I have a love hate relationship with this show. I love football and I love documentaries, but I don't like this coach (season one and two coach) and I don't even like some of these players. As for those that I do like, I want to see them succeed. But that's not always the goal of a documentary anyway--to get you to like someone or something. A documentary brings the viewer information about a subject they didn't know before or were never even aware of.
I consider this show a documentary and not a "reality show" because it's not about false narratives or fake drama with a soft script. It's just documenting these young men as they try to make something of themselves in the wasteland of junior college. And junior college is a wasteland.
High school is where you get started. That's where you learn, grow, and display your skills for recruiters. A four-year university (preferably a D1 school) is where you're at the next best thing to the NFL and it's your best chance to get noticed by the NFL. JUCO is where you go when you've screwed up. Either you've screwed up in high school or you've screwed up at your four-year university. So, to see this no-man's-land of education and football on screen is fascinating.