In 2004, Fogelnest won a New York City A.I.R. Award for hosting the "Top 92 Worst Xmas Songs of All-Time" on the former WXRK where he worked as a DJ for many years before the station changed formats and became WFNY-FM.
Upon K-Rock's format switch, Fogelnest hosted a radio show on the new Free-FM with Jackie Clarke called Jake and Jackie. The show was a combination of pop culture discussion and radio sketch comedy. Fogelnest left the show for Sirius XM radio in 2006.
From 2006-2014, Fogelnest hosted mornings on Sirius XM's College rock/Indie rock channel, Sirius XMU. He was also heard afternoons on Sirius XM Alt Nation. Fogelnest exited Sirius XM in November 2014 to focus full-time on writing and producing for television.
