6) - Low or very low COI score: 17 (1.8) - p < 0.001 | Public, Private, Other | High or very high COI score: - Public: 63 (34%) - Private: 117 (62%) - Other: 8 (4%) Low or very low COI score: - Public: 71 (162%) - Private: 22 (51%) - Other: 14 (6%) | 12 |
Sarkisova 2019 [41] | Masked telephone interviews with PT facilities | 54 | Contacted 54 PT offices instead of patients. | Private, Government | The number of centers that accepted private insurance was significantly greater than the number that accepted government insurance (85.2% vs. 14.8%, p < 0.001). | 6 |
Simon 2006 [42] | Stratified random-sample cross-sectional survey of EDs in the National Hospital Ambulatory Medical Care Survey | 33,654 | Age 0–2 SIRV: 0.7 (0.5–0.9) IRV: 17.2 (15.6–18.8) Age 3–5 SIRV: 1.8 (1.4–2.1) IRV: 11.8 (10.7–12.8) Age 6–12 SIRV: 3.8 (3.4–4.2) IRV: 8.7 (8.0–9.4) Age 13–18 SIRV: 5.1 (4.6–5.5) IRV: 12.4 (11.3–13.4) | Private, Public, Self-pay | NR | 12 |
Slover 2005 [43] | Retrospective examination of Healthcare Cost and Utilization Project (HCUP) Kid’s Inpatient Database (KID). | 5511 | Humerus: 7.1 (1.8) Femur: 8.2 (2.3) Forearm: 10.9 (2.9) | Private, Medicaid, Self-pay, Other | Humerus - Private: 1863 (63.2%) - Medicaid: 762 (25.9%) - Self-pay: 223 (7.6%) - Other: 98 (3.3%) Femur - Private: 816 (63.3%) - Medicaid: 340 (26.4%) - Self-pay: 77 (6.0%) - Other: 57 (4.4%) Forearm - Private: 585 (70.9%) - Medicaid: 171 (20.7%) - Self-pay: 39 (4.7%) - Other: 30 (3.6%) | 12 |
Smith 2022 [44] | Cohort study | 368 | 11.7 (2.9) | Public, Private | Public: 141 (38.3%) Private: 227 (61.7%) | 12 |
Smith 2021 [45] | Utilized the Pediatric Health Information System (PHIS) database | 27,168 | MAT: 16.6 (2.6) Repair/Meniscectomy: 15.4 (3.3) | Private, Public, Other/Unknown | Private: 13,602 (50.0%) Public: 12,202 (44.9%) Other/unknown: 1364 (5.0%) | 12 |
Smith 2021 [46] | Retrospective cohort study | 434 | 11.7 (3.0) | Public, Private | Public: 169 (38.9%) Private: 265 (61.1%) | 12 |
Williams 2017 [47] | Retrospective study | 119 | 15.0 (1.7) | Private, Public | Private: 49 (41.1%) Public: 70 (58.8%) | 12 |
Xu 2022 [48] | Retrospective study | 122 | NR | Private (PPO, HMO), Public | Private: 80 (65.5%) - PPO: 67 (83.7%) - HMO: 13 (16.3%) Public: 42 (34.4%) | 12 |
Zoller 2017 [49] | Retrospective study | 121 | 16.1 (9–19) | Private, Government | NR | 12 |
Author, Year | Insurance Type | Time to Be Seen | Treatment Access | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|
Allahabadi 2022 [15] | Public, Private | Time from initial injury to clinic: - Public: 466 days - Private: 77 days p = 0.002 Time from initial injury to MRI: - Public: 466 days - Private: 82 days p = 0.003 Time from initial injury to surgery date: - Public: 695 days - Private: 153 days p = 0.0003 MRI scan before initial clinic visit: - Public: 44.7% - Private: 40.0% p = 0.85 Time from initial clinic visit to MRI scan: - Public: 25.4 days - Private: 12.6 days p = 0.23 Time from clinic visit to surgery: - Public: 226 days - Private: 73 days p = 0.002 | NR | Significant delays were seen for pediatric and adolescent patients with patellar instability and public insurance (approximately 6 times longer to clinical evaluation, more than 5.5 times longer to obtain MRI, and 4.5 times longer to surgery) relative to injured patients with private insurance. |
Beck 2020 [17] | Private, Government | Time from initial injury to 1st visit; days (range) - Private: 12 (3.5–92) - Government: 5 (1–41) p < 0.001 Time from 1st visit to MRI order; days (range) - Private: 0 (0–1) - Government: 24.5 (3.25–59) p < 0.001 Time from injury to MRI completion; days (range) - Private: 34 (16–124) - Government: 66.5 (38–136) p < 0.001 Time from 1st visit to MRI completion; days (range) - Private: 11 (4–24) - Government: 40 (23–74) p < 0.001 Time from MRI order to MRI completion; days (range) - Private: 9 (3–14) - Government: 16.5 (9–22) p < 0.001 Time from MRI completion to follow up; days (range) - Private: 6 (4–12) - Government: 17 (10–27) p < 0.001 | NR | This study demonstrates that pediatric sports medicine patients with government insurance have significant delays in ordering, completion, and follow-up of knee MRI in comparison to those with private insurance plans, even though there is no significant difference in the rate of positive findings on imaging leading to operative treatment. |
Bram 2020 [18] | Public, Private | Mean time to OR after injury (days) - Public: 105.9 ± 111.1 - Private: 69.9 ± 88.5 p = 0.001 | NR | This study identified several disparities in the continuum of care for pediatric ACL injury. We found differences in delays to surgery, rates of irreparable meniscus tears, duration of postoperative follow-up, rates of athletic clearance, number of PT visits, postoperative strength and ROM, and graft rupture along the lines of race and insurance status. There were no differences in rates of contralateral ACL injury or new meniscus tear. |
Fletcher 2016 [21] | Private, Public, Uninsured | NR | Odds Ratio (95% CI) of receiving any surgery, immediate surgery, postoperative follow-up, and delayed surgery for modified Gartland type II supracondylar humerus fractures (private insurance vs. government insurance/uninsured) - Immediate surgery: 1.14 (0.81–1.63), p = 0.45 - Delayed surgery: 2.46 (1.31–4.64), p = 0.01 - Any surgery (immediate and delayed): 1.65 (1.12–2.45), p = 0.01 - Seen for follow-up 2.39 (1.01–5.63), 0.04 | Despite an equivalent number of privately insured and publicly insured patients undergoing immediate surgery for type II fractures, those with public or no insurance who were discharged were 2.46 times less likely to obtain outpatient surgery when compared to privately insured patients. |
Hoch 2022 [24] | Medicaid, BCBS | Mean days to appointment in all states (n = 107) - Medicaid: 3.30 - BCBS: 3.43 p = 0.152 Mean days to appointment in expanded states (n = 52) - Medicaid: 3.70 - BCBS: 4.66 p = 0.145 Mean days to appointment in unexpanded states (n = 55) - Medicaid: 2.88 - BCBS: 2.38 p = 0.723 | Successful appointments by state (expanded); n (%) - Kentucky - Medicaid: 9 (75.0) - BCBS: 10 (83.3) p = 0.586 - Louisiana - Medicaid: 1 (8.3) - BCBS: 7 (58.3) p = 0.007 - Iowa - Medicaid: 9 (75.0) - BCBS: 7 (58.3) p = 0.339 - Arizona - Medicaid: 4 (33.3) - BCBS: 5 (41.7) p = 0.586 Successful appointments by state (unexpanded); n (%) - North Carolina - Medicaid: 3 (25) - BCBS: 9 (75) p = 0.017 - Alabama - Medicaid: 5 (41.7) - BCBS: 6 (50.0) p = 0.723 - Wisconsin - Medicaid: 7 (58.3) - BCBS: 8 (66.7) p = 0.339 - Texas - Medicaid: 6 (50.0) - BCBS: 11 (91.7) p = 0.026 Barriers to care by insurance type and state expansion status; n (%) - ICID required - Medicaid: - Expanded: 9 (18.8) - Unexpanded: 7 (14.6) - BCBS - Expanded: 14 (29.2) - Unexpanded: 10 (20.8) p = 0.152 - Insurance status - Medicaid: - Expanded: 12 (25.0) - Unexpanded: 7 (14.6) - BCBS - Expanded: 0 (0.0) - Unexpanded: 1 (2.1) p < 0.001 - Referral required - Medicaid: - Expanded: 3 (6.3) - Unexpanded: 10 (20.8) - BCBS - Expanded: 1 (2.1) - Unexpanded: 1 (2.1) p = 0.007 | For patients with first-time ankle sprains, access to care is more difficult using Medicaid insurance rather than private insurance, especially in Medicaid unexpanded states. |
Hogue 2024 [25] | Public, Private | NR | Completed new visits for patients with public health insurance - Pre-pandemic in-person: 31.1% - In-pandemic telehealth visit: 30.6% p = 0.057 | Telehealth is a viable method of care for a range of pediatric OSM conditions, providing a similar quality of care as in-person visits with a greater geographic reach. However, in its current format, reduced disparities were not observed in pediatric OSM THVs. |
Hung 2020 [27] | Private, Public | Time to be seen (mean) - Public: 402.38 days - Private: 85.61 days p = 0.000009 | NR | Public insurance status affected access to care and was correlated with the development of secondary bony injury and a higher rate of postoperative dislocations. Clinicians should practice with increased awareness of how public insurance status can significantly affect patient outcomes by delaying access to care—particularly if delays lead to increased patient morbidity and healthcare costs. |
Johnson 2019 [28] | Public, Private, Uninsured | Injury to referral; days (SD) - Private: 9.11 (11.04) - Public: 20.83 (23.89) - Uninsured/self-pay: 67 (115.92) p < 0.001 Injury to evaluation; days (SD) - Private: 13.71 (10.34) - Public: 27.43 (27.01) - Uninsured/self-pay: 64.71 (98.62) p < 0.0001 Injury to surgery; days (SD) - Private: 46.72 (26.76) - Public: 67.97 (44.90) - Uninsured/self-pay: 77.85 (102.29) p = 0.05 Referral to evaluation; days (SD) - Private: 13.51 (15.30) - Public: 17.64 (19.13) - Uninsured/self-pay: 20.06 (27.45) p > 0.05 Evaluation to surgery; days (SD) - Private: 29.08 (21.87) - Public: 50.95 (40.14) - Uninsured/self-pay: 45.38 (127.00) p = 0.0029 | NR | Publicly insured and uninsured pediatric and college-aged patients faced significant barriers in accessing orthopedic services, as demonstrated by substantially longer times between the initial injury and referral to an orthopedic evaluation and surgery; however, these socioeconomic factors did not affect the rate of surgical management. |
Kirchner 2019 [30] | Medicaid, BCBS | Median days to appointment - All states (N = 35) - Medicaid: 3 - BCBS: 2 p = 0.01 - Expanded (N = 12) - Medicaid: 3 - BCBS: 2 p = 0.13 - Not expanded (N = 23) - Medicaid: 3 - BCBS: 2 p = 0.03 | Appointment success by insurance type and state expansion status; number (%) - All states: - Medicaid: 36 (39.6%) - BCBS: 74 (81.3%) p < 0.001 - Expanded: - Medicaid: 13 (27.7%) - BCBS: 35 (74.5%) p < 0.001 - Unexpanded: - Medicaid: 23 (52.3%) - BCBS 39 (88.6%) p < 0.001 Barriers to care by insurance and expansion status; number (%) - PCP referral required - Medicaid - All states: 8 (8.8%) - Expanded: 1 (2.1%) - Unexpanded: 7 (15.9%) p = 0.07 - BCBS - All states: 0 - ED record required - Medicaid - All states: 9 (9.9%) - Expanded: 7 (14.9%) - Unexpanded: 2 (4.5%) p = 0.03 - BCBS - All states: 9 (9.9%) - Expanded: 6 (12.8%) - Unexpanded: 3 (6.8%) - ICID required - Medicaid - All states: 10 (11.0%) - Expanded: 7 (14.9%) - Unexpanded: 3 (6.8%) p = 0.09 - Private - All states: 7 (7.7%) - Expanded: 5 (10.6%) - Unexpanded: 2 (4.5%) | For a first-time shoulder dislocation, access to care is more difficult with Medicaid insurance compared with private insurance. Within Medicaid insurance, access to care is more difficult in Medicaid expanded states compared with unexpanded states. Medicaid patients in unexpanded states are twice as likely as those in expanded states to obtain an appointment. |
Modest 2022 [33] | Private, Federal, Self-pay | The logistic regression showed Hispanic (OR: 2.386, p < 0.0001), Asian (OR: 2.159, p < 0.0001), and African American (OR: 2.095, p < 0.0001) patients to have increased odds of inpatient treatment relative to white patients. Injury diagnosis on a weekend had increased odds of inpatient management (OR: 1.863, p = 0.0002). Higher social deprivation was also associated with increased odds of inpatient treatment (OR: 1.004, p < 0.0001). | NR | There are disparities among race and socioeconomic status in the surgical setting of SCHF management. Physicians and facilities should be aware of these disparities to optimize patient experience and to allow for equal access to care. |
Newman 2014 [34] | Private, Government-assisted, Uninsured | Time to surgery: - Multiple additional surgeries at time of ACL reconstruction: 3.3 months (median) - Single additional surgery at time of ACL reconstruction: 2.0 months (median) - No additional injuries: 1.6 months (median) Underwent ACL reconstruction significantly sooner: - If they were older at time of injury: (Hazard Ratio [HR], 1.2 per 1 year; 95% CI, 1.1–1.2; p < 0.0001) - Covered by private insurance plan: (HR, 2.0; 95% CI, 1.6–2.6; p < 0.0001) Median time to ACL surgery: - Private plan: 1.5 months (95% CI, 1.3–1.7) - Non-private plan: 3.0 months (95% CI, 2.3–3.3) | NR | The risk of delayed ACL surgery was significantly higher among pediatric and adolescent subjects who were less affluent, who were covered by a non-private insurance plan, and who were younger. This study also confirms previous studies that have reported an association between a delay in ACL surgery and the presence of additional knee injuries requiring operative treatment, accentuating the importance of timely care. |
Olson 2021 [35] | Public, Private | Injury to surgery: mean (SD) in days - Public insurance: 347 (466) - Private insurance: 117 (179) - p < 0.01 - 95% CI of mean difference: 31 to 204 Injury to MRI: - Public insurance: 260 (260) - Private insurance: 28 (27) - p < 0.001 - 95% CI of mean difference: 31 to 201 Injury to clinic: - Public insurance: 212 (343) - Private insurance: 73 (168) - p < 0.01 - 95% CI of mean difference: 9.0 to 154 Clinic to surgery: - Public insurance: 136 (181) - Private insurance: 44 (40) - p < 0.01 - 95% CI of mean difference: 10 to 73 Clinic to MRI: - Public insurance: 36 (48) - Private insurance: 3.9 (5.9) - p < 0.001 - 95% CI of mean difference: 5.0 to 30 MRI to surgery: - Public insurance: 109 (177) - Private insurance: 36 (137) - p = 0.09 - 95% CI of mean difference: −2.0 to 43 | NR | Publicly insured pediatric patients waited significantly longer for a diagnosis of meniscal tear compared with privately insured patients, even in a safety-net setting. These delays were not associated with greater tear severity or cartilage changes. Providers in all models of care should recognize that insurance status and the socioeconomic factors it represents prevent publicly insured patients from timely diagnostic points of care and strive to minimize the resulting delayed return to normal activity as well as the potential long-term clinical effects thereof. |
Patel 2019 [36] | Private, Government-assisted | Injury to first appointment (days ± SD): - Private: 48.9 ± 57.1 - Government: 96.5 ± 85.4 - p = 0.003 Injury to MRI: - Private: 44.2 ± 83.3 - Government: 85.9 ± 80.8 - p = 0.021 Injury to surgery: - Private: 90.4 ± 83.7 - Government: 174.6 ± 122.2 - p < 0.0001 First appointment to surgery: - Private: 41.9 ± 65.2 - Government: 78.1 ± 71.8 - p = 0.0036 | NR | Pediatric patients who have government-assisted plans may experience delays in receiving definitive injury management and be at risk for postoperative complications. Our findings suggest a significant discrepancy in time to treatment as well as rates of concomitant knee injuries and postoperative complications between government and private insurance types. |
Sarkisova 2019 [41] | Private, Government | Time to be seen to their first PT appointment (days) - Private: 8.09 - Government: 8.67 - p = 0.33 | Of the 54 PT centers that responded: - Accepted both insurance: 8 (10.3%) - Accepted private but reject government: 38 (70.3%) - Rejected MediCal/BCBS: 8 (10.3%) The number of centers that accepted private insurance was significantly greater than the number that accepted government insurance (85.2% vs. 14.8%, p < 0.001). | Our study found there was a significantly lower rate of children with government-funded insurance that had access to postsurgical rehabilitation. |
Smith 2022 [44] | Public, Private | Timing from injury to surgery >21 days (n = 78) - Public: 39 (50.0%) - Private: 39 (50.0%) <21 days (n = 290) - Public: 102 (35.2%) - Private: 188 (64.8%) | NR | Patients who underwent delayed surgery for tibial spine fractures were found to have a higher rate of concomitant meniscal injury, longer procedure duration, and more postoperative arthrofibrosis when the surgery length was >2.5 h. Those who experienced delays in diagnosis or MRI, saw multiple clinicians, and had public insurance were more likely to have a delay to surgery. |
Smith 2021 [46] | Public, Private | Patients who were seen surgically (n = 365) Public: 149 (40.8%) - Days b/w injury and MRI: Private: 216 (59.2%) | Children with public insurance and a tibial spine fracture were more likely to experience delays with MRI and surgical treatment than those with private insurance. However, there were no differences in the nature of the surgery or findings at surgery. Additionally, patients with public insurance were more likely to undergo postoperative casting rather than bracing. | |
Williams 2017 [47] | Private, Public | NR | There was a longer delay between the injury and initial clinic visit for patients with public insurance (56 6 83 days for private insurance; 136 6 254 days for public insurance; p = 0.02). The time elapsed between the initial clinic visit and surgery was not significantly different between the groups (35 6 26 days for private insurance; 35 6 35 days for public insurance; p = 0.81). | In adolescent patients with ACL or meniscal tears, patients with public insurance had a more delayed presentation than those with private insurance. They also tended to have more moderate-to-severe chondral injuries and meniscal tears, if present, that required debridement rather than repair. More rapid access to care might improve the prognosis of young patients with ACL and meniscal injuries with public insurance. |
Zoller 2017 [49] | Private, Government | Surgical wait times (months) Private insurance (% of tears in each insurance group): >3 mo —15%. - p < 0.001, OR 12.4 <3 mo—68% >6 mo—9%. - p < 0.001, OR 7.8 <6 mo—42% Government insurance: >3 mo—85% <3 mo—32% >6 mo—91% <6 mo—58% There was a significant association between government insurance and surgical wait time >3 months, surgical wait time >6 months, and significant tears. | NR | This study shows a significant increase in medial meniscal tear incidence, decrease in preoperative scores, and worse tear severity with a surgical wait time >6 months. Public insurance was a risk factor for longer surgical wait time and meniscus tear. |
Author, Year | Insurance Type | Injury Type | Surgery | Concomitant Procedures | Follow-Up |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Allahabadi 2022 [15] | Public, Private | Patellar instability | MPFL Reconstructive, MPFL Repair | No difference by insurance status in number of patients requiring concomitant procedures with MPFL surgery (68.4% vs. 62.5%; p = 0.58) | NR |
Beck 2020 [17] | Private, Government | All charts had a “sports medicine diagnosis” of ligamentous/soft tissue injury, structural abnormality, instability, or inflammation. Excluded from the study were patients >18 years of age, a diagnosis other than sports medicine (i.e., tumor, infection, fracture), and/or a lack of health insurance. - Major: ACL tear, full thickness meniscus tear, osteochondritis dessicans (OCD), loose body/chondral fragment - Minor: Chondromalacia/synovitis, plica, discoid meniscus/partial meniscus tear, signs of prior patellar dislocation, hoffa pad edema | NR | NR | Time from initial injury to 1st visit; days (range) - Private: 12 (3.5–92) - Government: 5 (1–41) p < 0.001 Time from 1st visit to MRI order; days (range) - Private: 0 (0–1) - Government: 24.5 (3.25–59) p < 0.001 Time from injury to MRI completion; days (range) - Private: 34 (16–124) - Government: 66.5 (38–136) p < 0.001 Time from 1st visit to MRI completion; days (range) - Private: 11 (4–24) - Government: 40 (23–74) p < 0.001 Time from MRI order to MRI completion; days (range) - Private: 9 (3–14) - Government: 16.5 (9–22) p < 0.001 Time from MRI completion to follow up; days (range) - Private: 6 (4–12) - Government: 17 (10–27) p < 0.001 |
Bram 2020 [18] | Public, Private | ACL injury requiring reconstruction Concurrent meniscus tear - Public: 130 (79.3%) - Private: 530 (70.6%) p = 0.95 | NR | Meniscectomy: - Public: 70/164 (42.7%) - Private: 214/751 (28.5%) p = 0.487 | Follow-up time (days) - Public: 345.6 ± 299.3 - Private 479.4 ± 419.8 p = 0.01 Number of physical therapy visits -Public: 26.7 ± 13.3 - Private: 36.4 ± 16.9. p < 0.001 |
Fletcher 2016 [21] | Private, Public, Uninsured | Supracondylar humerus fractures (N = 2583) - Type 1: 1134 (43.9%) - Type 2: 583 (22.6%) - Type 3: 866 (33.5%) Type 2 fractures (N = 583) - Admitted for surgical fixation: 383 (65.7%) - Discharged from ED: 193 (34.3%) Patients discharged with type 2 fractures (N = 193) - Private: 72 (37.3%) - Public: 105 (54.4%) - Uninsured: 16 (0.83%) | Patients with Type 2 fractures discharged from ED (N = 193) - Surgical fixation: 59 (30.6%) - Closed reduction in clinic: 92 (69.4%) | NR | Odds ratio (95% CI) of receiving any surgery, immediate surgery, postoperative follow-up, and delayed surgery for modified Gartland type II supracondylar humerus fractures (private insurance vs. government insurance/uninsured) - Immediate surgery: 1.14 (0.81–1.63), p = 0.45 - Delayed surgery: 2.46 (1.31–4.64), p = 0.01 - Any surgery (immediate and delayed): 1.65 (1.12–2.45), p = 0.01 - Seen for follow-up 2.39 (1.01–5.63), 0.04 |
Gao 2010 [22] | Public, Private | - E886.0, tackles in sports that cause fall on same level from collision, pushing, or shoving, by or with other person - E917.0, striking against or struck accidentally by objects or persons in sports without subsequent fall - E917.5, striking against or struck accidentally by objects or persons in sports with subsequent fall. | NR | NR | Mean days of hospital stay - Public: 2.50 - Private: 2.08 p value not given |
Greenberg 2022 [23] | Public, Private | ACL injury requiring reconstruction | Age at surgery; age (SD) - Private: 15.3 (2.0) - Public: 16.1 (1.7) p = 0.0003 Graft type (see below) p = 0.0432 Allograft - Private: 5 (3.3%) - Public: 14 (10.9%) BTB allograft - Private: 6 (3.9%) - Public: 13 (10.2%) HS auto (1 tendon) - Private: 27 (17.6%) - Public: 17 (13.3%) HS auto (2 tendon) - Private: 74 (48.4%) - Public: 53 (41.4%) HS auto (2 tendon) with allograft - Private: 4 (2.6%) - Public: 7 (5.5%) Quad autograft - Private: 25 (16.3%) - Public: 17 (13.3%) IT band autograft - Private: 10 (6.5%) - Public: 5 (3.9%) Other/Unknown - Private: 2 (1.3%) - Public: 2 (1.6%) | Patients with meniscus repairs, partial meniscectomies, and articular cartilage debridements were included. Patients with concomitant ligament injuries requiring repair/reconstruction (e.g., medial collateral ligament reconstruction) were excluded. | Time from surgery to first PT visit; months (SD) - Private: 0.34 (0.21) - Public: 0.38 (0.27) p = 0.1672 Time from surgery to hop test; months (SD) - Private: 7.7 (1.5) - Public: 8.3 (2.2) p = 0.0097 Average # of PT visits/week; # (SD) Total visits at time of hop test - Private: 1.04 (0.38) - Public: 0.92 (0.37) p = 0.0049 First 6 weeks - Private: 1.28 (0.48) - Public: 1.20 (0.55) p = 0.1815 Weeks 7–12 - Private: 1.26 (0.52) - Public: 1.06 (0.50) p = 0.0012 Weeks 13–24 - Private: 0.99 (0.45) - Public: 0.88 (0.45) p = 0.0408 >24 Weeks - Private: 0.77 (0.79) - Public: 0.75 (0.69) p = 0.8319 |
Hogue 2024 [25] | Public, Private | NR | NR | NR | Completed follow-up visits for patients with public health insurance - Pre-pandemic in-person: 35.0% - In-pandemic telehealth visit: 29.4% p < 0.001 |
Hubbard 2022 [26] | Government, Private, Uninsured | Supracondylar humerus fracture | NR | NR | Compliant with follow-up visits - Government: 323/351 (92%) - Private: 153/162 (94.4%) - Uninsured: 45/47 (95.7%) p = 0.5667 |
Hung 2020 [27] | Private, Public | Shoulder instability | All patients underwent arthroscopic surgical stabilization in the lateral decubitus position | Presence of secondary bone injuries - Public: 6/18 (33.3%) - Private: 25/37 (67.6%) p = 0.016 Incidence of anterior vs. other labral pathology - Public: 31/37 anterior (83.8%) - Private: 14/18 anterior (77.8%) p = 0.588 | Injury to diagnostic MRI (mean) - Public: 431.97 days - Private: 99.11 days p = 0.0001 Injury to surgery (mean) - Public: 561.38 days - Private: 226.44 days p = 0.0066 There was no statistically significant difference between the 2 insurance cohorts for the time from clinic presentation to diagnostic MRI and time from MRI to surgery. |
Johnson 2019 [28] | Public, Private, Uninsured | Meniscal tear | Total (n = 198) - Total or partial meniscectomy: 111 (56.1%) - Meniscal repair: 77 (38.9%) - Trephination: 2 (1.0%) - Debridement only: 8 (4.0%) Private insurance (n = 53) - Total or partial meniscectomy: 29 (54.7%) - Meniscal repair: 20 (37.7%) - Trephination: 0 (0%) - Debridement only: 4 (7.6%) Public insurance (n = 97) - Total or partial meniscectomy: 53 (54.6%) - Meniscal repair: 39 (40.2%) - Trephination: 2 (2.1%) - Debridement only: 3 (3.1%) Uninsured/self-pay (n = 48) - Total or partial meniscectomy: 29 (60.4%) - Meniscal repair: 18 (37.5%) - Trephination: 0 (0.0%) - Debridement only: 1 (2.1%) | NR | NR |
Li 2021 [31] | Private, Medicaid, Self-pay, Other | Patellar instability | Percent of patients undergoing surgery - Private: 5.9% - Medicaid: 4.9% - Self-pay: 0.0% - Other: 4.5% p = 0.009 | - 25 concomitantly performed chondroplasties - 17 lateral releases | NR |
Mercurio 2022 [32] | Private, Public, Other | ACL injury requiring reconstruction | ACL reconstruction | Isolated ACLR (n = 6061) - Private: 3523 (58%) - Public/other: 2538 (42%) ACLR + Meniscal procedure (n = 8337) - Private: 4176 (50%) - Public/other: 4161 (50%) ACL reconstruction vs. ACL reconstruction with meniscal procedure - Primary insurance (public/other): 1.1 (1.02–1.20) p = 0.02 * Patients without private insurance had a 10% increase in the odds of concomitant meniscal procedures | NR |
Newman 2014 [34] | Private, Government-assisted, Uninsured | ACL injury, concomitant meniscal and chondral injuries | ACL reconstruction | Categorized based on none, one, or multiple concomitant meniscal and chondral injuries | NR |
Patel 2021 [37] | Private, Public | Osteochondritis dissecans in knee | Trans-articular drilling 76 (48.4%) Loose body removal, chondroplasty 28 (17.8%) Osteochondral autograft transfer 12 (7.6%) Fixation with bioabsorbable screw 10 (6.4%) Fixation with chondral darts 9 (5.7%) Osteochondral allograft transfer 9 (5.7%) Fixation with metal screw 6 (3.8%) Intercondylar notch drilling 4 (2.5%) Retro-articular drilling 3 (1.9%) * N = 157. Some patients underwent more than 1 of these procedures concurrently. | NR | Mean: 15.8 ± 6.4 months |
Rosenberg 2023 [40] | Public, Private, Other | ACL injury, meniscus injury, chondral injury | ACL reconstruction | Meniscectomy no association between COI and meniscectomy (OR 1.6 [95% CI 0.9 to 2.8]; p = 0.12) or presence of a chondral injury (OR 1.7 [95% CI 0.7 to 3.9]; p = 0.20). | NR |
Simon 2006 [42] | Private, public, self-pay | Sports injury- or non-sports Injury-related visits | NR | NR | ED visits per 100 person-years (95% confidence intervals) Private: - SIRV: 3.2 (1.7–4.8) - IRV: 8.5 (4.6–12.3) Public: - SIRV: 3.2 (1.3–5.1) - IRV: 17.4 (8.4–26.3) Self-pay: - SIRV: 3.0 (1.1–4.9) - IRV: (6.0–19.3) * SIRV = sports injury-related visit * IRV = injury-related visit |
Slover 2005 [43] | Private, Medicaid, Self-pay, Other | Supracondylar humerus, femoral shaft, radius, and ulna forearm fracture | Humerus fractures - Closed reduction w/o Internal fixation - Closed reduction w/ internal fixation - ORIF femur fractures - Spica cast application - External fixator - Internal fixation w/or w/o closed reduction - ORIF Forearm fractures - Closed reduction w/o Internal fixation - Reduction w/ Internal fixation | NR | NR |
Smith 2022 [44] | Public, Private | Tibial spine fractures | Arthroscopic fixation, open fixation, closed reduction | Meniscectomy | Mean follow-up (months): 10.0 ± 1.1 |
Smith 2021 [45] | Private, Public, Other/Unknown | Substantial meniscal deficiency | MAT - Private: 44 (65.5%) - Public: 17 (25.4%) - Other/unknown: 6 (9.0%) Repair/meniscectomy - Private: 13,558 (50.0%) - Public: 12,185 (45.0%) - Other/: 1358 (5.0%) | ACL reconstruction, osteochondral grafting or ACI, guided growth procedure | NR |
Williams 2017 [47] | Private, public | ACL tear, meniscal tear | ACLR and meniscal repair | NR | The mean follow-up for this study was 5.6 months (range, 1–27 months). |
Author, Year | Insurance Type | Surgical Complications | Revision | ED/Urgent Care Visit | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hung 2020 [27] | Private, Public | NR | Incidence of repeat dislocation - Public: 9/37 (24.3%) - Private: 0/18 (0%) p = 0.022 Incidence of repeat operation - Public: 3/37 (8.1%) - Private: 0/18 (0%) p = 0.214 * Many publicly insured patients elected not to undergo revision surgery even when they had a repeat instability event | NR | Public insurance status affected access to care and was correlated with the development of secondary bony injury and a higher rate of postoperative dislocations. Clinicians should practice with increased awareness of how public insurance status can significantly affect patient outcomes by delaying access to care, particularly if delays lead to increased patient morbidity and healthcare costs. |
Li 2021 [31] | Private, Medicaid, Self-pay, Other | NR | NR | Patients visiting the ED; percent (odds ratio, 95% CI), p-value - Private: 83.3% (reference), reference - Medicaid: 72.6% (0.640, 0.510–0.802), <0.001 - Self-pay: 90.4% (1.881, 1.123–3.151), 0.016 - Other: 93.9% (3.098, 1.118–8.583), 0.030 | Patients with recurrent instability had higher odds of surgery, while Black and uninsured patients had lower odds of surgery. ED visits were associated with significantly higher charges compared to office visits, and Black patients had higher charges than white patients. Minority and uninsured patients may face barriers in access to orthopedic care. |
Patel 2019 [36] | Private, Government-assisted | Decreased knee ROM (stiffness): - Government-assisted: 22% - Private: 9% x2 = 4.51, p = 0.034 Graft failure: - Government-assisted: 8% - Private: 6% x2 = 0.13, p = 0.72 Re-operation: - Government-assisted: 9% - Private: 10% x2 = 0.02, p = 0.88 Infection: - Government-assisted: 4% - Private: 0% x2 = 2.56, p = 0.11 | NR | NR | Pediatric patients who have government-assisted plans may experience delays in receiving definitive injury management and be at risk for postoperative complications. Our findings suggest a significant discrepancy in time to treatment as well as rates of concomitant knee injuries and postoperative complications between government and private insurance types. |
Patel 2021 [37] | Private, Public | Union: - Private: 140 (79.5%) - Public: 36 (20.5%) Nonunion: - Private: 20 (71.4%) - Public: 8 (28.6%) | NR | NR | In this study, Black children with OCD of the knee were significantly less likely to heal than were white patients, even when controlling for numerous other factors in a multivariate model. Although the exact etiology of this finding is unclear, future work should focus on the social, economic, and cultural factors that may lead to disparate outcomes. |
Simon 2006 [42] | Private, Public, Self-pay | NR | NR | Visits per 100 person-years (95% confidence intervals) Private: - SIRV: 3.2 (1.7–4.8) - IRV: 8.5 (4.6–12.3) Public: - SIRV: 3.2 (1.3–5.1) - IRV: 17.4 (8.4–26.3) Self-pay: - SIRV: 3.0 (1.1–4.9) - IRV: (6.0–19.3) * SIRV = sports injury-related visit * IRV = injury-related visit | Sports and recreation are the leading causes of pediatric ED IRVs. Hispanic children, regardless of insurance status, had lower rates of SIRVs than white children, which helps explain the lower rate of nonfatal IRVs to EDs among Hispanic youth. |
Williams 2017 [47] | Private, Public | During this time, 9 complications were noted: 5 graft ruptures 2 superficial infections treated with antibiotics 1 arthrofibrosis requiring arthroscopic lysis of adhesions 1 ultrasound documented superficial vein thrombosis (greater saphenous vein). All occurred in patients who underwent ACL reconstruction. Five were in patients with private insurance, and 4 were in patients with public insurance (p = 0.36). | NR | NR | In adolescent patients with ACL or meniscal tears, patients with public insurance had a more delayed presentation than those with private insurance. They also tended to have more moderate-to-severe chondral injuries and meniscal tears, if present, that required debridement rather than repair. More rapid access to care might improve the prognosis of young patients with ACL and meniscal injuries with public insurance. |
Author, Year | Functional Score or Patient Reported Outcomes Score | Return to Sport or Other Outcomes | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|
Beck 2020 [17] | NR | A systematic review of 11 studies comparing type and timing of ACL repair in a pediatric population showed that patients with delays in operative management were more than 30 times more likely to report instability postoperatively, while patients with early operative treatment were more likely to return to preinjury activity level. | This study demonstrates that pediatric sports medicine patients with government insurance have significant delays in ordering, completion, and follow-up of knee MRI in comparison to those with private insurance plans, despite the fact that there is no significant difference in the rate of positive findings on imaging leading to operative treatment. |
Bram 2020 [18] | NR | Clearance for sports - Public: 83/164 (50.6%) - Private: 555/751 (73.9%) p < 0.001 Time to clearance for sports (days) - Public: 268.7 ± 64.2 - Private: 272.3 ± 71.7 p = 0.7 | This study identified a number of disparities in the continuum of care for pediatric ACL injury. We found differences in delays to surgery, rates of irreparable meniscus tears, duration of postoperative follow-up, rates of athletic clearance, number of PT visits, postoperative strength and ROM, and graft rupture along the lines of race and insurance status. There were no differences in rates of contralateral ACL injury or new meniscus tear. |
Gao 2010 [22] | NR | Mean hospital length of stay - Public: 2.5 days - Private: 2.08 days Mean charge per hospital day - Public: USD 7900 - Private: USD 8794 p value not given | The adjusted mean hospital length of stay was 20% higher for patients with a public payer (2.50 days) versus a private payer (2.08 days). The adjusted mean charge per day differed about 10% by payer type (public, USD 7900; private, USD 8794). |
Greenberg 2022 [23] | Private vs. public odds ratio for passing the single hop test for distance - Unadjusted odds ratio 95% CI: 3.02 (1.48–6.13); p = 0.0024 - Adjusted odds ratio 95% CI: 2.72 (1.27–5.81); p = 0.0102 Private vs. public odds ratio for passing entire battery of single-legged hop tests - Unadjusted odds ratio 95% CI: 1.87 (1.12–3.12); p = 0.0161 - Adjusted odds ratio 95% CI: 1.74 (0.98–3.07); p = 0.0567 | NR | Publicly insured patients average a lower number of weekly PT visits, experienced a longer delay from surgery to hop testing and were 2.7 times less likely to pass the single leg hop for distance test. |
Hogue 2024 [25] | Relative to having private insurance: - Public insurance was associated with lower ratings related to provider’s efforts to include the patients in the treatment decision (p = 0.045) and provider’s efforts to explain the condition (p = 0.026). - Having public insurance was associated with lower ratings in all assessed questions (p< 0.05). - Public insurance was associated with lower ratings related to preparedness for video visits (p = 0.024), and quality of audio (p = 0.001), and video (p = 0.021) connections. | White patients, non-Hispanic patients, and patients with private insurance consistently had a higher proportion of maximum ratings for overall care, ease of scheduling, and the care provider’s concern and effort. | Telehealth is a viable method of care for a range of pediatric OSM conditions, providing a similar quality of care as in-person visits with a greater geographic reach. However, in its current format, reduced disparities were not observed in pediatric OSM THVs. |
Patel 2019 [36] | Range of Motion Stiffness - Private: 9% (6/68) - Public: 22% (13/58) | Injury to return to play: - Private: 336.2 ± 130.4 - Government: 394.7 ± 153.6 - p = 0.044 Surgery to return to play: - Private: 255.7 ± 116.8 - Government: 238.9 ± 98.5 - p = 0.445 | Pediatric patients who have government-assisted plans may experience delays in receiving definitive injury management and be at risk for postoperative complications. Our findings suggest a significant discrepancy in time to treatment as well as rates of concomitant knee injuries and postoperative complications between government and private insurance types. |
Poorman 2020 [39] | NR | Patients identifying as white and female were more commonly admitted for patellar instability between 2007 and 2017. Males admitted for patellar instability were also significantly older than females. | Based on a PHIS database search, pediatric hospital admissions for patellar instability are steadily increasing. The majority of patients admitted for patellar instability are female, white, and have insurance other than Medicaid. Males admitted for patellar instability tended to be older than females admitted for the same. |
Rosenberg 2023 [40] | NR | Patients with high or very high COI scores experienced a shorter time between injury and surgery compared with patients with low or very low COI scores (median (IQR) 53 days (53) versus 97 days (104); p < 0.001). After adjusting for insurance and race/ethnicity, patients with low or very low COI scores were more likely to undergo ACLR more than 60 days after injury (OR 2.1 [95% CI 1.1 to 4.0]; p = 0.02) (Table 2) and 90 days after injury (OR 1.8 [95% CI 1.1 to 3.4]; p = 0.04) (Table 3) compared with patients with high or very high COI scores. After controlling for insurance, BMI, and time to surgery, patients with low and very low COI scores were more likely to have a concomitant meniscus tear at the time of ACLR (OR 1.6 [95% CI 1.1 to 2.5]; p = 0.04) (Table 4) compared with patients with high and very high COI scores. After controlling for insurance and time to surgery, there was no association between COI and meniscectomy (OR 1.6 [95% CI 0.9 to 2.8]; p = 0.12). Similarly, there was no association between COI and chondral injury when adjusting for insurance, BMI, age, and race/ethnicity (OR 1.7 [95% CI 0.7 to 3.9]; p = 0.20). | As the COI score is independently associated with a delay between ACL injury and surgery as well as the incidence of meniscus tears at the time of surgery, this score can be useful in identifying patients and communities at risk for disparate care after ACL injury. |
Sarkisova 2019 [41] | NR | Average delay to appointment scheduled (business days) ACL injury: Private—9.42; Government—7.05 Ankle injury: Private—7.58; Government—9.95 Back injury: Private—7.13; Government—9.06 | Our study found there was a significantly lower rate of children with government-funded insurance that had access to postsurgical rehabilitation. |
Simon 2006 [42] | NR | Hispanic race/ethnicity was associated with lower rates of SIRVs across all insurance types. After controlling for demographic factors and insurance, Hispanic children were less likely to have an SIRV than white children (odds ratio, 0.7; 95% confidence interval, 0.6–0.9). | Sports and recreation are the leading causes of pediatric ED IRVs. Hispanic children, regardless of insurance status, had lower rates of SIRVs than white children, which helps explain the lower rate of nonfatal IRVs to EDs among Hispanic youth. |
Slover 2005 [43] | NR | Supracondylar humerus fractures - Black and Hispanic patients were more likely to receive closed reduction with internal fixation (percutaneous pinning) than white patients (p = 0.02). White patients were 9.3% less likely than Black patients and 5.1% less likely than Hispanic patients to receive closed reduction and casting of supracondylar humerus fractures, but they were more likely to receive either closed reduction without internal fixation or ORIF. Femoral shaft fractures - Patients with private insurance were 2.7% and 3.4% more likely to be treated with an external fixation device for a femoral shaft fracture than patients in the Medicaid and self-pay groups, respectively. Similarly, patients in the all other payer group were 6.6% to 7.3% more likely to receive this treatment for a femoral shaft fracture than the Medicaid and self-pay groups (p = 0.015). Forearm fractures - For pediatric patients admitted to the hospital, no significant differences existed in the treatment method chosen for forearm fractures across race, primary payer, or income groups. | This study did demonstrate statistically significant differences in the treatment of pediatric supracondylar humerus across racial groups, with Black and Hispanic patients being more likely to receive percutaneous pinning of these injuries than white. Private insurance patients were also more likely to have femoral shaft fractures treated with an external fixator device than patients with Medicaid or self-pay as their primary payer. |
Smith 2021 [45] | NR | Patients who underwent MAT also had 2.0 times higher odds of being women (95% CI, 1.2–3.3; p = 0.01) and 2.0 times higher odds of being privately insured (95% CI, 1.1–3.6; p = 0.02). MAT was performed most frequently in the northeast (4.9/1000 meniscal surgeries) and least often in the south (1.1/1000 meniscal surgeries) (p < 0.001). | In the United States, pediatric and adolescent patients who underwent MAT were older and more likely to be female and have private insurance than those undergoing meniscal repair or meniscectomy. MAT was only performed in 17 of 47 children’s hospitals that perform meniscal surgery. |
Disclaimer/Publisher’s Note: The statements, opinions and data contained in all publications are solely those of the individual author(s) and contributor(s) and not of MDPI and/or the editor(s). MDPI and/or the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to people or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content. |
© 2025 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
Share and Cite
Kutzer, K.M.; Kiwinda, L.V.; Yang, D.; Mitchell, J.K.; Luo, E.J.; Harman, E.J.; Hendren, S.; Bradley, K.E.; Lau, B.C. Insurance Payor Status and Outcomes in Pediatric Sports-Related Injuries: A Rapid Review. Clin. Pract. 2025, 15, 52. https://doi.org/10.3390/clinpract15030052
Kutzer KM, Kiwinda LV, Yang D, Mitchell JK, Luo EJ, Harman EJ, Hendren S, Bradley KE, Lau BC. Insurance Payor Status and Outcomes in Pediatric Sports-Related Injuries: A Rapid Review. Clinics and Practice. 2025; 15(3):52. https://doi.org/10.3390/clinpract15030052
Chicago/Turabian StyleKutzer, Katherine M., Lulla V. Kiwinda, Daniel Yang, John Kyle Mitchell, Emily J. Luo, Emily J. Harman, Stephanie Hendren, Kendall E. Bradley, and Brian C. Lau. 2025. "Insurance Payor Status and Outcomes in Pediatric Sports-Related Injuries: A Rapid Review" Clinics and Practice 15, no. 3: 52. https://doi.org/10.3390/clinpract15030052
APA StyleKutzer, K. M., Kiwinda, L. V., Yang, D., Mitchell, J. K., Luo, E. J., Harman, E. J., Hendren, S., Bradley, K. E., & Lau, B. C. (2025). Insurance Payor Status and Outcomes in Pediatric Sports-Related Injuries: A Rapid Review. Clinics and Practice, 15(3), 52. https://doi.org/10.3390/clinpract15030052