Background: A number of clinical practice guidelines (
CPGS) concerning breast cancer (
BCA) screening and management are available. Here, we review the strengths and weaknesses of
CPGS from various professional organizations and consensus groups with respect to their methodologic
[...] Read more.
Background: A number of clinical practice guidelines (
CPGS) concerning breast cancer (
BCA) screening and management are available. Here, we review the strengths and weaknesses of
CPGS from various professional organizations and consensus groups with respect to their methodologic quality, recommendations, and implementability.
Methods: Guidelines from four groups were reviewed with respect to two clinical scenarios: adjuvant ovarian function suppression (
OFS) in premenopausal women with early-stage estrogen receptor–positive
BCA, and use of sentinel lymph node biopsy (
SLNB) after neoadjuvant chemotherapy (
NAC) for locally advanced
BCA. Guidelines from the American Society of Clinical Oncology (
ASCO); Cancer Care Ontario’s Program in Evidence Based Care (
CCO’s
PEBC); the U.S. National Comprehensive Cancer Network (
NCCN); and the St. Gallen International Breast Cancer Consensus Conference were reviewed by two independent assessors. Guideline methodology and applicability were evaluated using the
AGREE II tool.
Results: The quality of the
CPGS was greatest for the guidelines developed by
ASCO and
CCO’s
PEBC. The
NCCN and St. Gallen guidelines were found to have lower scores for methodologic rigour. All guidelines scored poorly for applicability. The recommendations for
OFS were similar in three guidelines. Recommendations by the various organizations for the use of
SLNB after
NAC were contradictory.
Conclusions: Our review demonstrated that
CPGS can be heterogeneous in methodologic quality. Low-quality
CPG implementation strategies contribute to low uptake of, and adherence to,
BCA CPGS. Further research examining the barriers to recommendations—such as intrinsic guideline characteristics and the needs of end users—is required. The use of
BCA CPGS can improve the knowledge-to-practice gap and patient outcomes.
Full article